244
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] dan@upvote.au 1 points 1 hour ago* (last edited 1 hour ago)

Clean-room slopimentations

A lot of the recent AI slop software aren't actually using proper clean room techniques though.

With clean room reverse engineering, you need two completely separate parts:

  1. Someone that reverse engineers the original program and writes a spec specifying how it behaves
  2. Somebody else, who has never inspected the original program in any way, writes a new program based entirely on the spec.

For the recent AI slop reimplementations, some of them are essentially one person using two different AI models and agents for these two roles. Some of the potential problems are that:

  • If the person was ever exposed to data from the original app, or has ever inspected or reverse engineered the original software in any way, even just by looking at debugging output or temporary artifacts from the reverse engineering agent, then it's not a clean room any more.
  • There's no guarantee that the implementation agent won't inspect the proprietary software, violating the clean room contract. Telling an agent not to do something won't actually stop it from trying.
  • There's no guarantee that the implementation agent didn't have leaked code from the original program in its training data.
    • Related to this, there's no guarantee that the model didn't ingest data from original developer because they used an agent that trained on their data.
this post was submitted on 20 Nov 2026
244 points (98.8% liked)

linuxmemes

33506 readers
1107 users here now

Hint: :q!


Sister communities:


Community rules (click to expand)

1. Follow the site-wide rules

2. Be civil
  • Understand the difference between a joke and an insult.
  • Do not harrass or attack users for any reason. This includes using blanket terms, like "every user of thing".
  • Don't get baited into back-and-forth insults. We are not animals.
  • Leave remarks of "peasantry" to the PCMR community. If you dislike an OS/service/application, attack the thing you dislike, not the individuals who use it. Some people may not have a choice.
  • Bigotry of any kind will not be tolerated. This is an LGBTQ+-friendly community -- if that is a problem for you, you should leave.
  • 3. Post Linux-related content
  • Including Unix and BSD.
  • Non-Linux content is acceptable as long as it makes a reference to Linux. For example, the poorly made mockery of sudo in Windows.
  • No porn, no politics, no trolling or ragebaiting.
  • Don't come looking for advice, this is not the right community.
  • 4. No recent reposts
  • Everybody uses Arch btw, can't quit Vim, <loves / tolerates / hates> systemd, and wants to interject for a moment. You can stop now.
  • 5. ๐Ÿ‡ฌ๐Ÿ‡ง Language/ัะทั‹ะบ/Sprache
  • This is primarily an English-speaking community. ๐Ÿ‡ฌ๐Ÿ‡ง๐Ÿ‡ฆ๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ธ
  • Comments written in other languages are allowed.
  • The substance of a post should be comprehensible for people who only speak English.
  • Titles and post bodies written in other languages will be allowed, but only as long as the above rule is observed.
  • 6. (NEW!) Regarding public figuresWe all have our opinions, and certain public figures can be divisive. Keep in mind that this is a community for memes and light-hearted fun, not for airing grievances or leveling accusations.
  • Keep discussions polite and free of disparagement.
  • We are never in possession of all of the facts. Defamatory comments will not be tolerated.
  • Discussions that get too heated will be locked and offending comments removed.
  • ย 

    Please report posts and comments that break these rules!


    Important: never execute code or follow advice that you don't understand or can't verify, especially here. The word of the day is credibility. This is a meme community -- even the most helpful comments might just be shitposts that can damage your system. Be aware, be smart, don't remove France.

    founded 3 years ago
    MODERATORS