63
submitted 1 year ago by cm0002@lemmy.world to c/technology@lemmy.zip
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] Tabula_stercore@lemmy.world 3 points 1 year ago

From Signal's terms and conditions

Other instances where Signal may need to share your data

To meet any applicable law, regulation, legal process or enforceable governmental request.

If i understand correctly, their servers are in the usa. So the usa government has the same level of access as compared to whatsapp? It's non profit now, but so was openai...

WhatsApp is definitely taking a step in the wrong direction. However, switching to another app is difficult, it's hard to get people ingrained in an ecosystem switch once let alone twice....

[-] BrikoX@lemmy.zip 8 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago)

Any company operating in any country has to comply with their laws. The difference is that Signal has almost no data to share to comply. Message content and metadata is encrypted so they have no access to it. Your phone number is the only identifier they have and would be obligated by law to share.

[-] blah3166@piefed.social 3 points 1 year ago

their servers are in the usa.

Their "home office" is in the US. That doesn't necessarily mean they don't have servers distributed globally.

So the usa government has the same level of access as compared to whatsapp?

No, the US government does not have the same level of access to Signal as they do with Whatsapp. The only reason the US has so much access to Whatsapp is because Whatsapp only bothered to implement End-to-end encryption (E2EE). Unfortunately, in 2205, E2EE is the bare minimum. E2EE via the Signal protocol has been a "solved issue" since 2013 and Whatsapp implemented it 3 years later (great!) but they have not improved privacy since. Whatsapp still collects a metric-fuck-ton of metadata like:

  • Who you communicate with
  • When you communicate
  • How long your calls last
  • The frequency of communication
  • When you're "active" on the platform
  • Group memberships and group titles
  • Your profile information (this is E2EE on Signal)
  • Your contacts get uploaded in a way that's visible to Whatsapp. Signal does contact discovery in a privacy preserving way.

Then they correlate this data with everything else they have about you to "fill in the gaps". Signal doesn't collect any metadata.

It's non profit now, but so was openai...

The difference here is there's nothing of value for Signal to "sell" since they don't collect metadata and have engineered it to work without being able to see anything. The Signal server and client are already open source, there's no "secret sauce". Lastly, because they collect zero data they can't even sell it for ad-serving purposes. Who would buy Signal?

switching to another app is difficult, it's hard to get people ingrained in an ecosystem switch once let alone twice

100% agree. The best way I've found is to drop the offending platform (whatsapp) and move to Signal. Let others know you accept text/SMS or Signal messages. Over the years the people on Signal (at least in my group) has steadily grown.

I would like to close by saying that Signal is not shy about complying with the law, they will not go to prison for anyone's potential crimes. That said, they publish the data they provide when compelled by law and the only data they collect is the day + time you signed up with their service and the last day (not time) one of your clients pinged their servers, source: https://signal.org/bigbrother/

this post was submitted on 28 Jun 2025
63 points (98.5% liked)

Technology

7349 readers
33 users here now

News community around technology, social media platforms, information technology and governmental policy surrounding it.

What doesn't fit here?

The core of the story has to be technology focused.


Post guidelines

Title formatPost title should mirror the news source title. If you don't like the title of article, look for an alternative source instead of editorializing it.
URL formatPost URL should be the original link to the article (even if paywalled) and archived copies left in the body. It allows avoiding duplicate posts when cross-posting.
[Opinion] prefixOpinion (op-ed) articles must use [Opinion] prefix before the title. Opinion articles refer to articles that their publisher doesn't explictly endorse.
Country prefixCountry prefix can be added to the title with a separator (|, :, etc.) if the news is from a local publisher who doesn't clearly mention the country.


Rules

1. English onlyTitle and associated content has to be in English.
2. Use original linkPost URL should be the original link to the article (even if paywalled) and archived copies left in the body. It allows avoiding duplicate posts when cross-posting.
3. Respectful communicationAll communication has to be respectful of differing opinions, viewpoints, and experiences.
4. InclusivityEveryone is welcome here regardless of age, body size, visible or invisible disability, ethnicity, sex characteristics, gender identity and expression, education, socio-economic status, nationality, personal appearance, race, caste, color, religion, or sexual identity and orientation.
5. Ad hominem attacksAny kind of personal attacks are expressly forbidden. If you can't argue your position without attacking a person's character, you already lost the argument.
6. Off-topic tangentsStay on topic. Keep it relevant.
7. Instance rules may applyIf something is not covered by community rules, but are against lemmy.zip instance rules, they will be enforced.


Companion communities

!globalnews@lemmy.zip
!interestingshare@lemmy.zip


Icon attribution | Banner attribution


If someone is interested in moderating this community, message @brikox@lemmy.zip.

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS