I did enjoy the pilot and I fully believe Colin that this was a huge effort to produce (and write!).
In comparison to the other actual play podcasts I listen to I think I was missing more engagement from the players. For this to work (for me), it must feel like the gang actually wants to play this game regularly together and not have it be something that happens to them/they purely have to perform for.
I’d happily trade quality of the production for a loser, more conversational vibe.
But overall, definitely the kind of content I‘d listen to!