24
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 11 Nov 2026
24 points (100.0% liked)
Fauxmoi
409 readers
63 users here now
The Lemmy gossip community.
Rules:
-Be respectful. No personal attacks.
-No bigotry - including racism, sexism, ableism, homophobia, transphobia, or xenophobia.
-No pedophile or rape apologia.
-No Ads / Spamming.
-No misinformation
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
How is that “cheeky”? If the agreement is upheld for The Pitt, then WB is effectively barred from making an emergency room medical show ever. Which is ridiculous.
The only medical shows they can possibly make are spin-offs of ER?
The criteria they gave are vague aspects of all emergency rooms, as any experienced medical doctor can attest.
Here’s the description for the top 10 litRPG novels available right now:
If this description is copyrighted, the genre dies.
What youre missing is the context of how the show was created. They reached out to Crichton's estate to make a reboot, balked at the price, then immediately made The Pitt.
With that context and the similarities it seems the judges thought there is enough evidence they were trying to make an ER fascimile that a court case is worth it. In the court case they may find the shows aren't similar enough, but given the events leading up to the show, it seems like they may have pulled a lot from ER.
And? Did Crichton write the Pitt? No, because he’s dead. Did they use his characters? No, because his greedy estate (whose very existence makes no sense) wanted too much money.
These legal shenanigans are all part of the commodification of art by capitalist parasites, which is why, for instance, Tolkien’s work still hasn’t entered the public domain, despite being almost a century old.
Well, a panel of 3 judges decided that Chrichton's widow had enough of an argument that The Pitt is a derivative work of ER. We'll see how the trial goes.
The same farcical judicial system that banned abortion and gave the president immunity from crimes. I don’t even have to assume they were bribed, just dumb af.
The Supreme Court is a little different than these judges here presiding over a copywrite case lol
Ah yes and everyone at Warner Bros is intelligent and honest and would never, ever try to make money while bending the rules.
I'm just bantering about a copywrite lawsuit about television shows. It's not that big a deal lol
You're coming at this really hard like Warner Bros are completely in the right and everyone else is super stupid. Which may be in this case, but I'm never one to give Warner Bros the benefit of the doubt.
Again, this isn’t about WB. It’s about art and copyright.
I mean, it's also about Warner Bros since they're the ones who had the contractual agreement with Crichton, but ok.
Is Michael Crichton's widow a faceless corporate entity?
It's not his estate, she filed it as an individual.
That's not to say I agree with her filing it, but it's not his estate doing this.
You're calling me anti-artist for indulging in a conversation about this case with you?
Yeah, ok.
You seem to be really fired up about this.
I appreciate you taking the personal attack out of your comment. I'm not trying to piss you off, I was really just discussing the case. I find it interesting and I do agree with a lot of what you're saying.
Is this whataboutism?! /s
You're right that the copyright laws in this country are not the greatest. I agree with you. I'm intrigued to see how this case plays out.
I was making a joke
We are capable of evaluating the court's arguments, and they do seem to make a very poor case. The commonalitres listed by the court themselves are embarrasingly and obviously staples of hospital drama.
We'll see what the court ultimately decides, but a loss is very likely and a win would be disastrous for almost every form of narrative art. The implications of owning an entire genre is copyright troll Nirvana. We're right to have feelings.
No one's criticizing you for having feelings about this. I'm just having a discussion.
I'm not picking sides. I'm just discussing the case and that this panel of judges did decide the shows were similar enough for this to move forward.
I bring evidence quite often, I source a lot of quotes and such. Just like I sourced my comment yesterday that you tried to twist into me attacking you when I clearly wasn't.
Clearly I've upset you somewhere along the way enough for you to take a conversation about copywrite laws into personal attacks.
You make snide asides how interesting you find it that people have certain opinions. I think you're kinda toxic and I am done.
It is interesting when people leap to defend certain relationship dynamics especially when you admitted you didn't know much about them.
Forums like Lemmy or Reddit are designed for back and forth conversation. I don't feel like I've been anything besides cordial with you, but there's a reason there's a block button.
You say that like that would be a bad thing...
That genre is already dead in some respects, because its main publishers (Royal Guard, Atheon, Podium) all use AI for editing and have no policy against AI use by authors — and worst of all, the readers are semiliterate gamers who think it’s impossible to be sure if AI was used, meaning that subreddits and other forums dedicated to promoting these works have explicit rules against mentioning AI.
I’m not kidding.
The Pitt is not a spin off of ER. Noah Wylie was in both and plays two different characters.
They started with wanting to make a spin-off of ER. When Crichton said no, that's when they came up with "The Pitt".
I don't know whether the shows are close enough to violate the contract WB has with Crichton, but it's enough for this panel of judges to allow the suit to move forward to determine that.