222
submitted 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago) by vasko@feddit.org to c/onehundredninetysix@lemmy.blahaj.zone

How can people be against capital punishment and then be pro torture? Either you are pro human rights or you're not ...

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] lime@feddit.nu 1 points 1 day ago

see that's why i think of it as a straw man.in my experience, people advocating for the death penalty tend to think of criminal punishment primarily as... punishment, rather than the attempt att rehabilitation we've come to largely agree that it is.

most people, i think, recognise that a majority of criminal activity is born, directly or indirectly, from circumstance. therefore, most criminals act out of a perceived necessity. the criminal justice system exists to make sure that these people are rehabilitated (with varying effectiveness...), and that they are kept from society until they are. the punishment is the separation, the penance is rehabilitation.

the punishment view seems to me more like an "eye for an eye" mindset. they did an illegal thing, so they should suffer. i've seen the view that the death penalty is "too good" for certain criminals, but i've never seen someone be anti-death penalty, pro-torture. i guess if you count the people ambiguous to prison reform into the pro-torture camp you'll bump the headcount somewhat.

[-] vasko@feddit.org 1 points 1 day ago

I see what you’re getting at, but, again, I think that’s mainly because I didn’t express myself very clearly. I specifically didn’t mention ‘opponents of the death penalty’; instead, I asked: ‘How can anyone be against the death penalty [...]’. I agree with you that it’s worded rather vaguely, but I would argue that both your interpretation and my intended meaning are reasonable, and think it's a bit unfair to dismiss this as a straw man argument.

[-] lime@feddit.nu 2 points 1 day ago

intent is hard in text form, yeah. i feel like the way you've contrasted those two sentences there highlights the problem: "how can anyone..." implies that some people do. without demonstrating that this is in fact a real opinion that people hold, it is a textbook strawman. if the intent was instead to raise the discussion of whether the sort of person alluded to does exist, the wording is not only vague but wrong.

so, for my confused mind: what was the intent here?

[-] vasko@feddit.org 2 points 1 day ago

I feel that I can no longer give you a straight answer to that without undermining the abstract art that has emerged from this silly post. Interpret the intention in whatever way suits you best and gives you the most. :)

[-] lime@feddit.nu 3 points 1 day ago

i can respect that.

this post was submitted on 16 Nov 2026
222 points (95.1% liked)

196

7246 readers
2379 users here now

Community Rules

You must post before you leave

Be nice. Assume others have good intent (within reason).

Block or ignore posts, comments, and users that irritate you in some way rather than engaging. Report if they are actually breaking community rules.

Use content warnings and/or mark as NSFW when appropriate. Most posts with content warnings likely need to be marked NSFW.

Most 196 posts are memes, shitposts, cute images, or even just recent things that happened, etc. There is no real theme, but try to avoid posts that are very inflammatory, offensive, very low quality, or very "off topic".

Bigotry is not allowed, this includes (but is not limited to): Homophobia, Transphobia, Racism, Sexism, Abelism, Classism, or discrimination based on things like Ethnicity, Nationality, Language, or Religion.

Avoid shilling for corporations, posting advertisements, or promoting exploitation of workers.

Proselytization, support, or defense of authoritarianism is not welcome. This includes but is not limited to: imperialism, nationalism, genocide denial, ethnic or racial supremacy, fascism, Nazism, Marxism-Leninism, Maoism, etc.

Avoid AI generated content.

Avoid misinformation.

Avoid incomprehensible posts.

No threats or personal attacks.

No spam.

Moderator Guidelines

Moderator Guidelines

  • Don’t be mean to users. Be gentle or neutral.
  • Most moderator actions which have a modlog message should include your username.
  • When in doubt about whether or not a user is problematic, send them a DM.
  • Don’t waste time debating/arguing with problematic users.
  • Assume the best, but don’t tolerate sealioning/just asking questions/concern trolling.
  • Ask another mod to take over cases you struggle with, if you get tired, or when things get personal.
  • Ask the other mods for advice when things get complicated.
  • Share everything you do in the mod matrix, both so several mods aren't unknowingly handling the same issues, but also so you can receive feedback on what you intend to do.
  • Don't rush mod actions. If a case doesn't need to be handled right away, consider taking a short break before getting to it. This is to say, cool down and make room for feedback.
  • Don’t perform too much moderation in the comments, except if you want a verdict to be public or to ask people to dial a convo down/stop. Single comment warnings are okay.
  • Send users concise DMs about verdicts about them, such as bans etc, except in cases where it is clear we don’t want them at all, such as obvious transphobes. No need to notify someone they haven’t been banned of course.
  • Explain to a user why their behavior is problematic and how it is distressing others rather than engage with whatever they are saying. Ask them to avoid this in the future and send them packing if they do not comply.
  • First warn users, then temp ban them, then finally perma ban them when they break the rules or act inappropriately. Skip steps if necessary.
  • Use neutral statements like “this statement can be considered transphobic” rather than “you are being transphobic”.
  • No large decisions or actions without community input (polls or meta posts f.ex.).
  • Large internal decisions (such as ousting a mod) might require a vote, needing more than 50% of the votes to pass. Also consider asking the community for feedback.
  • Remember you are a voluntary moderator. You don’t get paid. Take a break when you need one. Perhaps ask another moderator to step in if necessary.

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS