1134
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] CarstenBoll@feddit.dk 3 points 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago)

Isn't that what defines a state? Having a monopoly on violence and being able to secure its borders?

[-] wpb@lemmy.world 2 points 1 day ago

In some sense, yes. The secure the borders thing a weird and unnecessary addition, but the monopoly on violence thing is pretty spot on. The state has a legal monopoly on violence. But that position is not at all what the OP is arguing against.

Some people would extend the above to a kind of moral monopoly. They see someone employ violent tactics to rebel against the state, and they will say "this is morally wrong", or "this is not the way to do things", or "would someone please think of the optics?". They look at the violence employed by people in the BLM movement and argue against it. They look at the stonewall riots and argue against it. They look at people violently resisting the nazis in the second world war, and they argue against it, from a moral perpective. That is what this post is about.

[-] CarstenBoll@feddit.dk 1 points 1 day ago

I mean, statehood only works if you can secure your borders, you cease to be a state if you can't. It's just the minimum definition of a state without, I should say, any moral evaluation. There are states I'd be happy to live in and states I won't visit. They're still states.

I agree that broadly speaking all power comes from the threat of violence, or as Mao says grows from the barrel of a gun. Peaceful protests can still be threatening, though. We've seen many more or less peaceful protests succeed.

My country became a democracy because people marched to the palace and asked nicely. The implicit threat being that next time the mob might not ask nicely.

[-] wpb@lemmy.world 1 points 13 hours ago

I mean, statehood only works if you can secure your borders, you cease to be a state if you can’t

I don't accept this assumption, but it's kind of off topic so let's agree to disagree on this.

The implicit threat being that next time the mob might not ask nicely.

Point taken! But you must admit, this threat was made credible by the very, very bloody uprisings that were happening around you. And mind you, you were pretty much the only European country that this strategy worked for (piggybacking off of the violence of others): the others had to resort to violence. By and large, any toppled oppression is toppled violently, not by saying pretty please with a cherry on top.

[-] fyzzlefry@retrolemmy.com 4 points 1 day ago

Except in an oligarchy violence is also coming from the wealthy.

[-] TypFaffke@feddit.org -3 points 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago)

Yes, but you don't get the internet points with that kind of nuanced argument.

this post was submitted on 14 Nov 2026
1134 points (98.5% liked)

Microblog Memes

12596 readers
3111 users here now

A place to share screenshots of Microblog posts, whether from Mastodon, tumblr, ~~Twitter~~ X, KBin, Threads or elsewhere.

Created as an evolution of White People Twitter and other tweet-capture subreddits.

RULES:

  1. Your post must be a screen capture of a microblog-type post that includes the UI of the site it came from, preferably also including the avatar and username of the original poster. Including relevant comments made to the original post is encouraged.
  2. Your post, included comments, or your title/comment should include some kind of commentary or remark on the subject of the screen capture. Your title must include at least one word relevant to your post.
  3. You are encouraged to provide a link back to the source of your screen capture in the body of your post.
  4. Current politics and news are allowed, but discouraged. There MUST be some kind of human commentary/reaction included (either by the original poster or you). Just news articles or headlines will be deleted.
  5. Doctored posts/images and AI are allowed, but discouraged. You MUST indicate this in your post (even if you didn't originally know). If an image is found to be fabricated or edited in any way and it is not properly labeled, it will be deleted.
  6. Absolutely no NSFL content.
  7. Be nice. Don't take anything personally. Take political debates to the appropriate communities. Take personal disagreements & arguments to private messages.
  8. No advertising, brand promotion, or guerrilla marketing.

RELATED COMMUNITIES:

founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS