[-] notnotmike@programming.dev 1 points 2 years ago* (last edited 2 years ago)

I don't know how to word this any differently, so I think this conversation is just about done.

You keep bringing up how science says caffeine isn't "addicting" despite you yourself being the one to point out the DSM-V where they explicitly call the word out as not defined in the DSM-V. So for the fourth time: "addicting" is not a scientific term.

Just because it was preciously referenced in a 24+ year old version does not make it still scientifically relevant. It is not a scientific term any longer, and you can stop treating it like it is.

Meanwhile, in the DSM-V, caffeine is associated with withdrawal symptoms. Symptoms you yourself have described and experienced. So we can both agree caffeine use causes withdrawal.

So because (1) "addiction" is not a medical term and (2) caffeine causes withdrawal symptoms when usage is stopped it is therefore more than fair for people to define it as addicting in a nonscientific context like the one we're in. We should reference science, sure, but science has no opinion on whether caffeine is "addicting" because, again, it's not a scientific word.

Again, you're arguing semantics. This is arguing "gif" vs "jif" at this point. You've given up on medical sources like the DSM because they don't support you so now you are just doubling down with no basis in fact.

Hopefully, we see each other around on the Fediverse and maybe even have another discussion, but one that is more beneficial for us. This one seems to be just spinning our wheels. Good luck to you

[-] notnotmike@programming.dev 1 points 2 years ago

I've said this three times now, but: There is no scientific definition of addiction, so you would have equal trouble finding meth described as addicting.

The post title concerns the common usage of the term, this is not a medical forum. A guy just had a question. You're the one who, incorrectly, brought up addiction as a medical term

[-] notnotmike@programming.dev 1 points 2 years ago

Okay, so why bring up the DSM if you don't care what it says? You seem to be missing my point.

Caffeine is addicting in the colloquial sense that you want it when you don't have it. It is not a cause of substance abuse disorder.

If Caffeine was addicting you think it is okay for children to consume it.

I never said I did and, in fact, I don't think it's okay. I'm an outlier in that fact and that's my concern and the reason I'm even in this thread.

If Caffeine was addicting it would be labelled a Substance Use Disorder, it isn't

By definition in the DSM, neither caffeine nor meth are addicting. So this is a nil point

  • Many pharmaceuticals that are absolutely not addicting (ie: many anti-depressants) still have withdrawal symptoms, therefore withdrawal symptoms /= addiction.a

Again, addiction means nothing here except a colloquialism. It is no longer a medical term. If you have a source for a strict definition in a scientific sense beyond the DSM I'd be happy to adjust our conversation accordingly

  • Addiction, when it was in the DSM-IV...

You cannot use an outdated version just because it fits your argument better. The nomenclature was changed, so adapt

I am respecting addicts

By calling them "addicts" you are immediately not respecting them, per the negative connotation and the superior alternative term which we've discussed

Trivializing the word such that caffeine counts demeans those that suffer actual addiction, and is the problem here

And sidelining a conversation about a drug to argue semantics is better? Nobody in this thread will tell you caffeine is as bad as nicotine.

My interpretation here is that you suffer from substance abuse, in the past or currently, and you feel your experience is being trivialized. If that's the case then say that instead. Don't argue about definitions out of the DSM, just state cleanly and kindly that you feel that "habit" is a better term and let the conversation about the topic continue. Don't be so aggressive and self-righteous about it and people will be more inclined to listen and change.

And if you don't suffer from substance abuse then don't get outraged by pedantics on someone else's behalf...

[-] notnotmike@programming.dev 1 points 2 years ago

Got mine today. Hoping for gentle side effects...

[-] notnotmike@programming.dev 1 points 2 years ago

Half of our arguments stem from how to interpret the analogy...

[-] notnotmike@programming.dev 1 points 2 years ago

It could also be the language choice, which one are you utilizing? I could see some languages having a worse experience than others.

I've found it is exceptionally smart with bash. It often knows what to do better than I can, because I'm no master at bash. I'm proficient enough to know when it's right though, and it's usually pretty on point.

[-] notnotmike@programming.dev 1 points 2 years ago

I've already made a Smeagol reference in this thread, but perhaps one more is in order...

[-] notnotmike@programming.dev 1 points 2 years ago

Dota players will pronounce "Abaddon" (a hero's name) like "ah-buh-don" and it's really bizarre. In their defense though, many aren't native English speakers

[-] notnotmike@programming.dev 1 points 2 years ago

There's a PR open for the feature, but doesn't look like it's actually been implemented yet.

[-] notnotmike@programming.dev 1 points 2 years ago

I would look up your local paper specifically, if you haven't already. They aren't always going to show up in search results.

My local paper often does a brief "meet the candidates" piece for the city council, so you may find the same. Although they won't have everything all the time

[-] notnotmike@programming.dev 1 points 2 years ago

I know it's an old thread but...

No, not really. I'm a pretty casual player and there's a ton of stuff in this game I still haven't done and may never do. For example, I did my first ever gauntlet run yesterday and I've been playing for years. So, the idea of an entire new skill just doesn't appeal to me; it's more incoming work that I'll need to focus on at some point.

I also don't love the idea of adding a new skill in general. There are a half dozen of skills that I would much prefer be overhauled instead, like Firemaking and Smithing, without messing up the iconic skill screen.

view more: ‹ prev next ›

notnotmike

0 post score
0 comment score
joined 3 years ago
MODERATOR OF