view the rest of the comments
News
Welcome to the News community!
Rules:
1. Be civil
Attack the argument, not the person or their instance. No racism/sexism/bigotry. Good faith argumentation only. This includes accusing another user of being a bot or paid actor. Trolling is uncivil and is grounds for removal and/or a community ban. Do not respond to rule-breaking content; report it and move on. Keep on-topic
2. All posts should contain a source (url) that is as reliable and unbiased as possible and must only contain one link.
Obvious biased sources will be removed at the mods’ discretion. Supporting links can be added in comments or posted separately but not to the post body. Sources may be checked for reliability using Wikipedia, MBFC, AdFontes, GroundNews, etc.
3. No bots, spam or self-promotion.
Only approved bots, which follow the guidelines for bots set by the instance, are allowed.
4. Post titles should be the same as the article used as source. Clickbait titles may be removed.
Posts which titles don’t match the source may be removed. If the site changed their headline, we may ask you to update the post title. Clickbait titles use hyperbolic language and do not accurately describe the article content. When necessary, post titles may be edited, clearly marked with [brackets], but may never be used to editorialize or comment on the content.
5. Only recent news is allowed.
Posts must be news from the most recent 30 days.
6. All posts must be news articles.
No opinion pieces, Listicles, editorials, videos, press releases, or celebrity gossip will be allowed. All posts will be judged on a case-by-case basis. Mods may use discretion to pre-approve videos or press releases from highly credible sources that provide unique, newsworthy content not available or possible in another format.
7. No duplicate posts.
If an article has already been posted, it will be removed. Different articles reporting on the same subject are permitted. If the post that matches your post is very old, we refer you to rule 5.
8. Misinformation is prohibited.
Misinformation / propaganda is strictly prohibited. Any comment or post containing or linking to misinformation will be removed. If you feel that your post has been removed in error, credible sources must be provided.
9. No link shorteners or news aggregators.
All posts must link to original article sources. You may include archival links in the post description. News aggregators such as Yahoo, Google, Hacker News, etc. should be avoided in favor of the original source link. Newswire services such as AP, Reuters, or AFP, are frequently republished and may be shared from other credible sources.
10. Don't copy entire article in your post body
For copyright reasons, you are not allowed to copy an entire article into your post body. This is an instance wide rule, that is strictly enforced in this community.
You aren't exactly painting yourself as an oracle here. Spouting doom will always leave you correct eventually, but being wrong for decades beforehand doesn't become insight just because something finally breaks.
Why are you so confident that deliberately accelerating a collapse makes it "more manageable"? If the dot-com boom had lasted long enough for actual revenues to catch up with valuations, the eventual correction could've been far less severe. Buying time can give the underlying technology a chance to deliver. It's getting more efficient per token at an incredible rate, and there's enormous pressure to improve hardware efficiency too. At some point, falling costs and growing paid usage could make the economics sustainable, though neither of us knows when, or whether, that'll happen. You're assuming that time can only make things worse, then treating that assumption as a reason to burn it all down.
Also worth noting the increase in power generation has pushed us to add 50% to our total global solar capacity in the last two years. That's fucking awesome and unlikely to stop increasing suddenly.
I'm not saying nothing's wrong, or that all these companies are good guys, fuck no. But confidently predicting doom now is no more convincing than all the previous prophecies that predicted doom.
When's the last time we went decades without a "once in a generation" type economic catastrophe?
The topic here was the collapse of civilisation?
Fair enough. It seemed to be going back and forth but the guy you responded to is arguably talking about society as a whole.
I guess I interpreted it as a full collapse because they're implying that AI as a technology would disappear entirely, which at this point would require all computers to disappear or regress to a primitive state.
I keep thinking the term "Butlerian Jihad" is going to be entering normie culture at some point soon.
DUNE: A Brief History of The Butlerian Jihad (Encyclopedia)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9FcBWOvEnEI
If the dot com boom... So we're just using hypotheticals to boost positivity?
Often speeding up something, gives you more control. Think of riding a bike. Going long stretches and remaining upright is easy. But when your kid is in front and breaks unexpectedly, you have to slow and do that back and forth thing with the handle bars to remain upright. Now imagine letting the AI bubble pop now. Better for it to pop while there's still functioning governments, than when those governments are at the edge of breaking.
Yeah solar is great, I agree. But we're still building fossil fuel power plants and solar has done nothing so far to stop that. It simply slows it. If the fall happens right now, everything collapses. We've stopped the acceleration of the climate crisis, and humanity has a chance to survive at 1.5C+. Humanity can rebuild. If we collapse at 3 or 4° C, we won't have any ability to rebuild, as there's a much larger collapse happening.
The point is that society is going to collapse regardless. It's better for it to happen now because it gives humanity the best chance to survive. If we shut down civilization now, everything can come back. The earth can heal and we can survive. If it collapses in 2120, the earth is a much more formidable environment to try to nurture small cultures of people.
And as of right now? AI is the #1 enemy to the environment. And for what? Fake videos? So if we can end AI right fucking now, it sets a much more livable future for human beings. And honestly, a much more humane one. So if capitalism has to go down with AI, and society has to go down with capitalism, it's the most humane option. At least people will have a chance. If we continue down the path we're on, there's really no hope for a future.
“So we're just using hypotheticals” meanwhile your entire argument depends on civilisation definitely collapsing, doing so later definitely being worse, and doing so now leaving humanity able to rebuild.
I offered a possibility. You've built a whole prescription for humanity around your predictions.
And your bike analogy involves slowing down and steering to avoid a crash. You're advocating deliberately crashing because you've decided a worse accident is inevitable further down the road.
There's a lot wrapped up in that certainty, and its a sentiment that does personally annoy me for several reasons: You're assuming the problems you see won't be meaningfully understood or addressed by anyone else, and that because you can't see a workable solution, there isnt one. You're treating the limits of your own foresight as the limits of what's possible. Stop and consider whether you really consider yourself an unparalleled engineer and problem solver of the modern era. Dont tell me the answer, just ponder it.
Then, when it comes to your preferred scenario, suddenly humanity can cooperate, adapt and rebuild after civilisation collapses. Why does human ingenuity get to do so much heavy lifting after the catastrophe, but count for so little in preventing it? There's a huge juxtaposition in that reasoning.
You've scrutinised the future you dislike for everything that could go wrong, and waved through the future you prefer on everything that could go right. That's a very shaky basis for deciding everyone else would be better off enduring a collapse now.
And “if we shut down civilisation now, everything can come back” is doing an extraordinary amount of work there. How are you keeping people fed, water clean, medicines available and nuclear facilities maintained? Who's coordinating any of that through the collapse you're welcoming? Those are fairly significant details to skip on the way to “the earth can heal”.
You don't get to dismiss uncertainty in my argument while treating the most optimistic version of your own catastrophe scenario as a certainty, that's fucking nonsense.
I get that you're concerned but this is irrational and you probably need to talk to someone serious if this is actually weighing heavily on you. If its just an idle rant, less so.
AI isnt going to end, the big dog companies might go down, but you can run very good ones on your computer these days. Helps to look into stuff, the unknown is always scarier than the known.
tl;dr
AI is built from mass theft and anything built with it deserves to be stolen.
Companies having done that doesn't make it fundamental to the technology. That's just something a lot of people who base their worldview on article headlines parrot.
Don't get me wrong, those practices are bad. But they come from the incentives and behaviour of the companies involved. The technology doesn't require them. That's a failure of a system that rewards companies for taking whatever they can get away with.
All of this is a capitalism problem, focusing on the technology is a distraction that will never achieve anything.
I’ve had a quick look at your discussion here.
My view: The problem with neither .com nor AI was that the technologies are useless. The problem with the bubble is that many of the companies involved are promising far more than the technology can realistically deliver. Against this backdrop, it doesn’t matter how long you let the bubble run, because meeting those exaggerated expectations is simply impossible in reality.
AI has its uses, particularly as specialised tools for specific fields, but – largely due to the hype – it is currently causing enormous damage on various levels. Against this backdrop, I believe that the bursting of the bubble will lead to a faster shift away from exaggerated, inefficient and wasteful technological promises towards efficient tools and solutions… and is therefore to be welcomed.
Yeah agreed, but marketing and hyping is how you get people excited and how you get funding. I struggle to imagine how you'd ever remove that from the economic equation. It definitely can have its drawbacks.
Yeah I think your conclusion is pretty likely. Most tools started off inefficient and got more so, because a more efficient tool is more desirable. Broadly speaking.
I dont think its completely impossible that they (the big companies) eek out their existence long enough that their income overcomes their initial outlay. As I say, they arent static, they are still progressing both the software and the hardware. Ramp up their green energy investment, continue progressing the energy efficiency increases per token, consistent supply lines and competition in components and raw materials push prices down. All feasible. None guaranteed, but all feasible.
Gonna steal this.
Perfectly sums up most Lemmite's opinions.