220
submitted 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago) by vasko@feddit.org to c/onehundredninetysix@lemmy.blahaj.zone

How can people be against capital punishment and then be pro torture? Either you are pro human rights or you're not ...

top 50 comments
sorted by: hot top new old
[-] Cris_Citrus@piefed.zip 46 points 1 day ago* (last edited 20 hours ago)

This is a problem born mostly of having a criminal "justice" system that is about institutionalizing retribution, mostly by subjecting them to traumatic horrors and the most dehumanizing things we could come up with.

If you have solutions other than torture them, killing them stops looking like a mercy. The torture isnt actually a necessary option without alternatives.

[-] ThatWeirdGuy1001@lemmy.world 8 points 1 day ago

Not trying to be a dick but necessary

[-] Cris_Citrus@piefed.zip 1 points 20 hours ago* (last edited 20 hours ago)

Thank youuuu, my keyboard didn't wanna auto correct and I was tired and didn't wanna look it up lol

My brain is real bad at spelling sometimes

[-] glups@piefed.social 1 points 22 hours ago

Noth trying to be a dick**,** but necessary

[-] GreyEyedGhost@piefed.ca 1 points 19 hours ago

I figured it was an internal requirement of the responding poster. 🤷

[-] kryptonianCodeMonkey@lemmy.world 8 points 23 hours ago* (last edited 23 hours ago)

On a serious note, capital punishment serves absolutely no aspect of Justice. It does two things: 1. It saves the state ~~money,~~ space and effort required to imprison a person (EDIT: correction, it actually costs more to execute someone than life imprisonment without parole). 2. It might make the victim's loved-ones (if there are any) and the weird sadists of the citizenry feel a sense of closure (or sick joy) through revenge. Those things are not justice, though.

Justice is the correction of unfairness, moral corruption, and dangers to society. If imprisonment does not serve this goal, then it only serves, at best, pettiness, a lust for punishment, and the state's bottom line over human life. Rehabilitation should be the first and absolute purpose of the justice system, and protecting the public from a real and present danger the second. If imprisonment is serving neither purpose, or, as is often the case, counter-productive to either or both of those things, then it ought to be dramatically and thoughtfully reformed.

Notably many people would argue that the point of prison is deterrence. And it isn't like there isn't a any credence to that. But the reality of human psychology is that, more often than not, we tend to follow or only slightly bend rules without any real threat hanging over our heads. And the absolute volume of imprisoned people in the US alone should tell you that this deterrence is, at minimum, unideally effective. And many crimes are done from passion, negligence, ignorance, addiction, poverty, or some other circumstance where you are either not considering the risk or forced to take the risk rather than the alternatives. If you are relying on the deterrence of the threat of imprisonment to rid the world of crime, you clearly need to rethink things. We need to be addressing the root causes of crime instead, and prisons designed around proper rehabilitation can be one small part of that.

[-] funkless_eck@sh.itjust.works 7 points 23 hours ago

It absolutely does not save the state money. It is far more expensive several times over than imprisonment

[-] kryptonianCodeMonkey@lemmy.world 6 points 23 hours ago* (last edited 14 hours ago)

That's a fair caveat. The reason for the expense is largely due to the extra long court trials and extended appeals process granted for such cases (as well they should), and the fact that those individuals also tend to be put in higher security prisons which naturally cost more. The cost to actually do the execution isn't nothing either, particularly as many of the drugs are hard to get ahold of.

If we're being "fair", in a grotesque way, many staunch advocates for capital punishment would rather they be granted no lengthy appeals or imprisonment. They'd rather see them walked from the court room sentencing to a firing squad behind the courthouse, which would definitely be cheaper. But yes, in our current system, it is significantly more expensive to execute someone than to imprison them for life without parole.

[-] HasturInYellow@lemmy.world 5 points 22 hours ago

I am a proponent of capital punishment solely for those who have publicly, repeatedly and willfully been responsible for the death or impoverishment of hundreds to thousands to millions of people. These crimes do need to be litigat d or discussed. They happened openly for all to see and often with a paper trail to justify it legally.

When there is no doubt that they did these things for profit or their own pleasure, I don't really even care if they get a trial. Just torture until dead and then dumped into the sewer system.

[-] chiliedogg@lemmy.world 6 points 16 hours ago

I'm generally opposed to capital punishment, but yeah. Every now and then you need a Nuremberg.

[-] Rothe@piefed.social 12 points 1 day ago

Who are these pro-torture anti-capital punishment people you are referring to?

[-] vasko@feddit.org 12 points 1 day ago
[-] QuinnyCoded@sh.itjust.works 5 points 1 day ago

fair enough

[-] jumping_redditor@sh.itjust.works 1 points 22 hours ago

plenty of people are, it eliminates the concern of false convictions leading to permanent outcomes.

[-] lime@feddit.nu 13 points 1 day ago

you dropped your straw man outside

[-] vasko@feddit.org 15 points 1 day ago

Except that this isn’t a straw man argument. Of course, nobody puts it quite so bluntly, but some people do in fact argue in this way. One can certainly debate what constitutes torture, but don’t pretend that there aren’t people who express violent fantasies about those they regard as deserving or undesirable to society.

[-] Natanox@discuss.tchncs.de 7 points 1 day ago
[-] vasko@feddit.org 2 points 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago)

I'm not your bro, pal. :)

[-] lime@feddit.nu 4 points 1 day ago

some people do in fact argue this way

who?

[-] angband@lemmy.world 15 points 1 day ago

Anyone who comments about rapists getting used as sex toys in prison, for one. Anyone who makes a drop-the-soap-joke. Anyone who supports texas not having climate controls in prison. To some extent, anyone who supports chain gangs or forced agricultural labor. The us constitution, and its writers, who said slavery was a suitable punishment for crime.

load more comments (19 replies)
[-] DaPorkchop_@lemmy.ml 2 points 1 day ago

my dad does

[-] psx_crab@lemmy.zip 25 points 1 day ago

When you're pro-human wrong

[-] ignotum@lemmy.world 18 points 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago)

To exist is to risk suffering, that's why I, a REAL pro-human activist, am working to awaken cthulhu from his slumber so he can vanquish man from the face of the earth

It's just the lesser of two evils

Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn

[-] AmyAye@nord.pub 3 points 1 day ago

I mean, given the direction everything in the world is lurching, this kind of feels like a good idea.

[-] Natanox@discuss.tchncs.de 15 points 1 day ago
[-] vasko@feddit.org 7 points 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago)

My exact reaction, when people actually think this way!

Death row inmates also cost way more than typical inmates. Mostly due to the trials being more involved, various appeals, and other legal costs.

I'm not saying cost should be the determining factor in how we handle criminal justice, I've just encountered a frustrating number of people who assume that putting sometime to death is cheaper than life imprisonment because "they aren't around as long."

[-] halvar@lemy.lol 4 points 1 day ago

For some reason whenever capital punishment comes up the arc is always guy 1 doesn't support capital punishment (good), guy 2 does support it (bad) and guy 3 dosen't support it (worse).

[-] garbagebagel@lemmy.world 5 points 1 day ago

If the system wasn't incredibly racially biased and so often absolutely wrong on the people it wanted to do capital punishment on, I might have less of an issue with it.

Like if there's a literal psychopath (in the clinical sense) that was in no way ever able to change and would 100% constitute a threat in the outside world and you could 100% prove their guilt, okay sure I dont want my tax dollars paying for them to be alive anyway.

But that's not how the system works and as long as there are potentially innocent people on death row who could continue to fight to prove their innocence, then I will be against capital punishment.

I'm also against the entire north american prison system though so.

[-] Grail@multiverse.soulism.net 11 points 1 day ago

"Psychopath" isn't a clinical term, it's a slang term for ASPD. And people with ASPD aren't evil monsters, because psychiatry isn't about judging people. Doctors aren't priests.

[-] Micromot@piefed.social 2 points 1 day ago

So you would be pro death sentence if everyone was guilty of the crime they are accused of?

[-] garbagebagel@lemmy.world 1 points 22 hours ago

If they were causing death or severe harm to the people and were not rehabilitatable. I think this would be a really small section of people who are guilty of crimes, like a serial killer for example.

In practice, this would be nearly impossible to enforce though, and even less so with the way the system is currently.

[-] Micromot@piefed.social 1 points 20 hours ago

So why even try? In any imaginable case, having a death sentence is just worse than a rehabilitation system that some people would be in forever, which is much better than the people unjustly killed.

[-] HonoraryMancunian@lemmy.world 3 points 1 day ago

Black Mirror

[-] RedSnt@feddit.dk 3 points 1 day ago

A quick search reveals that the average time on death row in USA is 178 months or 14 years and 10 months. It's not exactly an instantaneous thing.

load more comments
view more: next ›
this post was submitted on 16 Nov 2026
220 points (95.1% liked)

196

7246 readers
2379 users here now

Community Rules

You must post before you leave

Be nice. Assume others have good intent (within reason).

Block or ignore posts, comments, and users that irritate you in some way rather than engaging. Report if they are actually breaking community rules.

Use content warnings and/or mark as NSFW when appropriate. Most posts with content warnings likely need to be marked NSFW.

Most 196 posts are memes, shitposts, cute images, or even just recent things that happened, etc. There is no real theme, but try to avoid posts that are very inflammatory, offensive, very low quality, or very "off topic".

Bigotry is not allowed, this includes (but is not limited to): Homophobia, Transphobia, Racism, Sexism, Abelism, Classism, or discrimination based on things like Ethnicity, Nationality, Language, or Religion.

Avoid shilling for corporations, posting advertisements, or promoting exploitation of workers.

Proselytization, support, or defense of authoritarianism is not welcome. This includes but is not limited to: imperialism, nationalism, genocide denial, ethnic or racial supremacy, fascism, Nazism, Marxism-Leninism, Maoism, etc.

Avoid AI generated content.

Avoid misinformation.

Avoid incomprehensible posts.

No threats or personal attacks.

No spam.

Moderator Guidelines

Moderator Guidelines

  • Don’t be mean to users. Be gentle or neutral.
  • Most moderator actions which have a modlog message should include your username.
  • When in doubt about whether or not a user is problematic, send them a DM.
  • Don’t waste time debating/arguing with problematic users.
  • Assume the best, but don’t tolerate sealioning/just asking questions/concern trolling.
  • Ask another mod to take over cases you struggle with, if you get tired, or when things get personal.
  • Ask the other mods for advice when things get complicated.
  • Share everything you do in the mod matrix, both so several mods aren't unknowingly handling the same issues, but also so you can receive feedback on what you intend to do.
  • Don't rush mod actions. If a case doesn't need to be handled right away, consider taking a short break before getting to it. This is to say, cool down and make room for feedback.
  • Don’t perform too much moderation in the comments, except if you want a verdict to be public or to ask people to dial a convo down/stop. Single comment warnings are okay.
  • Send users concise DMs about verdicts about them, such as bans etc, except in cases where it is clear we don’t want them at all, such as obvious transphobes. No need to notify someone they haven’t been banned of course.
  • Explain to a user why their behavior is problematic and how it is distressing others rather than engage with whatever they are saying. Ask them to avoid this in the future and send them packing if they do not comply.
  • First warn users, then temp ban them, then finally perma ban them when they break the rules or act inappropriately. Skip steps if necessary.
  • Use neutral statements like “this statement can be considered transphobic” rather than “you are being transphobic”.
  • No large decisions or actions without community input (polls or meta posts f.ex.).
  • Large internal decisions (such as ousting a mod) might require a vote, needing more than 50% of the votes to pass. Also consider asking the community for feedback.
  • Remember you are a voluntary moderator. You don’t get paid. Take a break when you need one. Perhaps ask another moderator to step in if necessary.

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS