you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 16 Nov 2026
26 points (100.0% liked)
TechTakes
2798 readers
41 users here now
Big brain tech dude got yet another clueless take over at HackerNews etc? Here's the place to vent. Orange site, VC foolishness, all welcome.
This is not debate club. Unless it’s amusing debate.
For actually-good tech, you want our NotAwfulTech community
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
What to even make of this: https://nitter.catsarch.com/policytensor/status/2123877024737714367#m
So the Holocaust, factory-farming and other human atrocities supposedly constitute a moral argument for human extinction tout court. Words straight out of the mouth of a 60s Bond-villain.
The motivations of the usual right-wingers and assorted cynical plutocrats make sense, but I just can't get my head around to left-wingers who actively, ideologically embrace AI and transhumanism as if these were any kind of solution to these issues. Then again, eugenics was also popular in progressive circles at one time precisely for the promise of being able to engineer a more peacable humanity. But it's not even this ostensibly level-headed here, there's a palpably eschatological register to the whole post.
I guess a retort would be that if the new morally regenerate AI started out by carrying out a total human extinction, it would not in fact be so morally regenerate anymore, would it? AGI's Original Sin? Seems that the people who want to proffer on these topics should perhaps consider obtaining a passing acquaintance with theology first.
Apparently you do, because nowhere in any of those paragraphs do you offer a connection between ‘humans are bad’ and ‘robot god’
I guess the idea is that we need a human extinction and robot god is the only viable approach. And the robot god, who mercifully murders all of humanity, will totally be so moral as to not do any more murdering.
If you take suffering seriously as a moral evil, then supporting "succession" makes no sense. If conscious existence is "not okay", and indeed MALIGNANTLY USELESS, bringing a new and greater kind of consciousness into the world is surely the greatest possible evil—far eclipsing the admittedly horrifying history of human vice and cruelty.
also causing human extinction isn't like, morally neutral
There’s nothing left-wing about this kind of rhetoric. It’s a classic exemple of reactionary misanthropy.
I read something about this once. Turns out you can scour the earth clean of life and still be perfectly good provided you do two things. First you gotta get the local lunatic to build a big fuckoff boat. He'll make sure you have like four people and a bunch of random animals left. Then you get the important part: you gotta feel really really bad about afterwards and pinky-promise the lunatic and his sheep that you won't do it again.
So I basically agree with the author that those who aren't vegan would face some sort of justice in an ideal world (I'm more thinking purgatory than murder, I want more vegans not dead people) but that's pretty much the only active act of utter barbarity that most people engage in and even so there are large structural and historical factors in why people are so blind to the horror they engage in. Mass veganism was not really possible until recently (although the intense amount of meat and animal products eaten by the global north is deeply aberrant too).
But like what? What is the point of hoping for extinction? Most problems are structural not individual, and nothing is inevitable about the current world. Even if it was morally sound it's still stupid and pointless, people will never just twiddle their thumbs and wait to die so maybe you should try and formulate an actually useful ideology that can improve the world?
To quote a smoking hot short king: