As a non-american for me we are all missing the forest for the trees. The scale of impact is not comparable between a) importing some chips to china, and b) using vast circular financing to create an artificial supply shortage which spiked the cost of important hardware globally. Fuck this guy.
There was also a massive backdoor that made smuggling chips next to pointless anyways. It was fully legal for US companies (or other foreign cos) to buy chips then rent the use to chinese corps.
Why take ownership of something illegally when you can extract the benefit legally with a bit of cost in return for substantially less risk?
The barn door was wide open but climbing in through the window is T R E A S O N
Even if they close this loophole you're just going to have the same Chinese companies using the same tech, they might just need to add another middleman or two
You don't have to agree with the export ban to call it treason. Every US citizen involved willfully broke federal law and hid it.
Not to mention how all of this has had real impacts on the economy that we're all feeling to some degree. Why would even the most far left person be on Jensen's side?
We care because the government was upholding the ban while allowing one specific company to secretly get around it. It's especially bad when the justification for the ban is keep us "in the lead" of AI research and they're supplying the competition.
Maybe you'd care if it was a major company in your country fucking up your economy? It's crazy to me that you're defending corruption lol
[Edit] I forgot to mention that Trump and Lutnick are benefitting from this arrangement, too.
Your teacher made a stupid rule at the start of the year: no water in the classroom! You turn a blind eye to your coworker sipping a water bottle, as you should. Everyone seems to be struggling except the teacher's favorite student.
Then you find out the teacher agreed to let that student bring in a ton of water if they got some of it. Both kept the arrangement secret for over a year until the teacher got in trouble for something else.
Would you be mad at your classmate? Or just the teacher
Not the person who colluded with the teacher to disproportionately benefit them both to your detriment while pretending they were struggling just as much as you?
Yes. Making a fucked system is obviously worse than taking advantage of a fucked system, right?
I guess in that analogy you could say that the students should be expected to have solidarity against the unjust authority, so there could be a sense of betrayal regarding the student who broke that. But that's where the analogy breaks down because if you saw the CEO of Nvidia as "struggling just as much as you" I don't really know what to tell you. They aren't just another student on parity with everyone else, there shouldn't be any expectation of solidarity. He's out to make as much money as possible just like every other capitalist. Evading tariffs or export restrictions is to be expected, if they think they can get away with it.
Calling that "treason" is just silly. He's a traitor only in the sense that the entire capitalist class could be called traitors to the people.
No it isn't. It is illegal as the laws are written. It's not "treason" by any reasonable legal interpretation.
I'm focusing on right and wrong because I assumed that you were taking the much more reasonable stance that he's a traitor in a moral sense, that it should be considered treason, rather than the completely absurd claim that it's treason in a legal sense, that it is or will be considered treason. Get back to me when he's behind bars lmao.
I'm not "giving him a pass for being good at capitalism." I'm just recognizing that everyone at the top is corrupt and guilty of all sorts of shit. It's a free market economy, after all.
We're in an artificial intelligence arms race and Nvidia is providing "the enemy" with US technology. He is directly contributing to us losing the "fight"
He's not going to jail because the admin is corrupt so I guess we'll never talk again, darn!
Lol. First of all, who decided that China is "the enemy?" We're not at war, last time I checked. How are the courts determining what constitutes an "enemy country," and where is the list of which countries are "enemies" and which ones aren't? Just because you personally consider them an enemy doesn't mean shit.
Second, development of technology is not a "fight." There are plenty of companies that do business in China, including R&D, for example, Apple. Is Apple also guilty of "treason?"
He wouldn't be going to jail under any president in recent history or any president that would be realistically elected. It doesn't really have anything to do with the current administration, which, if anything, is targeting him more than others would because they're invested in upholding the tarrif laws they enacted. Capitalist systems don't just go around throwing billionaire CEOs in jail over things like this.
Unless he receives a formal pardon (which he won't), then future administrations will be completely free to prosecute him if they so choose. They won't though, regardless of party, regardless of who gets in. Even if AOC were president, she wouldn't prosecute him for treason. If you think otherwise, you don't understand the system.
Jensen wasn't doing this as a conscious objector to export restrictions, he was doing it to enrich himself, just like his artificial inflation of chip prices and buying the democratic process.
Restricting GPU exports to a rival authoritarian nation and preventing the most corrupt MAGA administration in history from violating those controls for self-profit is a national security issue, not “maga/export nonsense”, whatever that is supposed to mean.
China supports Russia in its illegal, brutalist, and completely unnecessary invasion of Ukraine.
China has been preparing to invade and take over the sovereign nation of Taiwan for decades, largely for its chip-making capabilities.
China enslaves and genocides its own Uyghur citizens in concentration camps.
China is an authoritarian hyper-surveillance state.
Preventing China from achieving tech dominance and from achieving its authoritarian geopolitical goals is in the direct interest of every single American, and most of the freedom-loving world. Jensen Huang and the Trump administration violated that interest to enrich only themselves and the CCP, which is why they are traitors.
The reason mainland China wants to reunite with Taiwan isn't over chip-manufacturing, but because the US maintains it as a military base, similar to the Republic of Korea and Japan. China has its own growing chip industry that is largely self-sufficient and is rapidly approaching the peak of western chip design. The government of Taiwan doesn't consider itself to be a distinct island nation, but instead the rightful rulers of all of China, including the mainland. Both the PRC and ROC agree that the mainland and the island of Taiwan are China collectively, where they disagree is in which government is legitimate.
China also isn't committing genocide or enslaving Uyghur people. Allegations against China were downgraded from genocide to human rights abuses, and the overwhelming majority of "evidence" of the abuses comes from Adrian Zenz, a far-right Christian Nationalist that is quite literally a paid propagandist for the Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation. I recommend reading Xinjiang: A Resource and Report Compilation for a more comprehensive understanding.
China isn't abnormally predatory when it comes to surveillance, western countries have similar or worse surveillance on average. China also has some of the highest perceptions of democracy in the world:
This is because of their democratic structure, which is based on people's councils laddering upwards, and an adherance to the Marxist-Leninist strategy of the Mass Line. The details and functions of China's democratic system are covered in professor Roland Boer's Socialism in Power: On the History and Theory of Socialist Governance.
You're contributing to a New Cold War, to nobody's interests except the United States ruling class. They want you to fear China, so that you do not question your own system, or push for cooperation that could provide cheap solar power and technological advancement for all.
Someone should put rare earth restrictions my my country for its repeated brutal, legally questionable invasions of multiple countries across the middle east for the last 30 odd years.
When it comes to China, liberals in the US are just as far-right/fascist as MAGA. Seriously, read any anti-chinese comment on Lemmy and replace China with Mexico in that comment and you will think you're on truth social.
The Chinese are human, like you and I. There is no such concept as 'copying research' as a negative thing. Research specifically increases human understanding of a thing. Intentionally keeping others ignorant based on invisible borders and one-sided hostility is evil. It is unimaginably evil. But also, yes, MAGA does claim that Mexicans are stealing US IP.
China is a dictatorship whose leader removed term limits and declared themselves ruler for life. The same cannot be said for Mexico, regardless of whatever denial and deflection du jour you're offering.
whose leader removed term limits and declared themselves ruler for life.
This is also incorrect, and speaks to just a general ignorance of how democracy works.
The same cannot be said for Mexico, regardless of whatever denial and deflection du jour you’re offering.
Well given you haven't offered any evidence to support your point that goes counter to actual reality, I can't really say you're correct. Also, let's say you were, MAGA says Mexico is run by unelected cartels. Hence why you racists are just MAGA but against Chinese people.
The censorship is plain to see, just ask Deepseek about it:
...And just like MAGA you think AI, sorry, SI is a source of knowledge. God you BlueMAGA really do make it so easy to just dunk on you.
China is a socialist country, run via democratic means. Social ownership is the principal aspect of the economy, and the working class controls the state. All socialism is democratic, the term "democratic socialism" in practice just means reformism, ie social democracy.
Your chauvanist views of China don't hold water. China is not capitalist. China marketizes underdeveloped sectors of the economy, while having social ownership of the commanding heights of the economy. This is based on the Marxist understanding of contradiction and the economic basis of different forms of production. The basis of markets is in disparate, decentralized production, while the basis of planned economy is in centralized production.
Markets naturally centralize through competition and technological advancement, preparing themselves for planned economy. To plan underdeveloped sectors of the economy is to place strain on administration, because the mechanisms and infrastructure to plan such an industry has not been developed yet through markets. This is classical Marxist economics, views held by Marx, Engels, and Lenin.
Block me if you want, that's your choice, but please be serious for a moment. Yelling about evil communists like you're McCarthy and repeating a firehouse of nonsense is hardly sensible.
My wife is Chinese. Take off with your gaslighting.
Edit: it is a typical strategy to accuse anyone critical of the CCP as being racist to chinese which is a ridiculous and dangerous line of reasoning. Israel does the same with respect to calling critics of the regime anti-semetic.
We pro maga/export nonsense now?
Export restrictions on chips began under Biden
As a non-american for me we are all missing the forest for the trees. The scale of impact is not comparable between a) importing some chips to china, and b) using vast circular financing to create an artificial supply shortage which spiked the cost of important hardware globally. Fuck this guy.
There was also a massive backdoor that made smuggling chips next to pointless anyways. It was fully legal for US companies (or other foreign cos) to buy chips then rent the use to chinese corps.
Why take ownership of something illegally when you can extract the benefit legally with a bit of cost in return for substantially less risk?
The barn door was wide open but climbing in through the window is T R E A S O N
Even if they close this loophole you're just going to have the same Chinese companies using the same tech, they might just need to add another middleman or two
You don't have to agree with the export ban to call it treason. Every US citizen involved willfully broke federal law and hid it.
Not to mention how all of this has had real impacts on the economy that we're all feeling to some degree. Why would even the most far left person be on Jensen's side?
But if it was a bullshit ban, why would I give a shit that people broke it? Its a dumb law, don't respect it.
We care because the government was upholding the ban while allowing one specific company to secretly get around it. It's especially bad when the justification for the ban is keep us "in the lead" of AI research and they're supplying the competition.
Maybe you'd care if it was a major company in your country fucking up your economy? It's crazy to me that you're defending corruption lol
[Edit] I forgot to mention that Trump and Lutnick are benefitting from this arrangement, too.
Then I would be mad at the government for enacting such a stupid law in the first place. Not for people ignoring it.
I'll give you an analogy more relevant to you:
Your teacher made a stupid rule at the start of the year: no water in the classroom! You turn a blind eye to your coworker sipping a water bottle, as you should. Everyone seems to be struggling except the teacher's favorite student.
Then you find out the teacher agreed to let that student bring in a ton of water if they got some of it. Both kept the arrangement secret for over a year until the teacher got in trouble for something else.
Would you be mad at your classmate? Or just the teacher
Just the teacher, primarily.
Not the person who colluded with the teacher to disproportionately benefit them both to your detriment while pretending they were struggling just as much as you?
Yes. Making a fucked system is obviously worse than taking advantage of a fucked system, right?
I guess in that analogy you could say that the students should be expected to have solidarity against the unjust authority, so there could be a sense of betrayal regarding the student who broke that. But that's where the analogy breaks down because if you saw the CEO of Nvidia as "struggling just as much as you" I don't really know what to tell you. They aren't just another student on parity with everyone else, there shouldn't be any expectation of solidarity. He's out to make as much money as possible just like every other capitalist. Evading tariffs or export restrictions is to be expected, if they think they can get away with it.
Calling that "treason" is just silly. He's a traitor only in the sense that the entire capitalist class could be called traitors to the people.
It is treason as the laws are written. Not sure why you're so hung up on what's right and wrong.
You're basically giving him a pass for being really good at capitalism.
No it isn't. It is illegal as the laws are written. It's not "treason" by any reasonable legal interpretation.
I'm focusing on right and wrong because I assumed that you were taking the much more reasonable stance that he's a traitor in a moral sense, that it should be considered treason, rather than the completely absurd claim that it's treason in a legal sense, that it is or will be considered treason. Get back to me when he's behind bars lmao.
I'm not "giving him a pass for being good at capitalism." I'm just recognizing that everyone at the top is corrupt and guilty of all sorts of shit. It's a free market economy, after all.
We're in an artificial intelligence arms race and Nvidia is providing "the enemy" with US technology. He is directly contributing to us losing the "fight"
He's not going to jail because the admin is corrupt so I guess we'll never talk again, darn!
Lol. First of all, who decided that China is "the enemy?" We're not at war, last time I checked. How are the courts determining what constitutes an "enemy country," and where is the list of which countries are "enemies" and which ones aren't? Just because you personally consider them an enemy doesn't mean shit.
Second, development of technology is not a "fight." There are plenty of companies that do business in China, including R&D, for example, Apple. Is Apple also guilty of "treason?"
He wouldn't be going to jail under any president in recent history or any president that would be realistically elected. It doesn't really have anything to do with the current administration, which, if anything, is targeting him more than others would because they're invested in upholding the tarrif laws they enacted. Capitalist systems don't just go around throwing billionaire CEOs in jail over things like this.
Unless he receives a formal pardon (which he won't), then future administrations will be completely free to prosecute him if they so choose. They won't though, regardless of party, regardless of who gets in. Even if AOC were president, she wouldn't prosecute him for treason. If you think otherwise, you don't understand the system.
The absolutely fucking nothing understander has logged in
Then why don't you answer any of my questions, oh thing understander?
There's no arguing with jingoism & sinophobia. These are deeply unserious people.
Jensen wasn't doing this as a conscious objector to export restrictions, he was doing it to enrich himself, just like his artificial inflation of chip prices and buying the democratic process.
Restricting GPU exports to a rival authoritarian nation and preventing the most corrupt MAGA administration in history from violating those controls for self-profit is a national security issue, not “maga/export nonsense”, whatever that is supposed to mean.
China supports Russia in its illegal, brutalist, and completely unnecessary invasion of Ukraine.
China has been preparing to invade and take over the sovereign nation of Taiwan for decades, largely for its chip-making capabilities.
China enslaves and genocides its own Uyghur citizens in concentration camps.
China is an authoritarian hyper-surveillance state.
Preventing China from achieving tech dominance and from achieving its authoritarian geopolitical goals is in the direct interest of every single American, and most of the freedom-loving world. Jensen Huang and the Trump administration violated that interest to enrich only themselves and the CCP, which is why they are traitors.
The reason mainland China wants to reunite with Taiwan isn't over chip-manufacturing, but because the US maintains it as a military base, similar to the Republic of Korea and Japan. China has its own growing chip industry that is largely self-sufficient and is rapidly approaching the peak of western chip design. The government of Taiwan doesn't consider itself to be a distinct island nation, but instead the rightful rulers of all of China, including the mainland. Both the PRC and ROC agree that the mainland and the island of Taiwan are China collectively, where they disagree is in which government is legitimate.
China also isn't committing genocide or enslaving Uyghur people. Allegations against China were downgraded from genocide to human rights abuses, and the overwhelming majority of "evidence" of the abuses comes from Adrian Zenz, a far-right Christian Nationalist that is quite literally a paid propagandist for the Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation. I recommend reading Xinjiang: A Resource and Report Compilation for a more comprehensive understanding.
China isn't abnormally predatory when it comes to surveillance, western countries have similar or worse surveillance on average. China also has some of the highest perceptions of democracy in the world:
This is because of their democratic structure, which is based on people's councils laddering upwards, and an adherance to the Marxist-Leninist strategy of the Mass Line. The details and functions of China's democratic system are covered in professor Roland Boer's Socialism in Power: On the History and Theory of Socialist Governance.
You're contributing to a New Cold War, to nobody's interests except the United States ruling class. They want you to fear China, so that you do not question your own system, or push for cooperation that could provide cheap solar power and technological advancement for all.
Someone should put rare earth restrictions my my country for its repeated brutal, legally questionable invasions of multiple countries across the middle east for the last 30 odd years.
Yeah, them an auth bunch. But it's very difficult/futile to restrict GPUs as they are easy to buy and smuggle.
Either go full control or don't. This was never designed to be effective.
When it comes to China, liberals in the US are just as far-right/fascist as MAGA. Seriously, read any anti-chinese comment on Lemmy and replace China with Mexico in that comment and you will think you're on truth social.
Mexicans are copying our research! Sheinbaum is ethnically cleansing a minority group! You can't talk about tiananmen square in Mexico!
To clarify, yes, those are all fascist concepts.*
The Chinese are human, like you and I. There is no such concept as 'copying research' as a negative thing. Research specifically increases human understanding of a thing. Intentionally keeping others ignorant based on invisible borders and one-sided hostility is evil. It is unimaginably evil. But also, yes, MAGA does claim that Mexicans are stealing US IP.
No, China is not committing ethnic cleansing., Mexico did though. MAGA doesn't have a problem with either.
You can’t talk about tiananmen square in China! This one is just a far-right myth. It has never had a basis in reality. Here's Xi talking about it on Chinese state media.. Here's a chinese state media article about it. How about a college site addressing it?. There's plenty of others when you just search for 天安门广场事件 on any chinese search engine, but obviously not in English. The english version of the search probably is banned, given the rampant misinformation.
I'm not anti-China by any means, I just thought it was a funny claim
China is a dictatorship whose leader removed term limits and declared themselves ruler for life. The same cannot be said for Mexico, regardless of whatever denial and deflection du jour you're offering.
The censorship is plain to see, just ask Deepseek about it: https://live-production.wcms.abc-cdn.net.au/46be8e7eb29fae679492442de6679edf
Incorrect, it is a council democracy.
This is also incorrect, and speaks to just a general ignorance of how democracy works.
Well given you haven't offered any evidence to support your point that goes counter to actual reality, I can't really say you're correct. Also, let's say you were, MAGA says Mexico is run by unelected cartels. Hence why you racists are just MAGA but against Chinese people.
...And just like MAGA you think AI, sorry, SI is a source of knowledge. God you BlueMAGA really do make it so easy to just dunk on you.
Democratic socialist, not American here, also my partner is Chinese: wont stop me from saying: China is a fascist dictatorship.
Edit: definitely a sign i need to be as wary of lemmy as reddit. 6 downvotes for calling the CCP a dictatorship is worrying ngl
China is a socialist country, run via democratic means. Social ownership is the principal aspect of the economy, and the working class controls the state. All socialism is democratic, the term "democratic socialism" in practice just means reformism, ie social democracy.
The country that disappears young ladies for throwing some ink on a poster?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dong_Yaoqiong
The same china that demands state patriotism before eligibility for office?
Yeah no fuck that noise. China is not democratic.
The country with billionaires next to people pooping in community outhouses?
The so called communist country with private, expensive, debilitating Healthcare costs?
Yeah fuck that noise too, China isnt socialist either.
China has some of the highest perceptions among its people about the health of their democracy:
This is because China has a system of consensus building and council democracy, from the lowest levels to the highest. You can read more about it in Socialism in Power: On the History and Theory of Socialist Governance by professor Roland Boer.
Your chauvanist views of China don't hold water. China is not capitalist. China marketizes underdeveloped sectors of the economy, while having social ownership of the commanding heights of the economy. This is based on the Marxist understanding of contradiction and the economic basis of different forms of production. The basis of markets is in disparate, decentralized production, while the basis of planned economy is in centralized production.
Markets naturally centralize through competition and technological advancement, preparing themselves for planned economy. To plan underdeveloped sectors of the economy is to place strain on administration, because the mechanisms and infrastructure to plan such an industry has not been developed yet through markets. This is classical Marxist economics, views held by Marx, Engels, and Lenin.
Block me if you want, that's your choice, but please be serious for a moment. Yelling about evil communists like you're McCarthy and repeating a firehouse of nonsense is hardly sensible.
Well no shit, you're Canadian. Anti-chinese racism is not higher in any other country on Earth.
My wife is Chinese. Take off with your gaslighting.
Edit: it is a typical strategy to accuse anyone critical of the CCP as being racist to chinese which is a ridiculous and dangerous line of reasoning. Israel does the same with respect to calling critics of the regime anti-semetic.
Plenty of racists marry minorities.
There are things you can criticise China for, but buying some GPUs... Ehh, so fucking what?