So, question first, for those who just want a "quicker" discussion: What games are worth paying $100 for?
Longer form, for the forum types: Games were $50 or so for a long time, then they went up to $60. They told us digital would drive the price down, but then it went up to $70, with some games going for $80. A threatened boycott got the price of The Outer Worlds 2 reduced, but then Rockstar came out and said GTA VI will be $100. Almost nobody balked, nobody threatened a boycott, and gamers came out to vote for $100 games.
So, the question is, where do we go from here?
I don't think every new game will be $100... but I think Elder Scrolls VI, Fallout 5, and most Call of Duty games will be. Maybe others.
I'm curious not only what game you'd pay $100 for (Mass Effect 5 anyone?), but I'm even more curious what, if anything, you think is going to stop the next publisher from deciding their game is worth $100 (whether it is or isn't).
I think the big reasoning a lot of people said GTA VI was worth the $100 was because it's been 13 years since GTA V. Well, it's been 15 years since the last Elder Scrolls game, and 11 years since the last Fallout (we're not counting online/MMO stuff, because GTA V's online has been going strong this whole time, too).
Also, in a year, will you pay $100 again for the PC version of GTA VI, if you're a PC gamer?
Lastly: do you think the expansions will be free, or are you sure you're (or they're) actually not done paying/charging for GTA VI? And yes, they've said the city is designed for future expansion. Not sure if that's story expansions, or just online.
Bias disclosure: I didn't buy GTA VI. I don't hate it, I just wouldn't have bought it at $70 or above. $60, maybe, but probably not. I generally hang back and pay $10-20 for my games after they've been out a few years. My wife got me Pragmata for my birthday, and we spent $50 on that. Since then, I've bought Starfield for $30, Prey for $8, Dishonoured for $10, and pre-ordered Stage Tour for $36 (it'll be $40 at release). I definitely buy games, but $100 gets me a lot more than just one game. If you take Stage Tour out (because it hasn't released yet), the rest of my purchases put me at $98, and that's for four games, including one that released this year and is probably the GOTY if we set sequels, spinoffs, and remakes aside. It's certainly the most original. I'll get GTA VI eventually. I liked pretty much all of them since the original. Even liked the second one.
That said, I did buy the Pip-Boy Edition of Fallout 4 (something like $130?) and then I turned around and bought the complete edition on Xbox a couple years later for like $55. Then I bought it again on GOG to experiment with on my Mac for around $10, so I have absolutely spent more than $100 on one game! So, totally not trying to be a hypocrite or anything! Just wondering where we go from here.

100% this.
It gets even crazier when you calculate things like "$ per line of code written" or "$ per megabyte" and track it back to the NES.
Video-games are exceptionally cost effective as entertainment, and gamers' resistance to price increases is one of the reasons battle passes and micro transactions blew up. Despite what everyone thinks, it's really hard to fund game dev these days because of the margins. Unless I'm willing to work for free for several years, i need an investor to put up around $1.5M to release a game as simple as Balatro.
There's plenty of corporate greed, and union busting, and all sorts of bad shit. But expecting a AAA game with a narrative/content driven experience over 20 hrs for less than $60 is fucking nuts
Which are of course famously good metrics for game price or quality...
They are a reasonable proxy for production-cost-to-entertainment-hours conversion.
The quality of a game is in the eye of the beholder. And there are good games that cost almost nothing to make, and there are shit games that cost millions to make.
The point I'm making is about how much money it typically costs to create an hour of playable content.
It obviously varies greatly from game to game, based on the type of game, replayability, etc, and actual appeal
But it is reasonable to say that, on average, player expectations for games have gone up over the last 40 years, meaning lines of code per hour of entertainment has gone up, hours spent working on assets per hour of entertainment has gone up, etc.
So, on average, we're paying more to make 20 hours of gameplay today than we were 40 years ago.
It's not about "more lines of code = better game" or anything like that.
It's about what it costs to make an hour of content, and what players will pay for that hour of content. Which translates directly to how many players you need in order to turn a profit. Which translates directly to funding struggles for anything but nearly guaranteed hits.
I like to look at the price per hour of entertainment. When you look at cinema for example, you'll have 2h of entertainment for $20. So $10/h of entertainment. Going to an amusement park: $150 for 8h = $18/h. Bowling: $25 for 1.5h = $16/h. Red Dead Redemption 2: $80 for 80h = $1/h. I know it doesn't include the console/PC itself but still... If you use your PC for more than just gaming, then yeah... video games are a very cheap form of entertainment, even with $100 games
Yup. That's exactly what I'm talking about. It's insanely cost effective. An order of magnitude more cost effective.
Books might be the only thing comparable.
And we're not even talking about multiplayer games where you can sink literally hundreds or thousands of hours into 'em.
Here's another fun fact to put it in perspective...
Let's say I want to hire a team of 5 people full time to develop a game, and I expect it to take two years, and sell for $19.99 on Steam.
All-up you're looking at about $1.5M at least for that type of game, between employee compensation, marketing, operations, QA, and overhead.
A reasonable estimate for net profit on a $19.99 PC game is around $7.49 per unit sold.
Wishlist conversions in the first week after launch are about 10%. For a popular game, you might see 4x your first-week sales over the following 2-3 years.
That means you need ~485,000 people to wishlist your game to recover a $1.5M investment after 2-3 years from launch.
And under current economic conditions, publishers won't fund the validation phase anymore. You have to build a demo or vertical slice and get that shit onto Steam so they can see the wishlist rates before they'll fund full production.
The economics of making games right now sucks. Yeah, games like Balatro can make a lot of money, but those types of breakout success are the exception. Most games released today don't even come close to recouping their investment.