Dutch Sedition

5 readers
56 users here now

Opruiing is the Dutch word for Sedition, and is described in Article 131 of the Dutch criminal code. It refers to any incitement towards criminal activity and is punishable by up to 5 years imprisonment.

This community exists to spread factual information about Article 131, and to identify violations of Article 131 on lemmy.world. Admins and mods are invited to use this community as a resource to ensure this website remains compliant with Dutch law. The reasoning for using a community instead of the report system is that opruiing is a complex issue and many mods may dismiss reports of opruiing without understanding the legal issues at play, which would prevent admins from seeing the reports.

It is also hoped that documenting the reach of Dutch law will lead to increased awareness on the part of Lemmy users of the difficulties of running a server under Dutch jurisdiction. opruiing is perfectly legal and may even be considered a moral good in other countries, such as the United States, which has a constitutional amendment supporting the right of citizens to rebel. Citizens of other countries may wish to move their opruiing to other Lemmy servers where such speech is legal.

Rule 1: No opruiing - This community is for documenting opruiing, not doing it ourselves. Do not incite criminal behaviour in posts or comments.

Rule 2: No brigading - Don't go to linked posts and start an argument about opruiing. Keep the discussion of criminality in this community.

Rule 3: Dutch instances only - It's no use pointing out opruiing on lemmy.ml or lemmy.nz or anywhere that isn't hosted in the Netherlands. They have different laws and opruiing doesn't apply, even if similar sedition laws exist.

founded 1 day ago
1
 
 

https://lemmy.nz/post/18068554/12968584

Under article 131 of the Dutch criminal code, which governs lemmy.world, inciting crimes is considered sedition and is illegal. These comments appear to advocate for a second CEO shooting, as "arrested it at a McDonalds" is a reference to Luigi Mangione. Mangione claims that the evidence was planted on him by the police, and this claim is consistent with the methods employed by the actual CEO shooter. Nonetheless, Luigi has become the face of the CEO shooting in the public eye. The third comment here by @MelodiousFunk@slrpnk.net clearly calls for a second CEO shooter to act, and is therefore inciting murder. Under Dutch law, this is sedition, and cannot legally be allowed on lemmy.world.

2
 
 

https://lemmy.nz/post/18051789/12963981

Under Article 131 of the Dutch Criminal Code, which governs lemmy.world, inciting others to commit a crime is sedition. This comment by @IDKWhatUsernametoPutHereLolol@lemmy.dbzer0.com clearly incites others to shoplift from corporate chain stores, which is considered sedition. This isn't allowed on lemmy.world because it's illegal in the country where the servers are hosted.

3
 
 

https://lemmy.ml/comment/15949184

In North Korea, hot dogs are illegal. Therefore, inciting North Koreans to cook and eat hot dogs is considered sedition under Dutch law. @NutWrench@lemmy.ml's comment about delicious treason dogs is a joke and is unlikely to be seen by any North Koreans. But if it was accompanied by an intent to incite North Koreans to eat hot dogs, then the comment is illegal under the Dutch laws that govern lemmy.world.

4
 
 

https://lemmy.world/comment/14355949

Under article 131 of the Dutch Criminal Code, the second comment here (and maybe the first) is considered sedition, as it advocates for illegal assassinations of world leaders. While Adolf Hitler is dead, the first comment could maybe be construed as intending to incite additional assassination attempts on Donald Trump. The second comment by @FelixCress@lemmy.world unequivocably incites assassination of current world leaders.

Lemmy.world is bound to Dutch law, and therefore cannot host these comments. They would have been legal to post on other instances.