To be fair: If you are chaining ternary expressions, you deserve to suffer whatever pain the language happens to inflict upon you tenfold.
Programmer Humor
Post funny things about programming here! (Or just rant about your favourite programming language.)
Rules:
- Posts must be relevant to programming, programmers, or computer science.
- No NSFW content.
- Jokes must be in good taste. No hate speech, bigotry, etc.
I get hating on PHP is a meme, and the language certainly has faults, but I feel like it’s no more arbitrary than how JavaScript behaves. And just like JavaScript, if you follow modern standards and use a modern version, it’s a much better experience. The language is only as good as the programmer.
but I feel like it’s no more arbitrary than how JavaScript behave
This is not the flex you think it is.
I didn’t mean it as a flex. It was a commentary on how the most commonly used programming language in current days is just as flawed as the most commonly used programming language in the past (in web development). Bad programmers are going to write bad code, regardless of the language.
That's why JS gets hates on just as much as PHP, if not more so these days as JS is fuckin everywhere!
The fault is the programmer for not using a switch statement.
"php doesn't stop me from coding like a moron, therefore php sucks"
How about "php enables me to code like a moron", or even better, "php breaks common conventions and forces me to think about every little detail and special edge case, slowing me down if I don't want to accidentally 'code like a moron' "
Nested ternary operators emerge because of the lack of if/switch expressions (which is C fault), so they are "useful" (they shouldn't be). However, PHP is the only language that treats it as left associative. This has 2 problems:
- You are forced to use parenthesis. Some (insane) people might do: (cond1) ? "A" : (cond2) ? "B" : "C" And it makes sense. Its ugly af, but it makes sense. But PHP now forces you to use more parethesis. It's making you work more.
- It breaks convention. If you come from any other language and use ternary operators, you will get unexpected results. After hours of banging your head against the wall, you realize the problem. And now you have to learn a new edge case in the language, and what to do to actually use the language.
"But you shouldn't use ternary operators anyway! Use if/switch/polymorphic dispatch/goto/anything else"
True, but still, the feature is there, and its bad. The fact that there are other alternatives doesn't make the PHP ternary operator worse than other languages' ternary operator.
PHP works against you. That's the problem. The ternary operator is not a good example, since there are alternatives. But look at something so simple, so mundane like strpos.
If strpos doesn't find returns false
. Every other language returns -1. And if you then use this value elsewhere, PHP will cast it to 0 for you. Boom, your program is broken, and you have to stare at the screen for hours, looking for the error.
"BuT yOU sHoUlD AlwAyS cHEcK tHe rETurN eRRor!"
And even if that's true, if we all must check the return value, does PHP force you to do so? Like checked exceptions in Java? Or all the Option
& Result
in Rust? throws, throws, throws... unwrap, unwrap, unwrap... (Many) people hate those features
PHP works against you. And that's why its bad.
But if you code like a moron the code should still behave as expected. People who code like this deserve a special place in hell, next to languages that behave like that.
Ever wondered about the array_fill
function? It can be baffling. Try filling an array with a negative index:
array_fill(-5, 4, 'test');
Many languages would throw an error, but PHP? It’s perfectly fine with this and you get an array starting at index -5. It’s like PHP is the Wild West of array indexing!
Well, many languages are perfectly ok with negative array indexes.
But all of those languages are either statically typed ones where you declare the boundings with the array, or php.
Absolutely, many languages do allow negative indices. The intriguing part about PHP, though, is that its ‘arrays’ are actually ordered maps (or hash tables) under the hood. This structure allows for a broader range of keys, like our negative integers or even strings. It’s a unique design choice that sets PHP apart and allows for some really interesting usage patterns. Not your everyday array, right?
I've been working with PHP for two years now (not by choice) but I still sometimes forget the weird behaviours these not-arrays cause. Recently I was pushing/popping entries in a queue and it fucked the indexing. I had programmed it like I would any other sane language and it wasn't until I was stepping through the bug I realised I had forgotten about this.
I hate PHP for so many more reasons. It baffles me why anyone would think it was a good idea to design it this way. Thankfully my current job involves actively burning it down and preparing for its replacement.
You think that's bad, just wait until you hear what C does
This is not valid syntax as of 2020. PHP 8 fixed a lot of issue like this as well as a lot of function and variable type issues.
Also this was deprecated in PHP 7 (2015).
They deprecated nested ternaries?
Not nested but 'Unparenthesized'
Also per the error message here is it working:
PHP Fatal error: Unparenthesized a ? b : c ? d : e
is not supported. Use either (a ? b : c) ? d : e
or a ? b : (c ? d : e)
Hating on php is one of the reasons i left reddit. This is just people who don’t use php hating php for some reason. You can do dumb examples like this for any language. Low effort and funny for children.
Your feelings are valid. I wonder though, would you put up this level of defense for posts making fun of arbitrary parts of non PHP languages?
You are not your favorite language. And I find most criticisms of most languages to be very valid. I don't think the intent of OP is to insult all PHP programmers. It's okay to like a language that has problems. All languages do.
I'd wager prevalence is part of their problem. Jokes get tired after a while, but that doesn't always mean they stop.
PHP, like any language, has its problems, but it seems to get poked at a lot more often. But making the same joke over and over has been a problem long before reddit was a thing.
Hey, I hate php AND javascript, and I've worked in both of them. :P
I took this more as a light-hearted poke at a silly edge case. As someone who used to build static analysis software for various languages, including PHP. This gets a chuckle out of me as it takes me back to having to deal with these exact types of edge cases.
Sure, it's counterintuitive, but so is not bracketing things in ternary operations.
that makes so much fucking sense
[This comment has been deleted by an automated system]
Ah, I understand now. The expression is evaluated like this:
$a == 1 ? "one" : $a == 2 ? "two" : $a == 3 ? "three" : "other"
$a == 2 ? "two" : $a == 3 ? "three" : "other"
"two" ? "three" : "other"
"three"
Halp. I don’t understand how it went from step 2 to step 3.
It's cause PHP associates the if-then-else pair only with its immediate "else" option, not with the entirety of the line.
Let's go by parts.
$a == 1 ? "one" : $a == 2 ? "two" : $a == 3 ? "three" : "other"
Is $a equal to 1? If so, we're "set" to the value on the left, which is "one"
, if not then we're set to the value on the right, which is $a == 2
. $a is not equal to 1, so we're set to the right value, $a == 2
.
This replaces the relevant part, $a == 1 ? "one" : $a == 2
, with $a == 2
. So we're left with:
$a == 2 ? "two" : $a == 3 ? "three" : "other"
Next, is $a equal to 2? If so, we're set to "two"
, if not we're set to $a == 3
. The comparison is true, so we're set to the value on the left, "two"
. The relevant part here is $a == 2 ? "two" : $a == 3
only, so it replaces it with "two"
cause again, PHP is only associating with its immediate pair. So now we're left with:
"two" ? "three" : "other"
Finally, is "two"
truthy? If so, we're set to "three"
, if not we're set to "other"
. Since "two"
is truthy we're then left with "three"
.
It's super confusing for sure.
Thank you for the great explanation, and for teaching me the word "truthy."
Thanks! I never worked with PHP but I understand your explanation. Making memes about languages is also about learning
Thank you!
Wat.
Ah, I understand now. The expression is evaluated like this:
$a == 1 ? "one" : $a == 2 ? "two" : $a == 3 ? "three" : "other"
$a == 2 ? "two" : $a == 3 ? "three" : "other"
"two" ? "three" : "other"
"three"
If you think PHP is weird, go look up ZZT-OOP, the scripting language from Tim Sweeney's first game.
(No, a scripting language for game characters doesn't need integers. If you need to count, you can do that by moving blocks around on the game board. It's halfway between LOGO and Minecraft.)
Finally got it...
$a == 1 ? "one" : ( ( $a == 2 ? "two" : $a == 3 ) ? "three" : "other" )
Now do CGI.
Please. I worked with it for five years and I still don't understand it.
!programmeranimemes@lemmy.world
Why
To quote the guy who invented PHP:
"I don't know how to stop it, there was never any intent to write a programming language [...] I have absolutely no idea how to write a programming language, I just kept adding the next logical step on the way."