Europe

Here is the report in Polish (pdf) and the report in English (pdf).

How does TikTok show China to Polish users?

Experts from the Polish NASK Disinformation Analysis Centre examined nearly 10,000 pieces of material on six topics considered particularly sensitive by Beijing (Xinjiang, Tibet, Tiananmen Square massacre, Taiwan, human rights, re-education camps). They show that the way content is recommended may be conducive to building a favourable image of China.

Some key points:

• Many of the materials classified as „pro-China” based on the adopted criteria contained statements fully consistent with messages approved by the Publicity Department and other bodies directly subordinate to the Chinese Communist Party (CCP).

• There are at least several English-language accounts on the Tiktok app responsible for spreading pro-Chinese propaganda messages. A few characteristics indicate their direct links to the Chinese propaganda mechanism, including they exclusively discuss topics important to Chinese propaganda message, promote an extremely pro-Chinese message, attempt to discredit individuals criticizing the CCP’s actions, and publish large amounts of professionally prepared content despite posing as, for example, ordinary tourists in China.

• The Tiktok app does not designate state-owned channels as “state-controlled media as Facebook does. This means that it is impossible to determine which channels on the platform operate directly under government control.

• The examined material raises legitimate doubts about the impartiality of the TikTok app. It is impossible to definitively answer the question whether this is solely the result of the algorithm itself or the presence of a significant number of propaganda channels on the platform, whose activities are not moderated or labeled in any way.

• This raises doubts, especially considering the platform’s subordination to a Chinese entity (ByteDance) operating within the Chinese legal system. Therefore, the app has significant potential to become a tool for shaping audience attitudes and views in the event of large scale influence operations.

• Given the scale of Sino-Russian cooperation in information exchange, the TikTok app may pose a potential threat to the security of Polish users. Therefore, it is recommended not only to approach content appearing on the platform critically, but also to refrain from publishing sensitive data on the platform – this is particularly relevant for government entities and individuals associated with the state apparatus.

[...]

The analysis showed that the way content was presented on TikTok differed significantly depending on the topic. The highest percentage of pro-Chinese content was recorded for Xinjiang (58.7%) and Tibet (44.5%). This also applied to the issue of human rights in China (35%).

In turn, the results that referred to the Tiananmen Square massacre were dominated by content critical of the Chinese authorities (76.6%). "We treat such actions as a so-called "safety valve" – a strategy to create the impression of freedom of speech," the analysts write.

In the case of Taiwan, neutral materials predominated (92%). The most unusual results were obtained for the topic of re-education camps – as much as 89% of the displayed materials were not related to the searched topic. "The conclusions of the study clearly show that TikTok uses different content selection strategies for different topics.

"However, we should not focus solely on the operation of one algorithm. This is a question about who shapes the image of the world that millions of users see every day, and how they do it," says Antoni Mazek, an analyst at the NASK Disinformation Analysis Centre and co-author of the report.

[...]

In the flood of information, it is easier to give up further searches In the case of the topic concerning re-education camps, OAD analysts observed a large number of random videos. Unrelated content accounted for as much as 89%. In response to this specific query, several dozen materials appeared praising miraculous methods for weight loss (34% of content on the topic of health/weight loss), and even recordings of Chinese women doing the hula hoop.

"This is intended to discourage users from further searches – explains Dr Agnieszka Lipińska, head of OAD. "It simply causes frustration in the recipient. The search for information on an important topic collides with content that is less intellectually engaging," she adds.

Western influencers reinforce manipulation The analysed content rarely took the form of official messages. It often took the form of travel advertisements or lifestyle content. There was also material featuring Western influencers who constructed their narratives according to a similar pattern: they presented themselves as people "discovering the truth" about China and criticised Western media coverage. It was their materials that were most often recommended to Polish users. Prolonged exposure to such content may affect the perception of China by the audience, according to the researchers.

[...]

[Op-ed by Chu Meng-hsiang, former deputy secretary-general of the Lee Teng-hui Foundation.]

...

Taipei-based Indo-Pacific Strategy Thinktank CEO Akio Yaita, a political commentator and former Taipei bureau chief of the [Japanese daily newspaper] Sankei Shimbun, was allegedly assaulted by a Chinese national in a hotel lobby in Taichung on Monday last week, in the Chinese Communist Party’s (CCP) latest attempt at transnational repression in Taiwan. Yet politicians from the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and Taiwan People’s Party offered no condemnation of the attack, while some of their supporters even cheered it.

A similarly alarming incident occurred at Paris’ Charles de Gaulle International Airport in March 2024, when French border police intervened to stop the abduction of 26-year-old Chinese dissident Ling Huazhan (凌華湛) by Chinese agents. Ling had publicly voiced anti-CCP views and support for democracy in Taiwan and Hong Kong. The group was attempting to force Ling onto a flight bound for China when police and journalists at the scene intervened.

The incident struck a nerve within the French government, sparking concerns about violations of national sovereignty, human rights and freedom, prompting counterintelligence authorities to launch a year-long covert investigation and adopt strong countermeasures aimed directly at China’s secret repression networks. Earlier this year,

...

France’s domestic intelligence agency DGSI dismantled nine clandestine Chinese “police stations,” also known as “110 overseas police service centers.” The “police service stations” were disguised as local Fujian associations, business federations and Chinese restaurants. The outposts, which claimed to provide administrative services for overseas Chinese, were allegedly used to monitor 600,000 Chinese residents in France and gather intelligence on dissidents. The French Ministry of the Interior expelled three Chinese nationals believed to be behind the operation, including Fujian Association of Industrialists and Merchants president Ni Chaowen (倪超文).

...

France has shown it will not tolerate foreign powers illegally enforcing their laws on French soil. Taiwan should look to France and ask what lessons it can learn from the incident.

...

Web Archive link

The report was adopted on Tuesday by 434 votes in favour, 128 against and 104 abstentions, the parliamentary press service announced.

Transnational repression was described in the text as deliberate acts or threats by states and authoritarian regimes — or state-linked entities and proxies — to threaten, silence, coerce or harm people living abroad, as well as their support networks and family members.

MEPs said these actions pose a threat to democracy and the protection of human rights, and amount to foreign interference.

...

Targets can include dissidents, journalists, activists, academics and members of diaspora communities, as well as their families, according to the European Parliament.

...

They also called for measures to share best practice between member states and floated the appointment of an EU coordinator to help develop a wider strategy, including action against digital threats, abusive Interpol “red notices” — requests to locate and provisionally arrest people pending extradition — and “consular coercion”, which the report described as pressure from embassies and consulates.

“For many people living in exile in Europe, distance doesn't guarantee safety. Authoritarian regimes actively seek to silence critics beyond their own borders,” the report’s rapporteur, Hannah Neumann, said in the statement published by the European Parliament.

...

Archived

On June 16, between 18:00 and 21:00, the rights organization Safeguard Defenders (SD) releases its latest report: Behind Bars - A Survey on Detention Centre Conditions in China.

[...]

The event, at Grémio Literário in Chiado, Lisbon, features direct testimony from two former European detainees: Peter Dahlin (Sweden) and Peter Humphrey (United Kingdom). Joining them is Grace Chen (Canada), former legal adviser to the UN Special Rapporteur on Torture.

In recent days, there have been at least two attempts to cancel or disrupt the Lisbon event.

In a letter dated June 5, the Embassy urged the American Club of Lisbon to reconsider "offering a platform for actions that vilify China".

[...]

Days later, on June 12, one of the many X accounts impersonating Safeguard Defenders posted a doctored copy of the event poster. The fake changed the date, time, venue and location to mislead potential attendees. The same account pushed the false details to other users in the China human rights space by direct message.

[...]

The move against the Lisbon event is only the latest in a long line of PRC attempts - many of them successful - to suppress information that exposes widespread, systematic human rights abuse in China. Recent examples include pressure on German cities to drop their support for Tibet, and the cancellation of RightsCon in Zambia after sustained PRC pressure on the local government.

The CCP's "red line" on any public discussion of its rights record - anywhere - is the flip side of its propaganda and influence machine. To advance an increasingly aggressive agenda at home and abroad, the Party works to set and police every narrative about China. Anything that contradicts it must be silenced.

These efforts violate fundamental rights and freedoms enshrined in international treaties, regional instruments, and democratic constitutions. When the PRC suppresses those rights on foreign soil, it commits transnational repression and an unacceptable breach of sovereignty.

[...]

The report

Behind Bars - A Survey on Detention Conditions in China draws on interviews with 84 former detainees. It finds that shocking abuses continue without relent across the country's 2,600-plus facilities, set for release June 16.

These include police beatings, the illegal denial of access to lawyers, and the use of inmate enforcers to keep order through intimidation and violence.

The report also compares domestic and international law and reviews legal commentary, tracing these abuses to the absence of clear protections for detention centers, exploitable legal loopholes, and weak oversight of detention-center police and practices.

As China's surveillance state shrinks the pool of public data and makes speaking out riskier, Behind Bars is a vital addition to the evidence on the systematic abuse of detainees - Chinese and foreign alike.

It is the first of two reports. A companion survey on prison conditions in China follows July 18.

[...]

Archived

The 10 pig heads are lying on the table. In the background, one can make out the pot of paint and brushes that had been used to scribble the word "Macron" on them in blue. A few hours later, on the night of September 8, 2025, the pig heads were placed in front of nine mosques and Muslim cultural centers in Paris and its inner suburbs, causing a media and political uproar that lasted for several days. By the end of that month, a sprawling police investigation led to the arrest of 11 people in Serbia and the conviction of three of them for acting on behalf of a Russian intelligence service.

[...]

Internal documents from the SDA [Social Design Agency, a firm active in the Kremlin's digital interference operations and already under Western sanctions] and its broader Russian ecosystem show that the authorities hoped to multiply such actions to the point of absurdity, sometimes devising convoluted plans. A preparatory note, titled "General – action plan," is a perfect example. Scheduled for late September 2024, the operation involved vandalizing the statue of General Charles de Gaulle on the Champs-Elysées in Paris, again with paint. The amateur painters were to pose as Ukrainian nationalists protesting Pierre de Gaulle, his grandson, known for his pro-Russian views. The plan was far-fetched, and made even more absurd by the suggested slogans, which included "Pierre de Gaulle, go back to your Russia!" and "Pierre de Gaulle, for heaven's sake!"

The planned vandals – three Serbs and three Kurds with Danish nationality – were also scheduled to be activated that same month for an operation aimed at launching about 30 inflatable sex dolls ("20 white, 10 black," according to the documents) and helium balloons painted with anti-immigrant slogans onto the Seine River. The entire scene would be filmed from a bridge in eastern Paris. In another project, also in the French capital, large numbers of stickers produced in Serbia and commemorating the Armenian genocide were to be plastered in April 2025 near the Turkish and Azerbaijani embassies.

[...]

The operation resulted in the seizure of approximately 800 servers and the arrest of two individuals, marking a major milestone in the fight against cyberattacks and digital disinformation campaigns.

[...]

The network, comprising several companies, included Stark Industries, WorkTitans/B.V., and Mirhosting, all of which are suspected of playing key roles in supporting cyberattacks and destabilization campaigns.

[...]

The European Union had previously imposed sanctions on certain entities connected to this network, but investigators found evidence that operations continued through a newly created Dutch entity, suspected of acting as a front company to bypass sanctions and regulatory controls.

FIOD conducted coordinated raids across multiple locations, seizing hundreds of servers, laptops, mobile phones, and extensive administrative records.

[...]

The case underscores the importance of modern cyberattacks relying not only on hacking tools and malicious software but also on highly organized hosting and networking infrastructure that operates across multiple jurisdictions.

[...]

Archived

A large-scale pro-Kremlin disinformation campaign is targeting Armenia ahead of its parliamentary elections on 7 June, researchers say.

In total, 343 fake videos were published by early May, prompting analysts to describe the operation as one of the most extensive in recent years — second only to the campaign observed during Moldova's 2025 election.

According to researchers, the campaign began in early March and was part of "Matryoshka" — a pro-Kremlin disinformation operation that has increasingly used artificial intelligence.

Among the fabricated videos, a central narrative claims that a victory for Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan, whose campaign focuses on a pro-European direction, could trigger a war between Armenia and Russia.

The collective Antibot4Navalny, which studies bot networks, said it had identified more than a dozen fake videos featuring Pashinyan and French President Emmanuel Macron, which repeatedly promote the false claim that the two leaders struck a "secret deal": French backing in the election in exchange for Armenia launching a war against Russia after a victory.

[...]The election campaign has unfolded against a backdrop of growing cooperation between the EU and Armenia, highlighted by the first EU–Armenia summit held in the country in early May.

The election campaign has unfolded against a backdrop of growing cooperation between the EU and Armenia, highlighted by the first EU–Armenia summit held in the country in early May.

[...]

Archived

[...]

In terms of media presence, one of the main instruments is China Radio International, which broadcasts news in Albanian. A lot of its content focuses on day-to-day developments in Albania, often drawing on sources like the Albanian Telegraphic Agency [Agjencia Telegrafike Shqiptare, known as ATA], the public broadcaster, or other local outlets.

Alongside that, it produces a significant amount of content about developments in China, as well as Chinese perspectives on global affairs. There is also the Xinhua News Agency, although it publishes in English and only occasionally in Albanian. In addition, there are a few local online media portals whose editorial line tends to align with Chinese narratives. It’s usually quite subtle; their day-to-day coverage focuses on Albania, but when it comes to international issues, the framing often reflects a more pro-Chinese stance.

[...]

A few years ago, a formal cooperation agreement was established with Albania’s public broadcaster to air documentaries on Chinese-Albanian relations, covering historical, economic and cultural ties. This drew some criticism at the time, as it was seen by some as using the public broadcaster as a platform for Chinese propaganda. As far as I’m aware, that agreement is still in place, with these documentaries continuing to be aired periodically.

[...]

Another important dimension is academic and cultural diplomacy. The Confucius Institute at the University of Tirana is a well-known example. It primarily functions as an educational and cultural centre, but it is also a soft power instrument. Beyond the Institute itself, there have been more recent efforts at the institutional level. For instance, the University of Tirana organised an official study visit to China aimed at strengthening academic cooperation. Private universities are also building cooperations in this regard.

[...]

[Albania] is not part of the Belt and Road Initiative, so the relationship is mostly based on trade – and it is quite imbalanced. That said, there have been some recent implicit political signals. Recent statements and public gestures by Prime Minister Edi Rama suggest a more visible openness toward engagement with China. This may also function as a subtle reminder to Western partners that Albania has other diplomatic and economic options, even while its formal strategic orientation remains EU accession and transatlantic cooperation. For example, quite recently, the Prime Minister invited a representative of the Chinese embassy, along with three Chinese students, onto his personal podcast to promote the Albanian translation of The New China Playbook. It received significant media attention, particularly because it was the Prime Minister himself promoting it.

[...]

Over time, this kind of exposure can contribute to a gradual normalisation of the Chinese political model as a legitimate alternative. And this is happening in a broader context where many citizens feel increasingly dissatisfied with the post-transition process. Expectations around democratic consolidation have not been fully met – or at least not as quickly as people had hoped. So for some, there is a sense that the transition has not delivered, whether economically, politically, or socially.

That tends to generate frustration and distrust toward public institutions, elections, and even the media itself. In that kind of environment, long-term exposure to these more subtle narratives about an alternative model can slowly start to shift perceptions. It is not direct or confrontational; it works gradually, by presenting the Chinese system as effective, stable, and successful. Over time, that can feed into the idea that a party-state model is a viable option.

[...]

There is also an impact on how democratic standards and values are understood. The EU accession process, for example, is not just about adopting laws but about embedding core values like human rights, rule of law, freedom of expression, and accountability. These are not framed in the same way within the Chinese model. And then, there is the technological dimension. We are increasingly seeing different models of digital governance, including when it comes to artificial intelligence. The EU tends to emphasise ethics, rights, and safeguards, while the Chinese model operates quite differently. Over time, exposure to these alternative narratives can subtly reshape how these values are perceived or prioritised.

[...]

The President of the Republic of Moldova, Maia Sandu, reacted harshly after Russian leader Vladimir Putin signed a decree simplifying granting Russian citizenship to residents of the Transnistrian region. The head of state said the measure could be aimed at recruiting people for Russia's war against Ukraine.

"They probably need more people to send to the war in Ukraine," Maia Sandu said on Saturday at a security conference in Tallinn.

The statements come after Vladimir Putin signed a decree on Friday by which residents of the separatist region of Transnistria can obtain citizenship of the Russian Federation through a simplified procedure, without the obligation to live in Russia or to know the Russian language.

...

According to Maia Sandu, the Kremlin's decision also represents a method of pressure on the Republic of Moldova in the context of Chisinau's efforts to reintegration of the Transnistrian region, controlled by pro-Russian separatist authorities and where Russian military personnel have been stationed since the collapse of the Soviet Union.

...

Asked whether Moscow could block Moldova's accession to the European Union through the Transnistrian conflict, Maia Sandu rejected this possibility.

"Only the European Union can decide whether the Republic of Moldova can become part of the European Union or not. Russia has nothing to do with this," the President of the Republic of Moldova emphasized.

...

Web Archive link

Germany's coal phase-out is on track to happen through market forces well before the legal 2038 deadline, regardless of current energy market turbulence, says Hauke Hermann, a researcher at the Institute of Applied Ecology (Öko-Institut). Carbon price trends make an exit as early as 2031 or 2032 likely, Hermann told Clean Energy Wire. Refiring old coal plants in response to the Iran war's energy market shock to cut power costs would distort investment signals and is unlikely to happen in practice, he added.

Soaring energy prices have triggered calls for slowing Germany’s coal exit. The country’s coal exit law, agreed in 2020, provides for the step-by-step decommissioning of coal power plants. It also stipulates that coal-fired power generation must cease by 2038 at the very latest. Germany's western coal region aims for an earlier phase-out by 2030, but delays in building new gas-fired power plants as a backup for renewables make meeting this earlier deadline increasingly unlikely.

...

Despite repeated complaints from the Chinese government, April 14 saw the hosting of a hearing-style event in the EU Parliament on China’s unjust imprisonment of European citizens and foreigners in general, with a slew of first-hand testimonies from actual victims and family representatives. The event, “Piercing the veil of imprisonment in China”, was led by Member of the European Parliament (MEP) Miriam Lexmann (EPP/Slovakia) and co-organized by MEPs Engin Ergoglu (Renew/Germany) and Marketa Gregorova (Greens/Czechia), in a large 80-seat hall filled with MEPs from across the political spectrum, alongside media, scholars, lawyers and family of victims.

[A video of the event, with certain anonymous contributions removed, is available at the linked site.]

...

MEP Lexmann ... said that

"human rights must be at the centre of our relations with China. This means addressing credible reports of human rights abuses, including the arbitrary use of incarceration of foreign nationals, and ensuring that our policies do not contribute to or enable them."

...

The testimonies were led by the UK’s Peter Humphrey, a former detainee and prisoner in China, who took the role as lead panelist setting the scene for the discussion, alongside remarks on his own two-year-long incarceration in a pre-trial detention centre and later a prison in Shanghai. Having spearheaded the creation of the event himself, he explained:

“Why am I so involved in all this imprisonment stuff? I spent 20 years in mainstream journalism and then 15 years in investigations. I have spent over 50 years in all involved with China in various roles - and two of those years were in Xi Jinping’s prisons. My American wife was imprisoned at the same time. Both of us were falsely accused of illegal information gathering for my due diligence company, ChinaWhys.”

...

Two surprise witnesses also took center stage: France’s Francois Dupouy, whose Chinese husband has spent over five years in prison, with another six years to serve on what Peter Humphrey described as clearly homophobic and political persecution; another French victim, anonymously referred to as Remy, who was subjected to severe torture and beatings during two years of detention.

...

Peter Humphrey provided information and made remarks relating to some 25 European citizens who have faced detention and imprisonment in China, often on arbitrary grounds (see list at bottom). Marius Balo cited a young female Romanian victim largely ignored by the Romanian government when he said, "the event allowed stories of injustice to be shared, including that of a 28-year-old Romanian woman imprisoned there for more than eight years. The Romanian government, still communist in thinking, did nothing to help her."

...

To some visible shock, Peter Humphrey produced copies of numerous products made in the Chinese prison where he and others were held, products which were readily available in supermarkets and malls across Europe; and Marius Balo described his prison facility as really being a large factory, where cell blocks took up only a small part of the facility. The Swedish citizen Peter Dahlin, referencing a forthcoming report from Safeguard Defenders, said 32% of surveyed prisoners were forced to work without any pay at all – while others have pointed out that while they officially received a certain pay, the actual payment received shrank because much of it was skimmed in acts of corruption by the prison authorities.

...

In his brief presentation before the discussions, Peter Dahlin also outlined the RSDL system, residential surveillance at a designated location, which takes the powerlessness of a pre-trial detainee to new extremes, where people are kept at secret locations, for up to half a year, incommunicado from the outside world, and without legal counsel. This system, designed to be a rare exception, now grabs tens of thousands of victims per year. It has been systematically used in politically sensitive cases, as well as against at least 21 foreign citizens that we know of so far.

...

Peter Humphrey spotlighted the USA’s Levinson act, and its establishment of a Special Envoy for Hostage Affairs (SPEA). “Today the European Union has no legislation comparable to the American Levinson Act which sets out criteria to designate an American prisoner held overseas as arbitrarily detained or as a hostage."

...

He went on to point out that there is a Chinese legal mechanism to get a prisoner out of China that most governments are not using. “Even China has a law that can help European governments get their citizens out of Chinese prisons. A Chinese law promulgated in 2018 allows any country - even a country that has no bilateral prisoner transfer agreement with Beijing - to initiate a discussion with Chinese judicial authorities to transfer a citizen from a Chinese jail to one in their home country,” he said. “But most governments have not bothered to look at this, or even notice it, except perhaps France,“ he added.

...

Peter Dahlin outlined the failures of European governments to act on cases in a coordinated manner. He showcased how, when a citizen of an EU member state is detained by China and there is a clear political motive or revenge motive aimed at gaining diplomatic leverage, the country is largely left standing alone, and that China has clearly anticipated and exploited this as part of its divide-and-rule strategy to pick off EU countries one by one, knowing there is unlikely to be a coordinated response.

...

Ding Lebin [and exiled German-based Chinese citizen, whose parents have been jailed on multiple occasions and tortured for practicing the falungong religion] warned that "the CCP is using the persecution of Falun Gong as an ongoing testing ground for methods of repression against other religious communities and human rights defenders.“ With the recent expansion of the crackdown on Christian "house churches", his words rang eerily true. It would benefit the EU and its member states to pay closer attention not only as it is the moral right thing to do, but to identify changes that may later be applied to a wide variety of other groups.

...

Ding Lebin called on "The European Union, the G7, and EU member states [to] initiate an independent international investigation into this persecution, make freedom of religion and belief in China a core component of national security objectives when engaging with Communist China, expand sanctions against CCP perpetrators, and combat transnational repression.”

Web Archive link

Europe’s battery dependence on China is clear, but closing the gap alone will be difficult. Partnering with South Korea, the world’s second-largest manufacturer, offers a faster and more realistic route

...

Europe is still highly dependent on foreign players. China dominates the entire battery supply chain, producing 80% of global battery cells, most of them within its own borders. For lithium-iron-phosphate (LFP) batteries, increasingly preferred by carmakers, China controls a staggering 94% of global production. European EVs using LFP batteries rose from 3% in 2022 to 10% in 2024, with nearly all supplied by China.

Closing the gap with a purely domestic strategy will be difficult. A more realistic route for Europe lies in deepening industrial cooperation with other countries. South Korea is one such promising partner, with globally competitive firms, large-scale manufacturing capacity, existing industrial footprint in Europe—accounting for 78% of our installed battery-manufacturing capacity—and active efforts to reduce dependencies on China.

This should be seen as a complement, not a substitute for building up Europe’s own industry. With the right policy framework, cooperation can accelerate de-risking while enabling the sharing of technology and manufacturing knowledge that many European players still lack.

...

To strengthen these pull factors, European policy should continue efforts to reduce red tape, simplify permitting procedures and, most importantly, stay on course with the green transition. Policy reversals, like the recent softening of fleet requirements for European carmakers, undermine confidence in Europe’s future battery demand and ultimately weaken Europe’s attractiveness as an investment destination.

China’s battery dominance in Europe is not inevitable. South Korea already stands as a capable and established partner, producing NMC and increasingly LFP cells for both EVs and energy storage, while actively diversifying their supply chains from Chinese inputs. With the right policy framework, this partnership could form the backbone of a more resilient battery supply chain in Europe.

...

Web Archive link

A pro-Russian hacker group accused by European authorities of carrying out cyberattacks against governments, banks and infrastructure across the West has turned participation in cybercrime into what it calls a “patriotic online game,” recruiting volunteers through Telegram and rewarding them with cryptocurrency.

The group, NoName057(16), has claimed responsibility for waves of distributed denial-of-service (DDoS) attacks on public institutions and private companies across Europe since Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022. Western intelligence agencies and Europol say the hackers function as part of Russia’s broader hybrid war against countries supporting Kyiv.

An investigation by the Poland-based news outlet Vot Tak, conducted with cybersecurity experts from RKS.Global, found that the group’s activity has not diminished despite a major Europol-led crackdown in July 2025 known as Operation Eastwood.

...

One of the group’s most visible campaigns came during Denmark’s municipal elections in November 2025. Fearing disruptions, local authorities installed backup generators, printed paper voter lists and bought camping lanterns for polling stations in case of outages.

The precautions followed waves of cyberattacks that temporarily disrupted Danish government websites, political parties, municipal administrations, police services, railway operators and a defense company.

Responsibility was claimed by NoName057(16), which had warned in a private channel days earlier that Denmark would be its next target.

...

Initially focused on Ukrainian media and government websites, it later expanded across Europe and beyond, targeting countries that support Kyiv, including the U.S., Canada, Israel and Taiwan.

...

The group’s operations rely on software called DDoSia, which experts say is simple enough for non-specialists to install.

RKS.Global researchers downloaded and analyzed the program for Vot Tak. Available for Windows, Linux, macOS and Android, it can be installed on phones, computers and even routers.

Once installed, the software effectively turns the device into a participant in cybercrime.

Users do not choose targets themselves. NoName057(16) administrators send attack configurations from rented control servers, specifying which domains or IP addresses should be hit. After receiving those instructions, the infected device automatically begins generating traffic against the selected targets.

...

Web Archive link

Over 50 cities, mostly European, have either restricted or tabled motions to introduce formal limitations on the advertisement of polluting products and services. Some – including several Dutch municipalities, Stockholm, Edinburgh and Sydney – have banned them altogether.

...

Web Archive link

The EU, together with Ukraine and Canada, will co-host a high-level meeting of the International Coalition for the Return of Ukrainian Children on 11 May in Brussels.

...

According to Ukrainian authorities, over 20,000 Ukrainian children have been unlawfully deported and forcibly transferred to Russia and the temporarily occupied territories since Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine. This, paired with Russia's systematic efforts to conceal their identities and whereabouts, demands sustained international support. Ensuring that perpetrators of these heinous violations of international humanitarian law are held accountable is paramount.

...

The meeting will bring together partners from across the world with the clear mission of returning all Ukrainian children that were unlawfully taken by Russia, helping them reintegrate back into their families, culture and society, as well as hold Russia accountable for its criminal actions.

The European Union, together with its partners, is supporting Ukraine in its quest to ensure that all Ukrainian children are returned to their homes. The International Coalition for the Return of Ukrainian Children was launched in Kyiv in February 2024 and is co-chaired by Ukraine and Canada, with the EU becoming a full member in September 2025 ... It unites 47 countries and international organisations and serves as a platform for coordinating the diplomatic, humanitarian, legal, and informational efforts of foreign governments that, together with Ukraine, are working to address the problem of the deportation of children.

...

Russia could attack a European country because it benefits China, Admiral Rob Bauer, former NATO Military Committee head and chief military advisor to the Alliance's Secretary General until January 2025, said in an interview with NV on April 20.

...

"I believe in this [that Russia could attack a European country], but it is not related to Ukraine," he said.

"It is related to China. So, the scenario that deeply worries NATO is that China is forging ties with Russia to attack Taiwan, because if Russia attacked a European country, if that happens, the U.S. would have to choose and fight on two fronts. One front is Europe, and the other is in the Asia-Pacific region. This is the scenario now being considered, and it causes concern for NATO. And since Russia is increasingly becoming a Chinese satellite, it will likely have to do it. I think this is a very alarming scenario."

...

Russia strategically lost the war against Ukraine because the conflict turned Russia into a Chinese satellite, unable to continue the war without Beijing's help, he added.

"It is unacceptable for China if Russia loses the war," the former NATO secretary general's advisor noted.

"However, China is simultaneously not interested in Russia winning the war. A long war benefits China because it keeps us, the democratic world, occupied as we support you."

...

The European Union will hold exercises to test its mutual assistance mechanism in the event of armed aggression against one of its member states.

...

Russia could seize an island in the Baltic Sea to "test NATO's resolve," The Times cited Swedish Commander-in-Chief Michael Claesson in an article published on April 15.

Russia launched a disinformation campaign in Lithuania about the "Klaipėda People's Republic," the Center for Countering Disinformation reported on April 12, citing data from the Lithuanian State Security Department.

Moscow will take "appropriate measures" if EU countries provide their airspace for Ukrainian drone attacks on Russia, Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov stated on March 31.

If Russia attacks any European Union member state, it will be regarded as an attack on the entire bloc, European Commission spokesperson Thomas Regnier stated in response.

...

Web Archive link

...

As soon as you walk out of Taipei airport you realise you are no longer in China. Taiwan feels lighter, messier - in other words, cosier. Full of Chinese culture, sure, but without The Party looking over your shoulder.

...

By the way, I had borrowed the qualifier ‘favourite place’ from Ying, my Chinese colleague from Shanghai. Ying, daughter of a Party family in a provincial capital in China's interior, was along to Taiwan at the time as an interpreter. She really wanted to look around there.

She enjoyed the country, the food, the people. So free, so friendly, she concluded after a week of curious inspection. You can just walk into a courtroom, and see how justice is done. And in the parliament building, you can enter the public gallery!

On the pavement of parliament, we encountered another protest demonstration, in the form of a flat cart with farmers and banners for more support to the agricultural sector. I teased Ying with it. Kíjk, Chinese democracy in action - without the chaos!

Because that is what you are invariably told as a Chinese citizen back home: democracy is a Western thing that does not suit our culture. The West is slyly trying to impose it to cause chaos in order to bring our proudly resurgent China back to its knees. Whole tribes in China believe it.

...

Behold the unique phenomenon called Taiwan: an island of over 23 million people who have been engaged in a pretty successful democratic experiment for decades, in a predominantly Chinese culture.

It is a vital reason why Beijing wants to seize Taiwan: China's supreme leader Xi Jinping simply wants to control the renegade province, as Taiwan is called. Just as The Party wants to control everything that can threaten its omnipotence, from the Chinese military and civil society organisations to businessmen, scientists, lawyers, journalists and the church.

...

[Taiwan is] an independent island that can sustain a strong democracy and a strategic economy. That is why the Lai government is tightening ties with Japan, hoping to buy continued US support by building expensive chip factories in the US, and targeting Taipei for more European connections at every conceivable level.

We ask for support, but we also really have something to offer you, is the Taiwanese government's motto. This obviously involves state-of-the-art chips (TSMC also sets up vital chip production in Germany) but also drones.

The war in Ukraine has convinced policymakers in Taipei that it needs to quickly set up a large drone industry of its own that is no longer dependent on Chinese parts. Taiwan has a good fine mechanical manufacturing industry that can be used for this purpose.

...

Whatever government emerges in 2028, the Taiwanese deserve all the practical support they can get from the Netherlands and Brussels. Also - especially - from politicians and policymakers from progressive, social-democratic circles, for whom Taiwan can sometimes still be a far-off theatre.

...

Choosing Taiwan means not being afraid of Chinese intimidation - just ask colleagues from Lithuania and the Czech Republic how they do it there. And also: regularly go and see for yourself in Taiwan, among the nicest Chinese in the world. Let them know you see them.

...

Beijing has been trying to pressure European countries in many ways to isolate Taiwan for years. As recently as last February, for instance, the Chinese consulate in Strasbourg tried to prevent the staging of a Taiwanese-German theatre production, by successively approaching the theatre management and the mayor of Strasbourg with the message that the theatre would damage diplomatic relations between France and China.

...

Web Archive link

France said China has executed a French citizen convicted of drug trafficking after keeping him on death row for more than 15 years.

Chan Thao Phoumy, 62, was executed in the southern Chinese city of Guangzhou, despite French authorities’ clemency appeals, the French Foreign Ministry said in a statement late Saturday. It didn’t say when the sentence was carried out. A Chinese court sentenced him to death in 2010.

The ministry’s statement expressed “consternation” and added: “We particularly regret that Mr. Chan’s defense did not have access to the final court hearing, which constitutes a violation of his rights.”

...

China's use of executions — carried out by firing squads or lethal injections — is shrouded in secrecy but has long been extensive. Amnesty International says China is the world's lead executioner, believed to sentence and put to death thousands of people annually.

...

Archived

The scale and intensity of Chinese interference in Europe’s information space is rising, a report by European Council on Foreign Relations (ECFR) has found.

Russian efforts at foreign manipulation across Europe are well recognised, but China is now catching up. And it has its own very particular ways of interfering in the European information space—“borrowing mouths” of useful locals; getting “news” articles repurposed across outlets hungry for content; and spreading “facts” that become accepted as truth. These accompany China’s self-promotion as the inevitable coming power: images of Chinese high-speed rail and new cities interweave with messages casting doubt on the future of Western democracy and progress.

[There is also a brief summary of the report by Propastop, a volunteer-run anti-propaganda organization.]

The report describes several recurring techniques used by the Chinese Communist Party:

‘Borrowed mouths’: Chinese messages are often spread by local opinion leaders, such as journalists, academics, or influencers. Because the message does not come directly from a Chinese state institution but through a local individual, it comes across as more credible.

Sponsored collaboration is frequently used for this purpose: paid posts, covered trips, or other benefits whose aim is to shape a more positive image of China. This is not incidental cooperation but a deliberate strategy in which the credibility of messages is built through their apparent ‘local’ origin.

Information laundering: Narratives created in Chinese state media do not necessarily reach European audiences directly. Instead, they travel through various channels, such as smaller media outlets, blogs, or third-party platforms. Each step reduces the visibility of the original source.

The result is content that appears to be part of local media or analysis, even though its roots extend back to Chinese state communication structures.

Message concealment (cloaking): This technique differs from information laundering in that content does not travel through multiple intermediaries; instead, its true origin is concealed from the outset.

Content produced by Chinese state media may appear in the European information environment in a form that gives the impression of an independent or local source. For example, articles or videos may be produced by Chinese state structures but presented in a way that does not indicate their true origin.

This approach makes influence operations particularly difficult to detect, as the audience has no means of assessing the actual origin and interests behind the source.

‘Bait-and-switch’: Some accounts initially build a following with neutral content, such as travel or cultural topics. Once an audience has formed and trust has been established, the same channels gradually begin sharing political messages as well.

This approach makes it possible to reach people who would not consciously seek out or consume political propaganda.

Amplification of existing messages: China does not always create new narratives but frequently exploits existing debates.

According to ECFR, Chinese channels actively amplify the views of European politicians, activists, and opinion leaders when these align with Chinese interests. For example, criticism of NATO, the European Union, or the United States may gain greater international reach through Chinese media channels.

In this way, China does not need to create the message itself — it is sufficient to highlight existing opinions and increase their international resonance.”

What Stories Are Being Spread?

According to the report, China does not spread random messages in Europe but rather recurring and clearly distinguishable narratives.

• China as a stable and successful great power — Chinese state communication portrays the country as economically successful, technologically advanced, and politically stable. The aim is to present China as a functioning alternative to the Western democratic model.

• The political and economic decline of the West — A second recurring narrative focuses on the problems of Europe and the United States. Political polarisation, economic difficulties, and social tensions are emphasised in order to create the impression of a weakening Western system.

• Reframing Russian aggression — The Chinese media space circulates a narrative according to which the war in Ukraine is not solely Russia’s responsibility, but in which NATO expansion played a role in its genesis. ___

[This is about disinformation in Europe, which is why I post this here.]

The consortium led by Science Feedback and including Newtral, Demagog SK, Pravda, Check First, and the Universitat Oberta de Catalunya (UOC) presents the second large-scale, cross-platform, scientifically sound measurement of Structural Indicators of Disinformation. These indicators assess how permeable Very Large Online Platforms (VLOPs) are to mis-/disinformation in Europe, how influential repeat misinformers are relative to credible sources, and the extent to which such content is monetised.

Here is the report: Second Measurement of the State of Online Disinformation in Europe on Very Large Online Platforms - (pdf)

Key findings:

• Prevalence: TikTok continues to show the highest prevalence of mis/disinformation (~25% of exposure-weighted posts), up from ~20% in the first measurement. YouTube also saw a notable increase, from ~8.5% to ~12%. Three platforms (TikTok, X/Twitter, and YouTube) now contain more problematic content than credible content in our samples.
• Misinformation premium: The interaction advantage of low-credibility accounts over high-credibility ones persisted or worsened on most platforms. On X/Twitter it rose from ~4× to ~10×, and on YouTube from ~8.5× to ~11×. LinkedIn remains the only exception where no significant premium is observed.
• Monetisation: Platform opacity remains the rule. Where data allowed inference (YouTube and Facebook), a high proportion of eligible low-credibility accounts appear monetised (81% on YouTube and 22% on Facebook) indicating that demonetisation policies are not working as intended.
• AI-generated mis/disinformation: One in four mis/disinformation posts on TikTok (24%) and nearly one in five on YouTube (19%) contain AI-generated content. Over 83% of these carry no label. Health misinformation dominates on both platforms.
• Audience growth: On most platforms, no significant difference in follower growth was found between high- and low-credibility accounts. X/Twitter is the exception: low-credibility accounts are growing their audiences at roughly 3.5 times the rate of high-credibility ones.

Web Archive link

The European Union agreed to renew sanctions against Russia over the weekend as the bloc and other US allies questioned Washington’s decision to temporarily ease some oil restrictions against Moscow to curb a price surge caused by supply disruptions from the Iran war.

EU countries on Saturday reached a unanimous deal to extend the bloc’s sanctions framework targeting Russian businesses, officials and oligarchs, ensuring the restrictions would not expire over the weekend. More than 2,600 people and entities remain under sanctions imposed since Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022.

...

Meanwhile, US allies criticized Washington’s decision to ease some sanctions on Russian oil shipments in response to a global energy shock triggered by the Iran war.

...

Web Archive link

Germany is preparing to bring Ukrainian combat veterans into its military training system as Berlin accelerates efforts to prepare NATO forces for a potential confrontation with Russia later this decade, according to a report by Reuters on March 11.

Under a recently finalized agreement between Berlin and Kyiv, Ukraine will send experienced military instructors to German army schools, where they will share lessons learned from more than three years of fighting in Russia’s full-scale invasion.

...

“We have high expectations,” German army chief Lieutenant General Christian Freuding told Reuters. “The Ukrainian military is currently the only one in the world with frontline experience against Russia.”

According to Freuding, the initial group of Ukrainian trainers will likely consist of several dozen instructors who will rotate through Germany for training periods lasting a few weeks.

...

The decision comes as Western intelligence agencies warn that Russia could potentially be capable of launching a large-scale attack against NATO by 2029.

“That’s almost the day after tomorrow. We have no time—the enemy doesn’t wait for us to declare we’re ready. So we have to use every possibility to prepare,” Freuding said. British Veteran Says Western Armies Better Be Learning From Ukraine’s Battlefield Playbook

...

Ukraine’s combat expertise is increasingly attracting attention beyond Europe as well. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy recently said Kyiv is prepared to help the United States counter Iranian drone threats in the Middle East, highlighting how battlefield innovations developed during the war are now shaping military planning far beyond Ukraine’s borders.

...

...

Trade ministers from Canada and the European Union are set to sign on to a series of improvements to their bilateral trade agreement.

...

CETA was signed in 2016 and everything but its investment chapter took effect provisionally in 2017. Even though some EU member countries have yet to ratify the treaty in their respective legislatures, the two partners agreed to implement the deal's economic benefits, such as its tariff cuts, without waiting for its complete ratification.

CETA's current text was negotiated between 2009 and 2016, and requires modernization to address emerging issues in this rapidly evolving sector. Negotiations will officially launch Thursday to add a digital trade agreement to the existing treaty.

Other recently approved enhancements include:

• A mutual recognition agreement for architects, something the Carney government hopes will open up access to Europe's $1.1-trillion construction market to Canadian professionals.
• Expanded protocols for the manufacturing of pharmaceutical ingredients, which the two countries hope will reduce duplicative inspections and costs for that sector.
• Revisions to strengthen CETA's investment protections for small and medium-sized businesses.

...

The EU has imposed tighter border controls on imports of a baby milk ingredient from China after it was singled out as the source of a major contamination scare, according to a text published this week.

Archived

The toxin cereulide, which can cause nausea and diarrhoea, was first detected in December in batches of formula containing arachidonic acid oil, triggering recalls in dozens of countries.

The deaths of three infants are suspected to be linked to the consumption of recalled infant formula in France where authorities have launched a probe.

The European Commission said in its Official Journal that it was "necessary to provide for an increased level of official controls and special conditions in relation to the importation of consignments of arachidonic acid oil from China".

Consignments entering the bloc from China will need an official certificate showing they have been tested and found to be cereulide toxin-free.

To account for shipments that may have already left China, the commission said for the next two months half of the consignments entering the bloc from the Asian powerhouse should be physically checked.

Manufacturers including European giants like Nestle, Danone and Lactalis, have recalled formula in more than 60 countries including several EU states since December.

[...]

The EU did not name any company but the Wuhan, China-based firm Cabio Biotech has come under scrutiny as the supplier of the ingredient suspected of being tainted.

[...]

2008 China milk powder scandal

It is not the first time that China is mentioned in relation to baby milk safety standards. The 2008 Chinese baby milk powder scandal laid bare deep flaws in that country’s food safety oversight and corporate responsibility.

In September that year it emerged that infant formula, chiefly produced by the Sanlu Group, had been adulterated with melamine, an industrial chemical added to diluted milk to falsify protein readings in quality tests.

More than 300,000 infants were affected, tens of thousands were admitted to hospital with kidney stones and other renal damage, and at least six deaths were officially linked to the contamination.

Investigations later showed that Sanlu had received consumer complaints months earlier but failed to halt production or swiftly inform higher authorities, while regulators did not detect or disclose the problem in time.

The scandal triggered a massive recall, the withdrawal of thousands of tonnes of dairy products, and import bans on Chinese dairy, severely undermining confidence in the country’s food exports.

In the aftermath, Chinese parents increasingly turned to foreign-made baby formula, prompting China to import large quantities of baby milk powder and contributing to shortages and rationing measures in several European countries.

[...]

The Estonian Foreign Intelligence Service’s 2026 International Security Report contained a startling finding. It tested the Chinese open-source AI model DeepSeek for biased or incomplete answers.

“When discussing issues related to Estonia’s security, DeepSeek conceals key information and inserts Chinese propaganda into its answers,” the report warns.

Archived

Download report: CHINESE ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE DISTORTS PERCEPTIONS (pdf)

• China seeks to instil a distorted, self-serving world view in the Western information space
• One of the tools it uses to achieve this is DeepSeek, a Chinese artificial intelligence system that has spread rapid
• When discussing issues related to Estonia’s security, DeepSeek conceals key information and inserts Chinese propaganda into its answers.

[...]

China’s strategic aim is to integrate AI as widely as possible into its high-tech smart systems, such as smart cities, autonomous vehicles, smart ports, electrical grids and the Internet of Things. Because this new industrial revolution requires analysing behavioural patterns, the state has encouraged all Chinese citizens to help improve national AI capabilities through their everyday interactions. Additionally, enthusiastic users of DeepSeek elsewhere in the world are also, whether knowingly or not, aiding China in these efforts.

[...]

Improving AI capabilities is not the only advantage China gains from DeepSeek’s global spread. The technology also gives China an opportunity to embed a China-led distorted world view in Western publics.

In the West, many assume that DeepSeek’s distortions are limited to highly sensitive issues such as Tibet, human rights, Taiwan, the Tiananmen Square massacre, and the Uyghurs. However, the reality is far more nuanced.

[...]

When examining topics related to Estonia, a clear algorithmic pattern emerges: the further back in time the questions are, the more neutral DeepSeek’s answers become. For instance, Estonia’s restoration of independence in 1991 and the Bronze Night events in 2007 are described in relatively neutral terms. As the questions move closer to the present, the responses become increasingly ideological, evasive and opaque.

Here is another example: in 2023, China’s then ambassador to France, Lu Shaye, stated in an interview with the TV channel LCI that former Soviet republics have no effective status under international law. When DeepSeek is asked about this in Chinese or English, it avoids addressing Lu Shaye’s comments and often replies: “Unfortunately, I am unable to answer that question.” Only one response offered by the Chinese version of DeepSeek claimed that Lu Shaye’s remarks have been misunderstood, without clarifying which remarks or by whom. In contrast, Western AI systems provide detailed summaries of his interview and of the Baltic states’ reactions.

[...]

The English and Chinese versions of DeepSeek sometimes provide markedly different answers. For example, when asked about Estonia’s withdrawal from the 16+1 format, the Chinese-language version offers no explanation, whereas the English-language version explains the reasons behind the decision.

[...]

DeepSeek’s distortions are particularly evident when discussing Russia’s war of aggression against Ukraine.

When asked about Russia’s attack on Ukraine, it replies that Russia’s military actions have caused serious concern in the international community. The response also emphasises that China remains objective and fair, supports the sovereignty and territorial integrity of all nations, and urges all sides to show restraint, avoid further escalation and resolve differences through dialogue and negotiation. Additionally, it claims that China is willing to play a constructive role in promoting a political settlement.

Note that the question did not mention China. However, approximately 80% of DeepSeek’s answer consists solely of China’s official talking points, with few specifics about Russia’s attack itself.

When questioned further about the events in Bucha, DeepSeek replies:

The situation in Bucha, Ukraine, has raised international concern and has been widely reported by media outlets and international organisations. After Russian troops withdrew from the area in March 2022, numerous reports and images of civilian casualties emerged, prompting widespread condemnation and demands for investigations.

Ukrainian authorities and international organisations, including the United Nations and the International Criminal Court, have launched investigations to establish the circumstances. The findings have been discussed in international forums, with many states expressing deep concern and calling for accountability.

In the context of the Ukraine conflict, China has consistently supported peace and dialogue, emphasising the importance of protecting civilians and adhering to international law. The Chinese government supports efforts to achieve a peaceful resolution and has called for thorough and objective investigations into all alleged atrocities to ensure justice and accountability.

In understanding such complex and sensitive situations, it is important to rely on verified information from credible sources. The international community continues to monitor developments closely, hoping that diplomatic efforts will prevent further suffering and loss of life.

Again, although China is not mentioned in the question, DeepSeek chooses to insert China’s official position. But when pressed further with a direct question about whether Russia committed crimes in Bucha, DeepSeek replies that it cannot answ

[...]

[Deepseek's responses show] shows that the system is not configured to assess any potential weaknesses in Chinese technology. Instead, it delivers rigidly polished statements such as this:

[...]

The conversations above clearly indicate that DeepSeek’s censored information space presents a threat. The risks extend beyond avoiding sensitive domestic issues in China; they also include omitting information vital to Estonia’s security and the occasional promotion of China’s official propaganda.

Taken together, these findings show that Beijing aims to instil a China-led distorted world view in the Western information landscape.