53
Lula’s Digital Army Model Spreads to France, Spain and Argentina
(clashreport.com)
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 30 Oct 2026
53 points (100.0% liked)
World News
42051 readers
329 users here now
News from around the world!
Rules:
-
Please only post links to actual news sources, no tabloid sites, etc
-
No NSFW content
-
No hate speech, bigotry, propaganda, etc
founded 7 years ago
MODERATORS
When Bolsonaro did it last election it was treated as a crime, but when Lula does its ok. Leftists should not agree to this kind of thing just because it was done by the left
You do realize Bolsonaro tried to do a coup, right?
Lula's camp had to fight against the media platform owners, who bent over backwards to help Bolsonaro. If the media (including social media) has it's thumbs on the scale in your opponent's favor, and you don't organize against it you will lose. Of course, either way it is a kind of manipulation, but I prefer the kind of manipulation that requires hundreds of thousands of real people to take part, rather than a few oligarchs.
Centrista de merda
Xingar não é argumento. Se discorda apresenta por que
bolsonaro paid corporations for automated mass messaging, this is more like an ar game with the members of a massive group. it's different because one is organic and the other one is a synthetic endeavour of the international bourgeoisie.
lula is not the left, tho, and if this model spreads to argentina for example to promote peronism it's the same shit. of course i rather have them than gringo mc gringus fascist maximus as the president but it's not that much better. it's still reformist bullshit.
I dont think they are all that different. Lula also paid corporations to do his campaing.
Besides, even if this differnce existed, it wouldnt be suficient to say one is legit and the other isnt
you could've just left it at 'I don't think' clearly no qualifier is required
Not really bending what i think is right or wrong to put a pro imperialist left in good light, even if they are against Bolsonaro
go read up on the concept of false equivalence
If you could point out why the laws should be arbitrary it would be more useful
Nobody said laws should be arbitrary, and plenty of people in this very thread already addressed your bullshit in great detail.
the difference is that one paid for bot farms while the other one did political praxis. the right doesn't have actual support from people on the street, they need to invent reality.
If you belive that what Janones did is praxis and not paid, thats on you
i'm not saying there wasn't money involved, but if you think a bot farm which is essentially not people is the same as people doing dumb missions on social media is the same thats on you.
Our enemy's shameful bot farm
Our online blessed army
Do you not believe organizers should be paid?
Explain your question better, please
It sounds like you're essentially saying that paying organizers is the same as running bot farms.
This seems to imply that you don't believe organizers should be paid.
... or you don't believe organizers are human, but that's probably not what you meant.
My point is both of them did the same, both paid people and bots, but it was treated as a problem when Bolsonaro did, but was ok when Lula did
But they didn't do the same, Lula didn't run bot farms. That's qualitatively different than paying organizers.
You're the one equivocating between running bot farms and paying organizers, so I'll ask again: do you not believe organizers should be paid? It's a simple question, don't know why you won't answer.
If lula did what he did without bots the msn is jesus christ himself, because it would be a miracle. Im not a religious person, so thats a no for me.
If you say organizer as a political activist, if they are not paid for their work then mostly only people who can get paid without working could be a political activist. Sounds like nonsense
Professional organizers are people who get paid for their political work. Activists are just volunteers.
And there was no "miracle" involved, just people recognizing they needed to act. This was a coordinated effort by a smaller team of professional (paid) organizers and a much larger mass of activists (unpaid). There's no proof bots were involved.
You're just judging based on vibes.
Donroe Doctrine
Wait, what's the problem with organizing people like this?
None, but when bolsonaro did, it was treated as if that was a problem