183
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 23 Sep 2026
183 points (91.8% liked)
Fuck AI
8865 readers
1221 users here now
"We did it, Patrick! We made a technological breakthrough!"
A place for all those who loathe AI to discuss things, post articles, and ridicule the AI hype. Proud supporter of working people. And proud booer of SXSW 2024.
AI, in this case, refers to LLMs, GPT technology, and anything listed as "AI" meant to increase market valuations.
Rules:
- Relevant posts only.
- No bigotry.
- No misinformation.
- No NSFW/NSFL content without being labeled NSFW or being in an appropriately-labeled spoiler tag.
- This isn't a place to talk about the cons and (supposed) pros of AI for different use cases. This is /c/fuck_ai .
- Especially no AI advocacy.
- No AI-generated content. If you want to post examples of AI failing hillariously, there are other communities for that like !ArtificialIgnorance@lemmy.ca .
- Venting is part of the purpose of this community, but don't aim frustration or accusations at other users.
- These rules are a living document that may change in the future.
You can help the mod team by making your reports detailed.
Effective reports:
- "The third image is a well-known anti-semitic trope"
- "Claiming that 'agentic AI' can outperform humans at all jobs is misinformation"
Less effective reports:
- "Breaks rules"
- "Misinformation"
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
You and I both want people to learn. You and I both see AI as an obstacle to learning. We just see things slightly differently.
I actually think this is not the main reason AI is awful for learning. The gravest problem, in my opinion, is the illusion of competence or the illusion of learning that it brings. This phenomenon is very well documented in the learning literature, well before LLMs were a thing. But LLMs amplify it.
Just take a look at PISA results. Students do poorly because they use LLMs and they never properly understood the content.
However, the education literature also paints a clear picture: after someone learns the basics, they're ready for other kinds of activities. In fact, if someone already understood thing and yet they still go over the same thing over and over, they stop learning. This is called the expertise reversal effect. So the alternative is to move on to other stuff.
I'm not arguing for having AI in the classroom. I'm just thinking of the implications of a well-researched theory: cognitive load theory. From that point of view, students that already learned the basics can then look at LLM slop and see its deficiencies. They can now plan an activity with an LLM and see how it nails some stuff and falls apart in other stuff. In that case, and only in that case, LLMs can improve learning in the same way that looking at your friend's essays can improve yours.
But, again, I'm not arguing for AI in the classroom. I think the world would be better off with a blanket AI ban in education. I think this is similar to how nicotine actually has some positive effects, but the bad outweighs the good by so much that it's much better to ban it.
Maybe.
I guess here I ask: what's the goal? What do we want more of? What do we want less of?
If our only policy is "out wiki should be incomprehensible to most*", I'm not sure we'll have more people in the world who understand the wiki. If, instead, we think "our wiki should be as accessible as possible", then we may find ways of teaching people.
i never said that, maybe i worded it poorly. What I'm saying is that simplifying a wiki article is detrimental to learning because it paints a wrong image. If i get a slop answer to a question about a wiki article I'm effectively avoiding the learning process that'd lead to me being more capable to maintain my system more effectively, not to mention that it teaches me to seek answers instead of taking the quick, risky and immoral shortcut. Sure, i guess AI can make it easier to understand, but these hobbyist pieces of software are meant to be used carefully by people who are willing to spend time to use them. If you don't want to read the wiki, It's okay, use something else, but using AI will eventually lead to issues.
As for the rest of what you said (my bad if i misunderstood), i think that if the only useful use of AI in education comes AFTER learning the basics, it is essentially just useless, since if you manage to know the basics you are clearly able to go further