330
Software is slow because of bad design, not slow languages
(www.seangoedecke.com)
Welcome to the main community in programming.dev! Feel free to post anything relating to programming here!
Cross posting is strongly encouraged in the instance. If you feel your post or another person's post makes sense in another community cross post into it.
Hope you enjoy the instance!
Rules
Follow the wormhole through a path of communities !webdev@programming.dev
What does that even mean? I make GUIs in web technologies, I make GUIs in godot, I make GUIs in bevy, I make GUIs in flutter, etc etc. Blink uses Skia. Flutter uses Skia. Is skia just bad? What are you even saying? What is slow about web tech, really? To me performance is almost always bad engineering choices like not understanding or handling I/O.
The issue is that any time you add another generic layer, it involves another layer of loops for "handle everything" tasks and lookups for "handle this specific thing" tasks. A native app could set a bunch of values for properties by changing them in a single function accessing a single data structure. You might have a single function that does the same thing using frameworks, but that function is potentially going to use accessor functions to reach down each layer to set those values where they matter plus could need to do a bunch of transformations as it traverses each layer (or maybe that's done on the render side).
So then you add a bunch of caching to improve these common scenarios and balloon memory usage, which was already inflated because those layers also need memory to store their data structures.
And these things get worse as they scale, so small scale tests still look snappy and hide how much things can grind to a crawl when it needs to handle the large or normal scale. Not to mention, if you don't have a speedy version to compare to, you might just think that it makes sense for this process to take a couple minutes because it has millions of things to do (despite running on hardware that can do billions of things per second).
So that means every single developer that has ever used Electron or CEF for something, has been making bad engineering choices?
You may have something there.
Why is how nodejs or cef does I/O worse than any other GUI toolkit's I/O layer?
I haven't gotten deep enough into it to see what's wrong, but pretty much any Electron or CEF application I've used has been pretty slow, though it could be that I have a very weak PC since I only have a Ryzen 5700 and 32 gigs of DDR4 and my NVMe drives (root and home partitions being separate physical drives) are only running on PCIe 3.0, not 4.0 or 5.0. Perhaps I ought to see if things like Steam or Discord run better if I upgrade to a mid-range PC with a Ryzen 9900x, faster RAM and faster drives, but I'm not made of money.
Games run smoothly, mind you - those don't require very beefy hardware after all. It's only extremely visually and IO demanding applications like Steam or Discord that run like absolute dogshit for me. Slack used to be pretty bad too, but I don't use it these days, don't need it. Ditto for Mattermost. I have one computer dedicated to Microsoft Teams, it's got a 12th gen i7 in it which can't really handle the task, but that's just Microsoft for you, everything they've made in the last decade has been shit.