If a nation reaches the point where millions of its citizens no longer trust the media, elections, courts, universities, police, science, or even each other, is it still one country or just 330 million people sharing the same borders?
We have pro AI vs anti AI
We have free speech vs police speech
We have pro 2A vs gun control
We have white supremacy vs multi-racial coalitions that can’t even agree on LGBT issues.
How are we as a society supposed to create standards to follow like in the past, when so many issues sharply divide us? One side has to win these elections, and one side is gonna go for it and implement their agenda that MILLIONS disagree with. Is that still a democracy? If Americans no longer believe the system is legitimate unless their side wins, has democracy already begun to fail?
Nothing is ever black or white. The US historically had and continues to have democratic elements in its system of government, although people are correct that it has always fallen well short of fully democratic. That said, experts on democracy have all documented a dramatic decline in the health and functioning of those democratic institutions in recent years. Some experts have described it as the largest and most rapid decline ever documented in modern times. But it's still not as authoritarian as many other nations. Elections remain largely free and are typically executed according to the law, despite bias in the way they operate. Free press continues to exist despite some pressures and consolidation among larger outlets.
Personally I think the only solution to this deterioration beyond continued struggle and education is a localist movement where political power is returned to lower levels of government. This is the only way to preserve democracy when the will of the populace has diverged so dramatically. But no major political factions seem to favor this approach currently.