32

cross-posted from: https://lemmy.zip/post/74661938

I recently got back into board games (thanks Tabletop Simulator!) and I found a couple Weird West board games while browsing boardgamegeek. Has anyone played these games? Have you found others you would recommend? I'm mostly interested in co-op games but that isn't a hard rule.

I haven't played any of these but so far I've found:

  • Shadows of Brimstone - This seems to be the most popular board game when it comes to a Weird West setting since it has about a hundred expansion packs. It's co-op (so I'm interested) but the rules might be a bit too complex for my simple mind. I'm curious about this one.
  • Grimslingers - First of all, I'd just like to say that "Grimslingers" is a fantastic name. I think this one is primarily a card game but it has both a co-op and versus mode and the rules seem less complex than Shadows of Brimstone, so again, I'm intrigued.
  • Dracula's America: Shadows of the West - "It is 1875, and Count Dracula is President of the United States of America." Now that's an attention-grabbing intro! I think this might actually be a game that uses miniatures from Shadows of Brimstone to set up its own wargaming scnearios. So I think it's just a rulebook and you're expected to provide your own miniatures to setup a game.
  • Grim West - This game came out in 2026. I guess it's a wargame that uses a standard deck of cards? I can't tell if buying this game just gives you the rulebook or if it requires anything more than a single deck of cards. I think the "game" might just be a single pdf rulebook?

This is what happens when I just blindly browse boardgamegeek. I come across games that sound like they have a cool aesthetic or setting but then I can't tell if it's a board game, a card game, or just a rulebook. That's why I wanted to reach out to this community and see if anyone can give me actual recommendations.

top 10 comments
sorted by: hot top new old
[-] KoboldCoterie@pawb.social 8 points 6 days ago

I've got Shadows of Brimstone; it's a fun game, but it's VERY held back by the massive space requirements (both to play and to store - it has a lot of minis and very large boxes), and the egregious setup and teardown time. However, TTS handily avoids both of these pitfalls and I'd say it's the ideal way to play it. It also has a lot of addons and expansion content that TTS lets you play with for free, so that's a nice bonus. (The abundance of minis make it a very expensive game otherwise.)

It's playable solo, and if you were going to be introducing friends to it, I might recommend playing the first scenario alone first, to familiarize yourself with the rules so you can better explain things.

It's very dice heavy, so if you dislike RNG, you might have an issue with that. The game itself is very fun, though, and if you approach it more like a roleplaying game, where each player gets into their character and you treat failures as narrative opportunities, it's a great time. You keep your characters across multiple sessions / scenarios and build up power over time, so it plays like a long-term campaign, not a series of individual sessions.

I've been keeping a roughly monthly Shadows of Brimstone game going for years (on TTS during the pandemic, in person before and since) and have had a long time to get setup and space optimized. Minis have clear cases, map tiles also get a flat case per set. All the flat stuff goes into an accordion file case. Cards go into their own case and the specific sets used at any given moment go into a vertical holder. We use character sheets and dials instead of the large character cards, tokens, and smaller cords to keep track of inventory and stats, though there's some things like character abilities that we still use small cards for. As many of the charts as possible are kept electronically. Because I've got about 5 base sets (ice, swamp, fortress, other fortress with conquistadores, other ice with vikings) and a bunch of expansions, it does add up. Over the years, I've are added some nicities including 3d printed token organizers, a deck of cash, poker chips for experience. With all that, it does take two large folding tables for a game with 6 people plus a smaller side table for the stuff that's going to be used but isn't it play yet. Everybody gets a job to do as well, so somebody runs the monsters, somebody hands out cash, somebody takes care of the deck and maps. Storage for all the stuff would take up about 8 cubes in an IKEA shelf thingy. So it's definitely not a small game after all the additions, but my group has gotten it down when it comes to set up, play, and teardown. Usually takes a few hours at a casual pace with lots of food and socializing going on as well. But it did take a bit to get there, both for organization of stuff and the play.

[-] Coelacanth@feddit.nu 5 points 6 days ago

I've wanted to play Shadow of Brimstone ever since I saw the Inside the Box episode about it years ago, but the price, space, setup time and prospect of painting hundreds of minis has kept me off. Maybe I'll look into TTS, it hadn't even crossed my mind.

[-] KoboldCoterie@pawb.social 6 points 6 days ago* (last edited 6 days ago)

Yeah, it's funny - we loved the premise, kickstarted it, and have the whole game (all of the expansions, everything) sitting on a shelf. We played it a few times, but it's such a massive slog that unless you've got a dedicated game room where you can leave it set up between sessions, or have very long game sessions, it's prohibitive to play.

Then we found it on TTS and played it a lot.

Same problem that Kingdom Death: Monster (which is one of my favorite board games) has - buying it is only really worth it if you're an enthusiast and want to dedicate a shelf to the minis and display them, or want the physical boxes. If you just want to play the game, TTS is far and away a more accessible option.

[-] Coelacanth@feddit.nu 3 points 6 days ago

How is the setup time compared to Gloomhaven? That's kind of been in the same boat for me

[-] KoboldCoterie@pawb.social 3 points 6 days ago

I've only ever played Gloomhaven on TTS, so I can't really compare to the physical game setup time, but based purely on the number of components, I'd estimate it's pretty close. Table space requirement is probably similar, too (or greater in SoB, because the 'maps' you're making from the puzzle piece terrain are larger and more sprawling in Shadows of Brimstone).

[-] jericho_cross@lemmy.zip 3 points 6 days ago

Kingdom Death: Monster? Well now I have another game to check out on TTS!

[-] KoboldCoterie@pawb.social 3 points 6 days ago* (last edited 6 days ago)

KDM isn't wierd west, so it doesn't really fit your recommendation request, but holy cow it's fun. It's brutally difficult, though; if your group isn't okay with setbacks, including losing their favorite character to an RNG event, it might not be for you. That said, it's got crazy good atmosphere and storytelling... if you like the body horror theming and fairly grotesque aesthetic..., and it's very deep. If you want to win the game (and aren't cheating), expect to have to play it multiple times from the beginning - it's usually not a game where you can just rewind 1 combat or event and be fine; when you lose, it's usually the result of cascading losses piling up over time, and by the time you realize you've lost, it's hopeless and the actual turning point was usually many hours of gameplay prior. A full game is 30 combat encounters, and each one typically takes an hour or more, so it's not a short haul.

[-] jericho_cross@lemmy.zip 4 points 6 days ago

Awesome, thank you so much for those details! Playing the game solo first (in TTS) is a great idea.

[-] mysticpickle@lemmy.ca 4 points 6 days ago

If you're looking for a lcg style card game there's also Doomtown: Reloaded. The rules are not what I'd describe as intuitive but once you get a handle in things it's a surprisingly deep and complex game!

this post was submitted on 08 Nov 2026
32 points (100.0% liked)

Board Games

2987 readers
327 users here now

Let's Play a Game! A place to discuss all things board game, regardless of genre. Everything from Scrabble and Catan to Ark Nova, 1830 and beyond is fair game! That means we have blackjack. Bring your own hookers, sorry.

Rules:

  1. Play nicely with others here.
  2. Discussion should be at least somewhat related to board games and all that entails.
  3. Self-promotion is allowed within reason. Don't go overboard!

Other comms that might be of interest:

  1. !longreads@sh.itjust.works
  2. !norway@sopuli.xyz

Other boardgame comms:

  1. !juegosdemesa@feddit.cl (Spanish)

founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS