271
submitted 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago) by abc@suppo.fi to c/linux@lemmy.world
top 50 comments
sorted by: hot top new old
[-] homes@piefed.world 107 points 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago)

I hate to admit it, but he’s right. I’m no fan of using AI either, but there are times and places where it can actually be a useful tool when used correctly. What’s really important is the quality of the contributions made to the project, and the usefulness should be judged on its merits alone of those individual contributions, not the “icky“ feeling people get from the idea of using AI at all.

Torvalds is clearly not here defending “vibe coding”, and he’s perfectly happy for people to not use AI at all. But when AI, as a tool, is used to responsibly, it can clearly be quite useful. And for the coders who can use it in a responsible and useful way to make meaningful contributions, I also think they should be permitted to.

[-] tangeli@piefed.social 63 points 4 months ago

He mentions the economic and environmental aspects of AI but I think dismisses them a little too quickly. While AI as a tool can clearly provide many benefits, the external costs (i.e. costs not directly born by the project but incurred by others/society as a result of use of the tool) should not be ignored.

And I don't see mention of the seeming expropriation of works without compensation by the AI developers and the as yet unresolved IP aspects of using AI. These are part of the big picture economic impacts but also have moral and possibly legal implications.

In short, I think there are reasons not to treat AI as merely a tool.

[-] homes@piefed.world 16 points 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago)

These are completely valid points absolutely worthy of discussion, and I fully agree with both of them, FWIW.

I was just responding to the point that Torvalds was making here.

load more comments (2 replies)
[-] hoshikarakitaridia@lemmy.world 38 points 4 months ago

Yeah he's smart and he has the boring take which is probably the wisest take. It's just a tool and the people who vibe code just use it negligently.

[-] homes@piefed.world 19 points 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago)

Yeah he's smart and he has the boring take which is probably the wisest take.

The wisest takes often are. He also has the benefit of decades of experience, dealing with trends and fads and upstart programmers with strong opinions.

[-] Semi_Hemi_Demigod@lemmy.world 8 points 4 months ago

Also an understanding that we live in a boring universe.

[-] artyom@piefed.social 21 points 4 months ago

The problem is that it's overwhelmingly not used "correctly".

[-] uuj8za@piefed.social 10 points 4 months ago

Yeah, exactly. Basically the whole thing incentivizes you to NOT use it correctly. Using it incorrectly is the default.

[-] tatterdemalion@programming.dev 8 points 4 months ago

I would say it's more than just an icky feeling. It's a justified moral opposition. But otherwise I agree. Just a tool.

[-] erictile@lemmy.world 8 points 4 months ago

Agreed. Every major AI model is trained off of data gathered without consent. AI even violates the licenses of the vast majority of open source projects due to the requirement that the original authors be listed in the copyright section when you pull code from a project. AI generated code does not do that.

load more comments (2 replies)
[-] ZombieCyborgFromOuterSpace@piefed.ca 73 points 4 months ago

AI is not the problem. It's the people and companies behind the popular public AI services that are the problem.

[-] 4am@lemmy.zip 47 points 4 months ago

ML algorithms are fine. It’s the capitalist use cases that are shit and bad for everyone.

[-] semperverus@lemmy.world 30 points 4 months ago

This is the correct outlook on it.

Academically, artificial neural network algorithms are cool as fuck, even given their shortcomings.

Capitalist greed has weaponized them and done horrible atrocious things to "improve" them (stealing works they have no rights to in order to profit off of them, replacing humans who want to work, ruining the arts, etc.)

[-] cenzorrll@piefed.ca 11 points 4 months ago

It's doing some pretty awesome things in the medical field as well, where experts can review it's output and make decisions based on everything else they know and are experts in

It's weird, like if experts feed AI things they know to be true, correct it when it gets it wrong, rinse and repeat. Then only use that AI for the things they trained it on, it seems to be pretty good. Whereas AI fed the entirety of human shit and corrected by middle managers, who are only experts in inflating their own ego, tends to output a lot of self-inflating bullshit.

load more comments (2 replies)
load more comments (1 replies)
[-] SCmSTR@lemmy.blahaj.zone 9 points 4 months ago

And all the stolen and continued stealing and privacy issues and biases and all of the other ethical issues... But yeah.

[-] canniest_tod@lemmy.world 63 points 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago)

I used to see anti-AI people as myopic and foolish, but seeing how it's being developed and implemented is really eye-opening. They're pushing an unfinished, unrefined technology that often adds to the ecological crisis and might be poisoning people's drinking water, so they can roll the dice in terms of what it'll do to the economy while using it to spy on everyone. The public face of all this is these companies telling us that we should be terrified of what it'll do to the job market, but we need to invest in it big time, right now. I apologize to anyone I spoke down to. I get it. It's not a way forward, but I get it.

[-] yakko@feddit.uk 16 points 4 months ago

Disaster capitalists can't be trusted to mix the vinegar for washing windows, much less a technology that can be used to undermine labour itself.

[-] SabinStargem@lemmy.today 8 points 4 months ago

The problem isn't inherent to AI. The issues are little different from the industrial revolution or robber barons, where industry is power, and the most malicious are ever grasping to obtain it.

0000

The solution isn't to abandon AI, but for ordinary people to become masters of the technology. Every home server, allows a homestead to have understanding and agency over their tools. If enough individuals own their own AI, it would become possible to overcome the influence of corporations, such as community projects to provide AI utilities to their communities.

For example, say a phone app is developed and spread by a town. It's purpose is to record receipts with a cellphone camera, and then the town's AI analyzes it. Using comparisons of purchasing prices, it can detect whether pricing is being changed on a individual basis, or other shenanigans. This can help stem price fixing and other corruptions.

We, as a society, should use AI to help counter malicious actors and to provide helpful services.

load more comments (3 replies)
load more comments (3 replies)
[-] mlg@lemmy.world 52 points 4 months ago

I'm pretty sure he already handed out a ban for someone who submitted a slop PR.

He's been pretty clear that he's only interested in clean code additions. It doesn't really matter how you achieved your PR so much so thst it's quality code with a useful purpose for the kernel.

[-] Zephyr@sh.itjust.works 52 points 4 months ago

Yeah he's had a very neutral take on it. Like it's a thing and it does good work some of the time but ultimately code not written by a person is harder to maintain. At least when a person writes code they typically have a strong understanding of what they wrote and can accurately communicate that to others.

[-] AChiTenshi@sh.itjust.works 31 points 4 months ago

As a developer I can say that plenty of developers have trouble accurately communicating how code they just wrote works.

That said its still infinitly being able to ask them questions on it then trying to parse AI code.

[-] Semi_Hemi_Demigod@lemmy.world 17 points 4 months ago

Hell, I’ve written code on Friday and by Monday it makes zero sense to me.

[-] toynbee@piefed.social 7 points 4 months ago

Who wrote this ridiculous, nonfunctional, unreadable spaghetti code?

Oh, I did?

... It's not so bad.

[-] tangeli@piefed.social 8 points 4 months ago

Not only trouble communicating but often knowing what the code they just wrote actually does. I will ever remember one of the first times I wrote a thorough set of tests for what I thought was a correct and simple little bit of code: it wasn't doing what I thought, until many iterations later.

load more comments (5 replies)
load more comments (4 replies)
[-] SCmSTR@lemmy.blahaj.zone 47 points 4 months ago

It's not fear over new tools, it's frustration with how it's wielded and how inappropriately, irresponsibly, unethically, and greedily it's pushed.

AI, itself is not the problem. The people who use AI, and the people who steal and trample and bludgeon to get it and while using it are the problem.

To disregard this entire aspect of the conversation is... Alarming and disappointing.

I believe we should all be pushing for ethical and responsible AI use and development, and what constitutes that and why. If not, the only resulting conclusion should and will be, simply: "Fuck AI", which is where we are, now.

[-] MathiasTCK@lemmy.world 9 points 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago)

What if we rush slop generators with ineffective safeguards to market instead?

load more comments (4 replies)
load more comments (1 replies)
[-] snooggums@piefed.world 40 points 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago)

While he is correct from a purely technical perspective, a lot of the backlash against other people using AI (LLMs generally) on collaborative work is due to how it is currently being implemented in a way that harms the environment, drives up hardware prices, sucks up mass amounts of data it shouldn't, breaks laws, negatively impacts those lower on the social latter , and a bunch of stuff outside of how it impacts code.

Like my limited experience with LLMs has been bad because it is frequently wrong, but I hate it because it is shoved into everything and has all the negative impacts I listed above. I wouldn't hate it and discourage others from using it if it was just new tech that didn't work.

load more comments (8 replies)
[-] bright_side_@piefed.world 37 points 4 months ago

the mailing list entry that phoronix links to: https://lore.kernel.org/linux-media/CAHk-=wi4zC+Ze8e+p3tMv8TtG_80KzsZ1syL9anBtmEh5Z40vg@mail.gmail.com/

"

On Tue, 14 Jul 2026 at 19:01, Roman Gushchin roman.gushchin@linux.dev wrote:

I think it makes the point of sashiko - helping maintainers - unachievable. If the point to not use
LLMs in general, let’s discuss this, not how to make each use case more complex.

It seems like [1] expresses a very anti-LLM position in general

Yes.

And no, that's not the position of the Linux kernel.

I realize that some people really dislike AI, but this is an area
where I'm willing to absolutely put my foot down as the top-level
maintainer.

Linux is not one of those anti-AI projects, and if somebody has issues
with that, they can do the open-source thing and fork it.

Or just walk away.

AI is a tool, just like other tools we use. And it's clearly a useful one.

It may not have been that "clearly" even just a year ago, but it's no
longer in question today.

There are other questions around AI (like what the economy of it will
actually look like in the end), but "is it useful" is no longer one of
those questions. Anybody who doubts that clearly hasn't actually used
it.

Yes, it can also be a somewhat painful tool, both for maintainer
workloads and just from a "it keeps finding embarrassing bugs"
standpoint.

But the solution is not to put your head in the sand and sing "La La
La, I can't hear you" at the top of your voice like some people seem
to do.

The solution is to make sure those LLM tools help maintainers
instead of just causing them pain. There's no question on that side.

We're not forcing anybody to use it, but I will very loudly ignore
people who try to argue against other people from using it.

And no, AI isn't perfect. But Christ, anybody who points to the
problems at AI had better be looking in the mirror and pointing at
themselves at the same time.

Because it's not like natural intelligence is always all that great either.

The kernel project has been and will continue to be about the technology.

Sure, the social angle of working on open source is important and
often a very motivating part of the project, but in the end that's a
side benefit, not the point of the project.

This is NOT some kind of "social warrior" project, never has been,
and never will be.

In the kernel community we do open source because it results in better
technology, not because of religious reasons.

And so we make decisions primarily based on technical merit. Not fear
of new tools.

          Linus  

"

[-] Cris_Citrus@piefed.zip 18 points 4 months ago

Thank you for providing the full quote of what Linus actually said so folks have context, regardless of how people feel about the position he's taking its always really helpful to have primary sources ❤️

[-] uuj8za@piefed.social 35 points 4 months ago

And no, AI isn't perfect. But Christ, anybody who points to the problems at AI had better be looking in the mirror and pointing at themselves at the same time.

No one is saying humans are perfect either. But Christ, the scale is clearly not the same. Before, an average bad dev had a limit blast radius. Now they can push a million lines of code and write a convincing description of why this is actually correct with little effort.

later

(Oops. Wait. You're right to push back. This is totally wrong. This should have never happend.)

[-] yes_this_time@lemmy.world 13 points 4 months ago

Blast radius you say say? Claude is that you?

load more comments (1 replies)
[-] Ghoelian@piefed.social 6 points 4 months ago

I also don't use entire cities worth of power and clean water.

[-] rimu@piefed.social 35 points 4 months ago

"AI is a tool" is a thought-terminating cliche. The phrase is intended to foreclose other ways of framing the discussion.

[-] Ghoelian@piefed.social 10 points 4 months ago

Yeah, it ignores the biggest problems a lot of people have with AI. It's not the slop code, it's that it was generated at a ridiculous cost to the environment and the population around the datacenter where it was trained.

load more comments (2 replies)
[-] lambalicious@lemmy.sdf.org 21 points 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago)

Past the whole thing about theft of code, theft of wages and theft of rights, my next problem with AI is that it's viral, in even worse terms than say the GPL is viral.

Once you accept slop submissions into a project, you have the problem that someone would have to check it. But why spend your own mental and emotional energy, better dedicated to dealing with and interacting with fellow humans, to trudge through a mass of hallucinated, gaslighting crap? Better set up some AI that checks the submitted code.

And now you have two problems.

Fortunately, lists like Open Slopware exist.

Linus is severely mistaken that Linux is not a "social warrior" project, but I guess that's mostly because he's the face the community has to try and "sanitize" for corporate the posture that people like RMS have. Gone are the times where he would openly flip Nvidia the bird. Which is not bad, but it's unfortunately ill-timed: if history has taught us anything useful this decade is that, right now, bootlicking to corporate and its trends such as "uniformity" and "neutrality" is not the win you think it is.

load more comments (22 replies)
[-] WraithGear@lemmy.world 15 points 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago)

it’s not just about the removal of the human, or run away corporations, or the destruction of the planet, or the squandering of art, or social warfare

it’s that ai is FUCKING DUMB.

you spend more effort trying to catch their dumb before it gets out into the wild, and to top it off it has the whole ‘semi self driving car’ problem where the point is laziness, so obviously the focus to whip the ai in shape is constantly waneing until it fucks up bad. and then you get to blame the ai, which is the PERFECT SCAPE GOAT. on top of that it’s sycophantic, where truth in its outputs is not even in its top 10 motivating pressures. it’s got a memory that will lose older information at inconsistent rates depending on fluctuating token availability, and when it suddenly sees a gap in knowledge, it will out right LIE rather then admit a failing. it does not have a true comprehensive under standing of any topic, because the very nature of an LLM is probalistic connection of abstracted nodes representing data/text. the longer it must work on a single conversation the more polluted its weights gets! it can’t prioritize certain expectations because again, not a true comprehension of the discussion.

and you want this to develop code! something that is understood to take deep planning and concentration, and interlocking systems?

[-] HubertManne@piefed.social 11 points 4 months ago

what is a social warrior? is it some sort of shortening of social justice warrior?

[-] kbal@fedia.io 7 points 4 months ago

I suppose that due to his position Linus is forced to have some kind of opinions about it, but I am so sick of all the "AI" talk that I can't even be bothered to click the link and find out what it is.

[-] scrubbles@poptalk.scrubbles.tech 7 points 4 months ago

You would like his stance then. Very level headed.

load more comments
view more: next ›
this post was submitted on 15 Jul 2026
271 points (97.2% liked)

Linux

20061 readers
13 users here now

Welcome to c/linux!

Welcome to our thriving Linux community! Whether you're a seasoned Linux enthusiast or just starting your journey, we're excited to have you here. Explore, learn, and collaborate with like-minded individuals who share a passion for open-source software and the endless possibilities it offers. Together, let's dive into the world of Linux and embrace the power of freedom, customization, and innovation. Enjoy your stay and feel free to join the vibrant discussions that await you!

Rules:

  1. Stay on topic: Posts and discussions should be related to Linux, open source software, and related technologies.

  2. Be respectful: Treat fellow community members with respect and courtesy.

  3. Quality over quantity: Share informative and thought-provoking content.

  4. No spam or self-promotion: Avoid excessive self-promotion or spamming.

  5. No NSFW adult content

  6. Follow general lemmy guidelines.

founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS