468
This is called “art”
(lemmy.nz)
Is someone holding these poor souls hostage and forcing them to be together?
Rules:
for more info, see larger rules post here: https://lemmy.blahaj.zone/post/1444294
What is it about right wingers and thinking statues prove anything about their politics, even if the statue is impressive and was made by one of their tribe? Terry Goodkind had a similar line of thought in his propaganda disguised as a fantasy series where the main character gets taken by the evil communists (who are all about making everyone equal in their suffering) but wins them over by carving an amazing statue (of himself and his wife iirc) that on its own starts a revolution.
Personally, I've never seen art so impressive that it makes me change my worldview, at least not from the technical execution of it. It's just a mindset so devoid of logic that it baffles me that they even try to make that argument, even when it doesn't turn out to be based on a false assumption that the person that made it was "on their side" (though as a white man, they have no claim on any of my achievements).
That series also had things like an emperor that could invade your dreams to torture you but the only protection was swearing fealty to the main character (and meaning it, the magic could tell if you didn't mean it!) and his wife leading a military resistance against an overwhelming army and succeeding through the brilliant tactic of her riding into battles naked.
Not like "wow, everybody who looks at that painting turns into a communist", obviously not. But there's a reason why people in power try to control art. Like e.g. the U.S. military spending $$$ on being depicted as the good guys in movies, or most autocrats outright banning certain arts, while pushing other artists etc.
That's why I added that next bit to focus the statement on the technical execution. Art does frequently serve as a vehicle for propaganda but IMO people's reception of it is more about a) what they already know or believe about the topic and b) how willing they are to think critically about the propaganda. There is an art to effective propaganda, but I'd say that's the only real case where technical skill affects the takeaway people who consume it take.
But the other technical skills on display will only serve to wow me for the artist's abilities. Like the old religious artists like the four the TMNT are named after, they definitely had a lot of technical skill, but rather than making me think that means there's any merit to their other beliefs, their works are more like "horrible taste, great execution" to me.
It’s not the statues so much as what they represent. They’re taught that all races but ‘White’ are ‘lesser savages’, only capable of basic substance living. In connection with this, they’re also taught that ‘Higher’, complex culture and art can only be created by ‘white people’.
So when they see those ‘lesser races’ creating ‘high art’ their brains break.
Don't forget about Goodkind's obvious rape and S&M fetishes having plot relevance
I can see art being inspiring in that way, but only as part of a cohesive statement that includes philosophical reasoning.
Like "let me write you an essay explaining this belief system, and then also present you with a song that captures how us followers of the mindset feel about it, while showing you our beautiful sculpture we made as a one shot symbol of the idea".
A powerful symbol can help anchor an idea, but I don't see it actually changing anyone's mind.
Can you imagine? "I used to be pro Western democracy, but ever since I saw their tilework and architectural depth, I've been pretty much subordinate to the will of the emperor of Byzantium and working to secure the resurgence of the Greek wing of the Eastern roman empire, and freeing Constantinople from Turkey."
These people have the intellectual capacity of early school graders, and to cover up their stupidity they pretend to be cultured.
Taliban famously blew up Bamiyan Buddha statues. They are as right wing as it gets.
I think this is more of a white supremacist thing than just standard right winger playbook. They want to claim Greek accomplishments as "western" while knowing nothing about the real history of that region and how they were connected to civilizations in Asia.
Anything "good" is "western" and "white". Everything bad is because of those "barbarians" and "invaders".
Even if "lesser people" do anything good, credit goes to the 'superior white knowledge' that taught them how to accomplish anything past breathing.
Yeah, when art changes my worldview it's because it hit me emotionally or intellectually, and even then it's usually only nudging me. Technical execution can impact that, look at something like the Buffy episode "The Body" or "I Saw the TV Glow" for examples in film of technical execution amplifying the emotional impact, but that's all it does. You just need enough technical skill to not impede your message/emotional beats, everything else is just amplification.
Statues can inspire awe and they can be gorgeous and impressive (as this one is), but especially when the statue is realistic, it's just not going to change my views on much other than the sculptor's skill.