Even if the US miraculously adopted a parliamentary system, it would still be an oligarchy, because capitalist states serve the capitalist class. Previously:
The US government was never not captured by the bourgeoisie, because the US was born of a bourgeois revolution[1]. The wealthy, white, male, land-owning, largely slave-owning Founding Fathers constructed a bourgeois state with “checks and balances” against the “tyranny of the majority”. It was never meant to represent the majority—the working class—and it never has, despite eventually allowing women and non-whites (at least those not disenfranchised by the carceral system) to vote. BBC: [Princeton & Northwestern] Study: US is an oligarchy, not a democracy
You mean the one that's already been reformed and is continuing to get reformed? Okay.
But yeah, you're connecting dots that aren't related to the question you asked. I swear it's every time I interact with someone from .ml that the conversation goes off on some wild tangent because the questions you ask are bad faith bait to start an argument about something else.
I always hold out hope that I can have a productive, good-faith conversation with .mls.
So far it's 0% but I'll probably keep trying. I'm pretty stubborn and naive sometimes.
I don't know if it's this particular website or what, but none of the card-carrying, self-described socialists and communists I've met are anywhere half as hostile or bad faith in their conversations. Maybe it's the anonymity that does it?
Anyway, if you want somewhere you can propagandize without lemmy.world people piping in, just defederate us.
“Bad faith” is when you’re unable to sheepdog us back to where you are now politically. It’s not going to happen, because we used to believe in bourgeois electoralism like you do, and we’ve learned from those mistakes and have moved on.
Buddy, you came to a “tankie” post to soapbox electoralism and election reform tangents, things we know from over a century of history and theory, will never lead to socialism.
Why are you putting "tankie" in quotes as if I called you or this post that? More disinformation, classic.
Similarly inaccurate is that my start in this thread wasn't "soapboxing electoralism and election reform tangents," it was a direct counter-claim to a claim made in the video. Again, your apparent stance of insistence that I let you spread disinformation in peace is ridiculous.
Even if the US miraculously adopted a parliamentary system, it would still be an oligarchy, because capitalist states serve the capitalist class. Previously:
You're just citing tangentially related topics.
It’s tangential that the system you propose to reform is not reformable? Okay.
You mean the one that's already been reformed and is continuing to get reformed? Okay.
But yeah, you're connecting dots that aren't related to the question you asked. I swear it's every time I interact with someone from .ml that the conversation goes off on some wild tangent because the questions you ask are bad faith bait to start an argument about something else.
This post is about a video by a Marxist-Leninist. You’re in our thread. If you don’t want to engage with us, then don’t.
I always hold out hope that I can have a productive, good-faith conversation with .mls.
So far it's 0% but I'll probably keep trying. I'm pretty stubborn and naive sometimes.
I don't know if it's this particular website or what, but none of the card-carrying, self-described socialists and communists I've met are anywhere half as hostile or bad faith in their conversations. Maybe it's the anonymity that does it?
Anyway, if you want somewhere you can propagandize without lemmy.world people piping in, just defederate us.
“Bad faith” is when you’re unable to sheepdog us back to where you are now politically. It’s not going to happen, because we used to believe in bourgeois electoralism like you do, and we’ve learned from those mistakes and have moved on.
I never did any of that, but enjoy yet another tangential opportunity to soapbox.
Buddy, you came to a “tankie” post to soapbox electoralism and election reform tangents, things we know from over a century of history and theory, will never lead to socialism.
Why are you putting "tankie" in quotes as if I called you or this post that? More disinformation, classic.
Similarly inaccurate is that my start in this thread wasn't "soapboxing electoralism and election reform tangents," it was a direct counter-claim to a claim made in the video. Again, your apparent stance of insistence that I let you spread disinformation in peace is ridiculous.