296
Analyze This (lemmy.nz)
submitted 4 hours ago* (last edited 4 hours ago) by homesweethomeMrL@lemmy.world to c/politicalmemes@lemmy.ca
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] drolex@sopuli.xyz 81 points 3 hours ago* (last edited 3 hours ago)

Hope this can be backed with:

  • the ranking algorithm definition and how it was derived from the UN criteria
  • which historical facts (duly sourced) were used to calculate each leader's score

Otherwise we are just idly intellectually masturbating.

ETA: I'm a moron, I didn't see the sources. Good on her for providing the recipes. I find them heavily biased towards the goal she wants to achieve, but it's a nice start, good work.

[-] dou9m@lemmy.ca 16 points 1 hour ago
[-] Catoblepas@piefed.blahaj.zone 5 points 1 hour ago

This sitting as the top comment for the post should tell you how much you should trust the takes on lemmy in general.

[-] Krudler@lemmy.world 1 points 26 minutes ago

I keep telling people, much to everybody chagrin... Lemmy is little different than any other social media site... Among the intellectually stimulating folks, is every fucking idiot you've ever met in your regular life... Here to boldly share their opinions with you

[-] emeralddawn45@lemmy.dbzer0.com 1 points 6 minutes ago

I mean it's definitely steadily gotten worse, and especially in the last few months as the Reddit holdouts have finally started to migrate en masse. I fully welcome people who have somehow never heard of Lemmy until now, but for the people who were aware of the alternative but decided to stick with Reddit despite all the bullshit over the last 3+ years and are just now deciding enough is enough, maybe theres somewhere else that's a better fit for them.

[-] Zephorah@discuss.online 16 points 3 hours ago

Now I just need to search and study all the names she listed outside of US presidents.

[-] drolex@sopuli.xyz 5 points 2 hours ago

As a set of moral red lines to never cross, right? Right?

😏

[-] Prove_your_argument@piefed.social 2 points 15 minutes ago

There’s a scoring and ranking system. Everybody wants to be the next GTAVI review score.

Can you get there?

[-] gasgiant@lemmy.ml 4 points 3 hours ago

I know most of the names but I think it's a fairly safe assumption that they're all top rate corrupt mfs.

Just as if they compared Netanyahu to Pol Pot, Hitler, Stalin and two other people. It would be fairly safe to assume that the other two weren't like Nelson Mandela.

[-] pelespirit@sh.itjust.works 18 points 2 hours ago* (last edited 2 hours ago)

I disagree with you on trying to find the goal. Here is the scale she used:

Eight criteria totaling one hundred points.

  • Enrichment of the leader and family through the o8ce carries a weight of 20 points, because corruption that leaves nobody richer belongs to a different category of misconduct
  • Bribery and pay-to-play carry 15 points
  • Disabling the institutions that detect corruption carries 15 points
  • Obstruction of justice and the use of prosecutors against opponents carry 12 points
  • Nepotism, pressure on the press, and election manipulation carry 10 points each
  • Self-protective pardons and impunity carry 8 points.
  • Election manipulation - 10 points
  • Pressure on the press - 10 points

Each criterion is scored from 0 to 10 against fixed anchors. A 4 means senior officials were involved and formal findings exist. An 8 means the conduct was directed by or for the leader at scale. A 10 means the state is organized around it.

[-] merc@sh.itjust.works 1 points 5 minutes ago

Why 20 points for Enrichment? Why 12 for obstruction of justice?

How can someone say that Trump is at a 5.5 on election manipulation now, but will be at an 8.4 by 2029, and use 8.4 in the calculations?

When it comes to enrichment, all it is about is their wealth when entering and leaving office? It doesn't draw a distinction between directly withdrawing money from the funds stored at a country's central bank and depositing them in a personal account in Switzerland, vs selling a memecoin that idiots choose to buy? By that standard, if a president writes a best-selling book while in office they're automatically corrupt? Also, it doesn't take into account the underlying wealth of the country, so a Papa Doc Duvalier who took lots of money from Haiti, but Haiti was really poor so there isn't much to loot is listed as less corrupt than Mobutu Sese Seko because there was more to steal in Zaire?

These scales also don't account for violence or the threat of violence. Putin has had a bunch of people murdered, which has allowed him to silence anybody who tries to stop him from doing what he wants. Trump is certainly responsible for a lot of deaths, but I don't think anybody knows of any Democratic politicians or any judges that he has had killed.

Trump is currently at 6.5 and projected to be at 8.8 on "Pressure on the press" despite his "pressure" mostly being whining about reporters being mean, tirades on Truth Social, and trying to exclude certain journalists from the press pool. Meanwhile most of these other dictators actually had journalists killed, had news organizations destroyed, implemented full censorship, etc.

For "Obstruction and weaponized prosecution" you'd think that whether someone was convicted and thrown in jail would be an important element. In fact, bypassing the courts to simply have someone disappeared would be something you'd expect to be near the top. It's true that Trump has tried to do a lot of politically motivated court cases and prosecutions, but he keeps losing virtually every single one of them. If you follow the courts it's laughable how bad his lawyers are, and how often they lose. And yet, he currently rates a full 7.5 on that scale, with the expectation he's going to reach a 9.1?

There's no question Trump is the worst and most corrupt president in US history. But, it's ridiculous to say that he's more corrupt than Putin, Suharto, Sese Seko, etc. And to pretend that someone arrived at a numeric value of his corruption by some "objective" calculations is just laughable.

this post was submitted on 18 Nov 2026
296 points (98.7% liked)

Political Memes

2776 readers
866 users here now

Memes for not explicit politics: !memes@sopuli.xyz

founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS