[-] lagrangeinterpolator@awful.systems 7 points 8 hours ago* (last edited 8 hours ago)

I would sneer, but he probably bought a ton of Anthropic stock as soon as it hit the public markets, and I don't want to be too mean.

On a more serious note, I don't find any point engaging with these types of people anymore. They treat this whole issue as if it was some football game. I'm reminded of Ed Zitron saying that these people have a mindset of a peasant. They would cheerlead for people who would shove them into a woodchipper to make another buck.

(If you want an actual counterargument to this nonsense, I wrote this a while back.)

[-] lagrangeinterpolator@awful.systems 5 points 9 hours ago* (last edited 9 hours ago)

Every long human written math paper has cosmetic mistakes in it. I've even read a 9 page paper where they put a 3 where they should have put a 4. It didn't matter at all for their result (they only needed it up to big O). I am not sure how many of these commenters understand the difference.

I do not have remotely enough expertise or time to evaluate the human proof, but an ignorant person running AI on it and reporting mistakes does not really indicate anything substantial.

Also, there are no 250,000 pages to verify because the prompter never released them. There is only the Lean proof (which the prompter certainly would have checked before releasing).

[-] lagrangeinterpolator@awful.systems 9 points 13 hours ago* (last edited 12 hours ago)

If this isn't just AI psychosis, maybe he's trying to appeal to mathematicians who are angry about the destruction of the values and ideals of mathematical discovery? It's not working.

Edit: never mind, the more I read it, the worse it gets. It really feels like Anthropic is a cult where they believe they are divinely ordained to deliver salvation to everyone. Or not, maybe AI will kill us all. Even OpenAI's announcements tried to be professional.

That might take a little while, given that the Lean proof is over 1GB. The prompter didn't release a natural language proof because it ended up being more than 250,000 pages. Of course, there are many sections that are wasteful and can be simplified.

OpenAI already got Navier-Stokes and dumped hundreds of slop proofs onto Github. At this point I believe that mathematical theorems are already priced in, even for the most mold-poisoned boosters.

One thing that is different about this result is that the prompter actually has serious expertise in math and had a major role in guiding the overall direction of the proof.

One of the major functions of AI is laundering responsibility. If someone makes a bad decision and AI was involved, they can blame the AI. More often these days, we also see the reverse. Overworked employees are forced to use AI while not having nearly enough time to review the slop. When something breaks, it couldn't have been the AI's fault. AI cannot fail, it can only be failed.

Now I think AI development itself is another big example of laundering responsibility. AI was not inevitable, and all normal people know it. The residents protesting data center development know it, the students booing commencement speakers know it. AI development was only possible because of the whims of a few rich oligarchs who forced it upon everyone. It doesn't even make money! Their rationalist courtiers act real smug and feel like their prophecies are coming true, all while trillions of dollars are going into the furnace to actively realize those prophecies.

Their obsession with predictions and lines on charts really shows their belief that the future is something that happens to them, not something they make. They idolize people who get a ton of election bets right on Polymarket, but never in a million years would they get their asses off the couch and vote, let alone call phones and knock on doors.

You might all enjoy a little more awareness of the situation. As we all know, the easiest way to make 1.58 billion dollars is to start with 20.24 billion dollars.

I am sick and tired of all this benchmark business. It really feels like people staring at tea leaves and bird patterns and sheep guts to see if they line up with the prophecy written in the book some random shady oracle sold them 200 years ago. If they wanted a clear picture, why don't they just ask a practitioner in the field? Ask a programmer if software has become very reliable and user-friendly, and if codebases are well-structured and easy to maintain and not spaghetti nightmares. Or they could just open their eyes and see Microsoft and the FAA shitting their pants on two consecutive days. But I guess it's not Rational if it doesn't let them make up 37 numbers.

[-] lagrangeinterpolator@awful.systems 6 points 5 days ago* (last edited 5 days ago)

The funniest part of Jensengate is seeing all the techbros being really sad and petitioning to restore Jensen to his rightful position, thinking that there is some analogy to Sam Altman. They seem to not realize that the reason Saltman was fired was because the board didn't like his stupid face. Meanwhile, Jensen has committed three affairs, two with employees, and somehow that is the less important thing, considering he smuggled tens of billions of dollars of chips illegally into China. I wouldn't be surprised if he ends up in jail. If Jensen thought he had a reasonable chance of surviving, why would he resign and start whining like a teenager?

They even built a vibe coded petition website with zero user validation whatsoever:

Terry Tao talks about how he used to try to cooperate with the AI industry to achieve a positive outcome, but now he finally sees their true colors. Link

During this event, OpenAI requested an interview concerning my vision of the future of AI and mathematics. I accepted, and spoke with them for perhaps an hour. I had done similar interviews in various venues, and I assumed that, as with these other cases, they would eventually post the entire interview online, which talked about both the possibilities and risks of AI much as I have done in these other interviews. As it turned out, they only used a few snippets of that interview for that infamous advertisement instead. In retrospect, I should have pushed back harder on their decision; but I decided at the time that even a selective release of my commentary would help raise awareness of the potential for AI, and in particular on the possibility of the “best of both worlds”.

Since then, the situation has deterioriated markedly. Many of the people in the industry that shared my views have left or become sidelined, with most major tech companies now increasingly focused on the race to develop extremely powerful, autonomous AI technologies regardless of their actual value to society. The current drama surrounding the Navier-Stokes global regularity problem is the most dramatic and visible instance of this, but there have been multiple other such examples, and much of my commentary in the last few months has been aimed that the increasingly severe divergence between the current objectives of the AI industry, and of mathematics in general.

Much respect to artists for seeing all this coming from the very beginning, and holding the line.

[-] lagrangeinterpolator@awful.systems 21 points 8 months ago* (last edited 8 months ago)

I decided to take a look at the bitcoin white paper.

Usually, the introduction of a technical paper is fluff and people quickly move on to the technical parts. However, the casual claims made in the first paragraph of this paper have aged extremely poorly, to say the least. In a better world, Bitcoin would have remained as an obscure academic toy, and this introduction would have remained fluff.

While the system works well enough for most transactions, it still suffers from the inherent weaknesses of the trust based model.

What weaknesses are there in the trust based model? Let's find out!

Completely non-reversible transactions are not really possible, since financial institutions cannot avoid mediating disputes. The cost of mediation increases transaction costs, limiting the minimum practical transaction size and cutting off the possibility for small casual transactions, and there is a broader cost in the loss of ability to make non-reversible payments for non-reversible services. With the possibility of reversal, the need for trust spreads. Merchants must be wary of their customers, hassling them for more information than they would otherwise need.

It seems like this guy really loves non-reversible transactions! But as we've seen with the history of crypto, non-reversible transactions sound really good until you fall victim to a crypto scam and there is no way to appeal to the bank to reverse the charges. Reversibility actually increases trust because you no longer need to be absolutely certain that you're dealing with an honest person.

A certain percentage of fraud is accepted as unavoidable.

Almost like that is a problem of human nature. And it's not like cryptocurrency has a spotless record when dealing with fraud! The problem with fraud is not the third party (the bank), but with the second party (the merchant or customer you're dealing with).

The introduction is not long, and most of the paper concerns the technical details of the construction of Bitcoin. By itself, there really is no way to complain about a pile of definitions. But there are still dumb comments that have aged poorly in retrospect.

A block header with no transactions would be about 80 bytes. If we suppose blocks are generated every 10 minutes, 80 bytes * 6 * 24 * 365 = 4.2MB per year. With computer systems typically selling with 2GB of RAM as of 2008, and Moore's Law predicting current growth of 1.2GB per year, storage should not be a problem even if the block headers must be kept in memory.

But why would you want a block header with no transactions? If you wanted to, I don't know, replace the world's financial system, you would need to handle millions of transactions every 10 minutes. How big would the blocks be then? And remember that many copies of the same blockchain would need to be stored (certainly, every miner would need to store a copy). How many thousands or millions of times would that multiply things?

Businesses that receive frequent payments will probably still want to run their own nodes for more independent security and quicker verification.

Turns out it was a bold assumption to think that businesses would just run their own bitcoin miners.

The proof of security (Section 11) is extremely sketchy by modern standards. (They're assuming that all attackers would follow a certain format to attack and not try something different. I get it, proper proofs of security in cryptography are very subtle and difficult.) There is also a page of fluff making random calculations with the Poisson distribution. In any case, the security of Bitcoin requires that the collective computational power of the defenders exceeds the power of any attacker (so the defenders can make new blocks faster).

Bitcoin is very strange as a cryptographic system in that the defender must have more resources than any possible attacker. In most cryptographic systems, the system should be secure even if the attacker has vastly more resources than the defender. Your phone's cryptography should be secure even if some government agency dedicated their supercomputers to try and break it. This means that Bitcoin must waste tons of energy, since that is required to maintain security. Any more energy dumped into it will only increase security and not make the actual transactions faster, which makes Bitcoin horrendously inefficient.

As a purely academic idea in cryptography, it is an interesting curiosity, but the arguments for why it's useful are sketchy. There are other such curiosities that are much more interesting, like homomorphic encryption or secure multiparty computation. It would be a nice line on a CV, but not "incredible".

The true significance of Bitcoin was the terrible libertarian economic argument for it, and the chain of events that would transform it into nothing more than a speculative fashion trend. It has nothing to do with the technical details of Bitcoin. The technical and economic arguments for Bitcoin turned out to be so weak that nowadays, the only real support for Bitcoin is that maybe you can sell it for a higher price to a greater fool.

“California is, I believe, the only state to give health insurance to people who come into the country illegally,” Kauffman said nervously. “I think we probably should not be providing that.”

“So you’d rather everyone just be sick, and get everyone else sick?” another reporter asked.

“That’s not what I’m saying,” said Kauffman.

“Isn’t that effectively what happens?” the reporter countered. “They don’t have access to health care and they just have to get sick, right?”

Kauffman contemplated that one for a moment. “Then they have to just get sick,” he said. “I mean, it’s unfortunate, but I think that it’s sort of impossible to have both liberal immigration laws and generous government benefits.”

Do I need to comment on this one?

view more: next ›

lagrangeinterpolator

0 post score
0 comment score
joined 2 years ago