20
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 06 Nov 2026
20 points (100.0% liked)
Scotland
864 readers
37 users here now
Fàilte gu Alba!
Mon in tae Scotland!
Welcome to Scotland!
Quick rules:
- dinnae be a cunt
- posts should relate tae Scotland
- one post per topic please
Have at it, and haste ye back
Related communities
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
Scotland has an abundance of renewable energy and empty space though, we have so much that the grid often is overcapacity to send it south where it is needed. As long as there is sufficient regulation making sure that they use that renewable power and don't start building gas turbines or dump them 20m from where people live it seems like they would be a benefit, especially if they are taxed appropriately.
That abundance should be used to reduce our reliance on fossil fuel energy and decarbonise. Instead with every Watt gained it's being assigned to a new, unnecessary, purpose.
We should be seeing our energy bills drastically reduce, and they're not.
This documentary by activist and writer Peter Gelderloos explains why using our additional energy production on new projects instead of current projects is detrimental to society and the climate quite well.
https://kolektiva.media/w/iY2SJKKXcUkBMPPxXngAGT
As for the empty space argument:
We should be increasing biodiversity to tackle the man made desert that is the Highlands, not tarring it over to create wealth for a handful of capitalist billionaires.
https://youtu.be/c0ygPXQ1nNM
I agree that the ideal usage of renewable energy is to decarbonise existing things, however we are already at the point where renewable energy companies are being paid to stop producing energy as it has nowhere to go. Millions of pounds are spent doing this most months.
Now the best use of public money is in making sure that energy goes into decarbonisation projects and grid upgrades, no argument there. But if private industry wants to invest in using renewable energy that would otherwise go to waste and result in the government hading out money to other private investors to not create energy then I think that's a good thing.
The point about empty space is that it is easy to put the data centre's away from where people live, their land usage footprint is tiny. The UK could build data centres for the entire world and the amount of land used would be less than the grouse shooting estates, we should focus on those and grazing land to rewild.
The 9 GW of datacentres that have apparently been applied for in planning would consume well over all of Scotland's total renewable energy output. Literally all of it.
Also consider that we still have substantial things needing decarbonised as soon as possible, like transport. We can reasonably expect more of that "overabundance" to be used in the near future.
As the article points out, most of that is companies trying it on with no real intention of following through. the current total data centre capacity in the UK is ~2GW with another 0.8GW under construction. There's no realistic prospect of 9GW of them being built in Scotland.
Also the argument that "too much of them would be bad" applies to almost everything, and isn't a reason to allow none of them, regulation exists and should be used!
And how much of the 9GW do you reckon they actually want to build? The guy representing the datacentre companies does not say. Even if it's only a third or a quarter of them, that's a ludicrous drain on a resource that, as the article also points out, is not actually in overabundance
The argument I'm making is not "too much is bad, therefore there must be none". There's even a proposal for a power cap on them in the article. Byt these companies have repeatedly demonstrated their willingness to ride roughshod over the rest of society at every opportunity. We should not extend them any trust beyond what we have ironclad control over.
I agree, but that shouldn't imply building none. I don't want us to be reliant on using data centres in the USA or China who can then use the prospect of cutting that off as leverage. I have no idea how much is reasonable but I am confident it is more than 0 and less than 9GW.
That's fair, I wasn't aiming that at you specifically but at the general atmosphere of All data centres are bad and must be stopped, as is visible in the headline image of the article and the other comments in this thread.
Regulate them into oblivion.
They provide no public good and have a list of down sides.
Empty space isn't actually that much in Scotland. As you need to have access to power, water, and data. Which limits locations to close to people already essentially. Given all the wind being built is at sea, floating data centers probably makes more sense!