Reddit Migration

37 readers
2 users here now

### About Community Tracking and helping #redditmigration to Kbin and the Fediverse. Say hello to the decentralized and open future. To see latest reeddit blackout info, see here: https://reddark.untone.uk/

founded 1 year ago
751
 
 

Is there a kbin API to allow posts? I had a look quickly at the docs and could only see get requests.

I ask this, as reddit can be ‘crawled’ simply by adding .json to the end of a user or sub (https://www.reddit.com/r/voidlinux.json for example). It should be possible to copy vast swaths of reddit over to kbin to build some history here, as well as potentially sync the data from reddit over to keep us from FOMO.

#RedditMigration

752
 
 

I read somewhere in the threadiverse people asking for some equivalent of sport streaming subreddit.

That's one case where i'm afraid fediverse won't work, the sharing of not so legal stuff.

If a song, or a movie, or a stream, is posted on youtube or instagram, we don't care, google will most likely not remove it, and no judge will close youtube for that 🙂

Do that on one of our fediverse, small, no profit, no ads, instances, whether is lemmy, kbin, owncast, peertube.
They will sue our ass

The most successful fediverse use cases so far are proven to be text discussions and our very own pictures.

@RedditMigration
@oblomov @tchambers

753
 
 

I keep looking back at what's happening with Reddit, not because I want to go back, but just morbid curiosity on if they will ever get their head out of their ass. The more I see, the more I feel the move to kbin was the right move. Removing mods, falsifying information, lying, deception, and just not listening to the community. Not only that, just looking at the content post blackout and it isn't the same anymore.

#RedditMigration

754
 
 
755
 
 

i have two subreddits, one of them has videos for content and the other one is more based around discussion about the links that get posted, so i realise i might have to do two different processes, and i'm not getting paid sooo ..

i have two priorities. one is to transfer as much content as possible. the other is to take as little effort as possible to do so. i'm not sure which one is higher, but considering that it's saturday night right now the second one is still really important because i'v got a bottle of rum and the sound system is turned on and imma groovin' and don't wanna stop

756
 
 

After weeks of burning through users’ goodwill, Reddit is facing a moderator strike and an exodus of its most important users. It’s the latest example of a social media site making a critical mistake: users aren’t there for the services, they’re there for the community.

757
 
 

A call-to-action for Reddit users to reclaim their digital autonomy

758
 
 
759
 
 

As we've seen in the past week, a large amount of users don't care why subreddits are blacked out or why, they just want their timeline back to normal.

It's understandable, most users just want something to "work" when they want to use it and don't give any thought to what that means. We've already seen mods be replaced, deleted histories come back to life, whatever it takes for Reddit to make it seem "normal" so they don't lose users. Heck, even some of those who have left Reddit may be tempted to go back and read / comment on things they see there, because Reddit obviously isn't going to die overnight. So how do we continue the fight in the current environment Reddit has put us in while still getting a message across the users?

My thought is the following, and I'm putting it here because I think recent migrants are/were more than semi-casual reddittors, and it's clear we've got some development talent out there. I'm a developer as well but I'm looking for:

  1. Thoughts on the approach I'm suggesting
  2. Thoughts on implementation / usage
  3. Overall feelings regarding this in general

The idea

Make browser plugin(s) and / or a website that [knowingly to the user] intercept comment post requests for reddit and stores the post content elsewhere. In its place, all that is submitted to reddit is a link to a website (where people can click to view users intended comment text) along with a blurb about "reddit owning your comment data".

The browser plugin can also find these comments within posts and automatically query and get the raw text and replace it within a reddit page to make viewing these posts easier for everyone.

The idea being that the more users install the extension to easily read these posts, the more users obfuscate their posts so that other users also need the extension to more easily read comments on reddit.

Not only does this protect user data from being owned by Reddit, it makes it so Google searches will not find content on reddit.

Example post before and after:

(Unencrypted, or viewed with the browser extension installed)

(The posted content stored in reddit)

There's my idea. A few thoughts / notes:

  • Is this possible? I haven't checked out manifest V3 or made a browser extension in a long time, but with what RES already does I assume this would be doable.
  • Is it worth it? Will enough people want to read comments stored in this manner to "join the fight"? Who knows
  • Should it store the comment data elsewhere, or just store encrypted text in the reddit comment itself?

Anyway. I know we've got a lot of ex-redditors here, a lot of very talented developers, and a fight still going on that deserves a next step from the users.

Open to any and all thoughts from. This is just a musing on a potential next step - I haven't decided if I'm going to start developing anything yet.

760
 
 

!streetwear@lemmy.world /c/streetwear@lemmy.world https://lemmy.world/c/streetwear

761
 
 

I’m having trouble with the difference between threads and microblogs/posts. I keep thinking in terms of Reddit. I know magazines would be what ‘subreddits’ are. Are threads what we see on the front page of a subreddit and but then what are posts? I read the FAQs but still confused.

Anyone able to shed some light? TY!

#RedditMigration

762
 
 

Ok, maybe I’m doing something wrong, and I might have language wrong here, so correct me if I’m way off the mark.

But I can’t figure out how to tell if I’m about to go to a comment section of a posy that’s from a kbin magazine or some other group’s magazine equivalent.

My understanding, as someone using the mobile site:

  • I have an account on kbin.social
  • Kbin.social is an instance of. . . Something…
  • kbin.social is federated with other. . . instances(?) like lemmy.world and sh.itjust.works.
  • because of this, we who have accounts on kbin.social can interact with posts from communities/magazines/whatever their equivalent is from Instances(?) that kbin has federated with.
  • the home page on kbin.social is the equivalent of Reddit’s r/all
  • the home page on kbin.social will show posts from other instances we’re federated with
  • presumably there is some way to tell whether the post we’re clicking on is from a community on kbin.social, or a community on a different instance
  • with some posts it’s easy, because there’ll be a little (lemmy.world) or similar under the title
  • some posts, however, have (kbin.social), and then when I click to go to the comment section, it turns out it’s from sh.itjust.works
  • when you click on a post originally from another instance, it shows a warning at the top of the page, that it may be incomplete. The name of the instance is only shown at the bottom of the page, not in the post information.

My questions:

  1. is my language right?
  2. How can I tell, before clicking on a post, what instance it’s from?
  3. assuming that both kbin.social and lemmy.world both have a “books” magazine/community/etc., how can I tell if the post on my home page from “books” is from kbin or lemmy?
  4. how do I see a feed of only my subscribed magazines?

Thanks!

763
 
 

Prior to the protest reddit was in full support of the protest. Most polls on subs supported a shutdown. Now, seemingly every community cant understand why the protest was needed and they're calling it a mod power trip. There is a 3rd possibility. This is an unfounded conspiracy but reddit themselves could be manipulating scores.

See the NFL thread if you don't mind sending traffic

https://reddit.com/r/nfl/comments/14b11kh/were_just_here_so_we_dont_get_fined/

764
 
 

Obligatory just came from reddit post :P So heres a bad photoshop I did.

#RedditMigration

765
 
 

“The blackouts are not representative of the greater Reddit community.”

766
 
 

Attached: 1 image Well, at least Reddit has admitted their "we're not trying to be like Twitter/Elon" stuff was false

767
 
 

Archive Link: https://archive.is/lEePE

The top mod of r/piracy has been removed by the admins and the subreddit will reopen.

768
 
 

While most of the people here upset and rightfully so, we have got to move past the angst to actually build this place out.

We have to recreate the environment and communities we've created on on Reddit here, so that people don't feel like they're missing out being on kbin.

That way, the next time Spez goes full Elon, we already have everything in place to make the jump.

I help run r/MMA on Reddit. We aggregate news as well as bringing on MMA figures for AMAs.

We, like many other magazines here, will need a way to quickly aggregate breaking news onto our magazine, and the easiest way to do that is going to be through a bot that mirrors submissions to our subreddit.

At least for the mags that rely on breaking news, if we implement this at scale, the end user wont be missing much by migrating over here if they get all the same great breaking news.

Do we have any bot builders in the house who could take this on as a project?

We would be leveraging Reddit's own userbase at scale to better kbin, and eventually beat them in the long run. That's the biggest L we could ever deal them.

EDIT: WASN'T SURE THIS WAS GONNA BLOW UP. IVE MADE https://kbin.social/m/BotIt FOR DEVELOPMENT. IF YOU'RE INTERESTED AND CAN HELP OR JUST WANT TO FOLLOW THE PROJECT, COME ON OVER. THANKS.

769
 
 

Steve Huffman said in an interview that Elon Musk's cost-cutting at Twitter was inspiring and that the two have chatted "a handful of times."

770
 
 

You can tell the landscape is seriously shifting at reddit because of the drastic change in user opinion just in the last week. Subreddits that were overwhelmingly in favor of the blackout last week have suddenly shifted to seem drastically against it. Is this a sign anyone actually changed their minds? No, it's just the opposite: most of us dissenters packed up our shit and left.

I'm disappointed in some of the specific game subs I've been a part of staying open in the name of "but the community and resources are all established here" (#Rimworld) or those who aren't even talking about it (#GenshinImpact, #TearsOfThemis). I'd really like to create some of these over here to get the ball rolling, but I know moderation is not a task to be underestimated; I KNOW I don't really have a suitable personality for it, plus I have my hands full with other projects.

#RedditMigration

771
 
 

Reddit can restore your deleted posts. However, if people flood them with GDPR / CCPA delete requests, they may become liable for lawsuits if they don't comply.

It sounds like their current policy is to not delete your posts even when deleting your account, but there may be grounds for legal action here.

772
 
 

I've been thinking about this today..

If there's a divide among people who want to still use Reddit and others who want to try out the Fediverse (Kbin, Lemmy, etc), I believe it may be a good idea if we had a bot that could mimic at least the posts (and maybe later even the comments) on subreddits that people are missing out here in the Fediverse. This can at least help populate the emptier communities that are here on the Fediverse and incentivize people to remain here without the fear of FOMO (myself included).

Is there any existing solution that could provide the necessary functionality? How feasible would this be if someone would start working on this now, considering the Reddit API changes?

773
 
 

If you're like me, you have a habit of typing reddit.com whenever you have some time to kill at a computer.

Kicking habits takes time, so as you develop a new habit of typing kbin.social (or lemmy.world or whatever the case may be), consider a browser extension that blocks or redirects traffic from reddit to your desired new social media destination.

For Firefox, I have found these to be helpful over the last week:

774
 
 

I know Spaz is the adam mod but still under our rules, he should never be allowed to post anything in the website ever again. He broke the number 1 rule in Reddit and many subreddits for mods. He can post whatever he likes in his official place but never in other subreddits. Everyone knows how annoying automod can become, it should be possible to do it or enough to annoyed him.

775
 
 

Is there a way to sort threads by top comments? 'Hot' doesn't seem to work for me.

#RedditMigration

view more: ‹ prev next ›