has there ever been a good video game movie?
this post was submitted on 11 Aug 2024
95 points (96.1% liked)
movies
1809 readers
345 users here now
Warning: If the community is empty, make sure you have "English" selected in your languages in your account settings.
A community focused on discussions on movies. Besides usual movie news, the following threads are welcome
- Discussion threads to discuss about a specific movie or show
- Weekly threads: what have you been watching lately?
- Trailers
- Posters
- Retrospectives
- Should I watch?
Related communities:
Show communities:
Discussion communities:
RULES
Spoilers are strictly forbidden in post titles.
Posts soliciting spoilers (endings, plot elements, twists, etc.) should contain [spoilers] in their title. Comments in these posts do not need to be hidden in spoiler MarkDown if they pertain to the titleβs subject matter.
Otherwise, spoilers but must be contained in MarkDown.
2024 discussion threads
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
It's bizarre to me. Hollywood has generally figured out that if a book sells really well that you shouldn't fuck with the movie version any more than you have to. If you gotta jiggle a few things around for pacing, fine.
But they'll still absolutely torch a video game story to "make it better"with no comprehension of the source material and it's literally never ever worked.
TV figured it out w/ The Last of Us and Fallout.
But games are about the player getting to engage with and explore the world and story at their own pace and shows let it aorta slow down too.
Really the answer seems to be take the world and make your movie in it as needed to make the story engaging.
The recent mortal kombat movie, Mario movie, detective pikachu and sonic movies show that it works. Also don't mess with the characters to much if you include them.
I liked the latest D&D movie a lot, but I guess that doesn't technically count.
Not good, per se, but certainly some entertaining ones.
The Last of Us is fantastic, but it's not a movie.
Arcane too
While not amazing, Silent Hill was ok (6.5 on imdb)
I hate that movie so much. I mean it was done pretty well and all but one scene pisses me off.
The first time she goes to hell dimension she gets up from the floor by grabbing a perfectly sized metal pipe. Which is the first weapon you use in the first two games. I'm like oh shit it's on now. But she didn't take the pipe with her. It seemed like a deliberate fuck you to fans of the games.
If I had never played the games I'd probably like the movie a lot more.
Can I count Big Trouble in Little China as the first Mortal Kombat movie?
If so, then yes, there's been at least one.
I see BTiLC reference, I upvote. Simple.
Despite its issues, I really liked Warcraft.
I enjoyed it as well.
The first Mortal Kombat movie was a classic!
Honestly the latest one was good too
Haven't seen either yet, but everyone seemed to love the Mario and Sonic movies
Check out the first Mario Bros movie (1993 I think?) if you want to feel your brain vomit out your ears. How they got to that story with the source material is anyone's guess.
Acid and heavy drinking?
I thought detective pikachu was pretty good
Both Sonic movies are a lot of fun and Jim Carrey is obviously having a great time being Robotnik.
Ranked by Tomatometer, there are 6 certified fresh!
https://editorial.rottentomatoes.com/guide/video-game-movies/
Does the Gran Turismo movie count as a "video game" movie? I haven't watched it but I know the general plot and that Gran Turismo is essentially a driving sim with no storyline (most recent one I played was GT4).
I think of it like if there was a movie about an avid Flight Simulator player has to land a passenger jet after both pilots are incapacitated, I wouldn't consider it a video game movie. Maybe that's how they remake Airplane! though.
It's based on a true story. They auditioned the top GT players to see if anyone could actually drive in a race. One guy made it.
Right. I mean that it doesn't take place in the "universe" of Gran Turismo. Which is the criteria I think I would use to consider it a "video game movie".
I mean, the universe is racecars on real tracks...
I really don't agree with the rating on some of these. I thought "In the name of the king" was quite enjoyable, as was the original 1995 Mortal Kombat.
Street Fighter was OK, wasn't it? I'm asking because I haven't seen it since I was a teenager and my sensibilities may have changed since then.
Guile: This is the collection agency, Bison. Your ass is six months overdue, and it's mine. (In the thickest definitely not American accent you have ever heard)
Yeah I'm not sure it was that good but it's fun to watch.
Final Fantasy, the ghost within. Great animation for it time, good plot, fine movie.
The (2023) Mario movie is good.
The Silent Hill series was pretty great. Also, the original Mario Bros movie.
Oh, and Advent Children!
Good in terms of being a good example of great cinema, no
Good in terms of being faithful to the source material and/or fun to watch?
- ratchet and clank
- resident evil
I'm sure I'll see Borderlands eventually, but it wasn't tracking for me as a must see. The trailer was just okay, and I'm not sure did the movie any favors-- In fact it looks like it was made by the same person that made the trailer for The Suicide Squad (2016).
I'll certainly see it at some point just out of morbid curiosity. Considering the bad reviews, I expect this will hit digital pretty fast.
They already have Blu-ray preorder steelbooks announced!!!
@UKFilmNerd It's crazy how badly the projections have been missing opening weekend hauls over the past two months. It seems that since Bad Boys, they've undershot every blockbuster by a significant amount.
I find it strange that there seems to be a job of professionally guessing movies opening weekend numbers. π
Well, money makes the world go round and movies are a combination of really expensive gambling and money laundering.
So you want to know the odds before you gamble your money too.