336

Hello,

I made beatthecouch.com in July and it's basically a game where you try to beat the S&P 500 and buy/sell when you want. Your opponent is a couch. It buys on day one and never sells.

Now over 100K+ games later, the hypothesis stands: it's not wise to try to trade and time the market. Here's the original data from the actual games itself.

Source: the game's own database, every completed game Jul 12 to Aug 28. Tool: Python and matplotlib. Market data: S&P 500 daily total returns 1928 to 2019.

thanks!

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] LodeMike@lemmy.today 35 points 1 day ago

Saying that a near century long period is a bad sample is a little obtuse IMO

[-] UnderpantsWeevil@lemmy.world 16 points 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago)

A "near" century that conspicuously omits the Roaring Twenties leading into the worst market crash in history and the COVID crash at the end.

As a counterexample, if you consider the Nikkie's historical run - from it's inception in 1950 to the 2019 benchmarks, the slog from the 1989 downturn to 2019 produces a negative ROI, about −1.65% annualized in yen. The Nikkei closed 1989 at 38,915.87 and 2019 at 23,656.62.

Any Beat the Couch gambit during this period rewards people for staying in cash.

Of course... since 2019, the Nikkei has seen a whooping 17% annualized return, skyrocketing to 66,405.56

The S&P, by comparison, only grew 13% annually.

So if you're playing "Beat the Couch" with the Nikkei as an option, you can win by holding that over the S&P.

But the real TL;DR; of it is that past performance isn't an indication of future success. You can't invest in the historical market. You have to play the market that exists today, without knowing in advance what the future return will be.

[-] tyranny@crazypeople.online 3 points 1 day ago

thanks for this write-up! i still feel i don't particularly understand, but i enjoyed reading it!

this post was submitted on 29 Aug 2026
336 points (94.9% liked)

Data is Beautiful

8259 readers
494 users here now

A place to share and discuss visual representations of data: Graphs, charts, maps, etc.

DataIsBeautiful is for visualizations that effectively convey information. Aesthetics are an important part of information visualization, but pretty pictures are not the sole aim of this subreddit.

A place to share and discuss visual representations of data: Graphs, charts, maps, etc.

  A post must be (or contain) a qualifying data visualization.

  Directly link to the original source article of the visualization
    Original source article doesn't mean the original source image. Link to the full page of the source article as a link-type submission.
    If you made the visualization yourself, tag it as [OC]

  [OC] posts must state the data source(s) and tool(s) used in the first top-level comment on their submission.

  DO NOT claim "[OC]" for diagrams that are not yours.

  All diagrams must have at least one computer generated element.

  No reposts of popular posts within 1 month.

  Post titles must describe the data plainly without using sensationalized headlines. Clickbait posts will be removed.

  Posts involving American Politics, or contentious topics in American media, are permissible only on Thursdays (ET).

  Posts involving Personal Data are permissible only on Mondays (ET).

Please read through our FAQ if you are new to posting on DataIsBeautiful. Commenting Rules

Don't be intentionally rude, ever.

Comments should be constructive and related to the visual presented. Special attention is given to root-level comments.

Short comments and low effort replies are automatically removed.

Hate Speech and dogwhistling are not tolerated and will result in an immediate ban.

Personal attacks and rabble-rousing will be removed.

Moderators reserve discretion when issuing bans for inappropriate comments. Bans are also subject to you forfeiting all of your comments in this community.

Originally r/DataisBeautiful

Please Enjoy our Partner Community:

!askhistorians@lemmy.world

founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS