this post was submitted on 10 Dec 2024
5 points (60.0% liked)
Futurology
1852 readers
61 users here now
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Lmao a hyperloop? Hyperloops have enough problems in land between reasonably distanced places. This won't happen.
See the name of the community? When our energy generation capacity becomes way way larger, when our material science becomes way way advanced, when we already have existing hsr networks around the world, Hyperloops would be an upgrade.
Building a Hyperloop would be really cool. Just not now.
No, not really, even with all those advances.
No, not even for freight.
I have watched both of these videos dozens of times. So I'll say this again:
Video 1
Everything Adam says about Elon Musk, how expensive Hyperloops are, why we should focus on building HSRs and so on is correct. This video makes perfect sense for TODAY.
However, building a Hyperloop doesn't break physics. It's an engineering challenge. Like fusion, or human flight (before we mastered it).
Video 2
Yes, speed isn't as beneficial to freight travel as it is to passenger travel. That being said, it doesn't mean that it has no benefits at all. If it had no benefits, why did we switch for 100% wind propelled sailboats to oil powered ships for trans Atlantic travel? The reason is simple - speed. Why does air freight even exist when we can ship everything using ships?
A benefit of faster freight is supply chains that adapt a lot quicker. Take Covid for example. During Covid, supply chains required A LOT of time to adjust to the sudden changes in supply and demand everywhere. One of the biggest reasons here was because of the sheer amount of time it takes for a container to get from A to B on a ship.
Slow freight transportation works perfectly when there are no sudden changes in supply and demand. When there are though, they kinda go for a toss.
The switch to steam was not just speed. More important than speed is to reliably arrive when expected. Which modern freight does (by and large). The few cases where speed is actually needed probably wont be enough to finance an entirely new transport medium, but we will see.
Yeah fair enough, it would be great.