23
Legal consequences of using I2P? (feddit.org)
submitted 4 months ago by sp3ctre@feddit.org to c/i2p@lemmy.world
5 comments fedilink hide all child comments

Hey guys,

I am running an I2Pd-Node on my raspberry pi somewhere in Germany and I am loving it so far.

About the ethical implications I am at peace with me, because I know, that it's not possible to allow good things without allowing the bad things too.

Sometimes I am a little bit concerned about, what a paranoid government could do. Technically - I don't know what I am forwarding. And since we're not talking about providing an exit-node (to clear-net) like we usually do with Tor, the risk should be greatly reduced as well.

As far as I know, theoretically this scenario could be possible: A large marketplace for illegal stuff appears within the I2P-Network. Law enforcement connects to it and tries to identify the "hops" between them and the marketplace (one by one) and my node is one of it. I know how crazy this sounds. Not very likely, but not impossible as well.

How do you think about this? Are there any recommended precautions you could take to prove you're not the criminal, if LE surprisingly knocks at your door?

~sp3ctre

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] marxismtomorrow@lemmy.today 6 points 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago)

I2P is an alternative encrypted routing system. Legally and technically not much different than the normal internet.

If:

Nefarious Actor -> Router -> <{internet router}> <{internet router}> <{internet router}> <{internet router}> <{internet router}> -> Router -> Nefarious Webserver

is a routing chain wherein each <{internet router}> is legally protected because it is indiscriminately acting to forward traffic regardless of nefarious activity, then:

Nefarious Actor -> router -> <{i2p router}> <{internet router}> <{i2p router}> <{internet router}> <{i2p router}> <{internet router}> <{i2p router}> -> Router -> nefarious website

Would be equally protected. You are not doing anything different, you are simply acting as an additional router, indiscriminately passing traffic along.

In the US, according to recent supreme court cases, this is constitutionally and legally protected - you are providing an intermediary service for general use and thus are protected the same way an internet carrier is. Most EU countries have something similar, and the EU has special protections for smaller service providers under the DSA. Since you are closest to an ISP under German law, just a very, very, very small one; you should be legally protected simply because you are not actively participating in nefarious activity, just users of your service might be.

Vaguely based on:

https://freedomhouse.org/country/germany/freedom-net/2024

https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_urhdag/index.html

https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/policies/digital-services-act

https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/25pdf/24-171_bq7d.pdf

this post was submitted on 13 Apr 2026
23 points (100.0% liked)

The Invisible Internet Project

1994 readers
1 users here now

I2P Community Edition

This isn't the official I2P channel, if you want go there then you can find it in the links below.

Rules

"Don't be a dick" - Wil Wheaton

General

Media:

File Hosting and Pastebins

Torrents

Social Networks and Microblogging

Exploring I2P

I2P Name Registries

Search engines

IRC

Irc2P comes pre-configured with I2P. To connect with other networks, please follow this tutorial.

Syndie

An open source system for operating distributed forums in anonymous networks

Inproxies

You can use inproxies to surf the I2P network without having to have an I2P router.

Follow us on Twitter

founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
CAVOK@lemmy.world
idki2p@lemmy.one