Cul de Sac
Touch of Evil
Freaks
Cul de Sac
Touch of Evil
Freaks
Seems no one has said the Seven Samurai yet.
Since I have (older) kids, I can add another layer to the analysis of "timeless" movies, because for me, they would be movies that would still hold the attention of my kids.
A lot of good ones have already been mentioned, but I would like to submit "Independance Day". Yes, it is cheezy at times, but not because of its age, it always was that way. It held my kids interest. They noticed that none of the people running from the alien ships had their phones out, because smart phones didn't exist yet. And I found that they already knew the most impactful points, because of all the memes.

Raiders of the Lost Ark
Went to the theater to see a Flashback Cinema presentation of Jaws. I know I've seen it before, but I didn't remember much of any details, so it was like watching it for the first time. I've gotta say, I can see now why it's the classic it is. It was still quite scary and gave me a couple of genuine jump-scares.
I recently heard a podcast about the making of The Thing, and I think the story of isolation and those special effects hold up, so I'd throw that out there too.
For an older movie, I think everybody should see The Breakfast Club at least once. It does rely on some 1980s tropes, like weekend detention, and people not having cell phones, but otherwise, solid timeless movie.
For a newer one, 君の名は。 (your name.) is still the best film I've seen to date, and I've seen a lot of them. It's kind of a shame it's Japanese, and animated, because that means a lot of people will give it a pass. The film could have been made in any country with practical effects (fun fact: JJ Abrams bought the rights and a script was even penned, the city was going to be Chicago and the small town was going to be in New Mexico, in the US) but so far, it hasn't been. If it ever happens, I think it will reach a wider audience, but, until then, I'm fine with just being right while also in a minority opinion.
Some of my favorites from my collection. All are pretty much guaranteed to be a good watch.
Happiness
Arsnic and Old Lace
Black and White version with Cary Grant.
Very funny early dark comedy. Set at Halloween.
Tap for spoiler
Main character goes back to the two aunts that raised him to tell them that he just got married and in the process stumbles across the fact that they are serial killers. They find lonely old men that have no family and poison them. It takes several additional twists from there.
I just recently rewatched 2001 - A Space Odyssey. While some special effects certainly look dated, I'm always amazed at how ahead of of its time it was. Truly a timeless classic.
The Time Machine. Transcendence, i guess? World on a Wire.
Look up the films of Jane Fonda.
9 to 5
Klute
Coming Home
Barefoot In The Park.
Barbarella.
[I just saw someone in the Criterion Closet talking about Klute. Reminded me of how good it is]
1956 - Forbidden Planet (great sci-fi concept and earliest appearance of Leslie Nielsen I'm aware of)
1979 - Alien (sci-fi-horror fusion, strong female lead)
1984 - Gremlins (timeless practical effects, poorly-aged Chinese character)
1985 - Back to the Future (does it need a blurb?)
1994 - Dumb and Dumber (classic Jim Carrey, very quotable)
2000 - O Brother Where Art Thou (Coen brothers, Americana, great soundtrack)
2006 - Idiocracy (goofy concept, now a documentary)
I really enjoyed "The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly" when I recently watched it for the first time. Beautifully shot and the soundtrack is instantly recognizable. Great Movie.
What I like about it that it is essentially a buddy movie. Even though the protagonists seem only motivated by greed (in the end it turns out otherwise, but only just).
The most fun but of trivia is that the first time they blew up the bridge, the cameras weren't rolling. So the Spanish army guys, who were the extras in the battle scene, had to build the whole thing again, just son they could blow it up a second time.
A pair of enthusiasts located the place of the cemetery and restored it, so you can visit it.
High plains drifter and outlaw Josie wales are also excelent.
fist full of dollars / yojimbo
Rashamon
Airplane, time bandits, adventures of Barron Münchhausen, LA Story, the jerk, army of darkness, the shining, Chinatown, a christmas story, 12 monkeys, spaceballs, back to the future 1-3, alien(s), clerks, no country for old men, zombieland, LOTR and cartoon 1978, life of brian, labrynth, to name a few random ones off the top of my head.
You are a person of taste. Nice list.
Army of Darkness out there with one of the best skeleton armies to this day. And you've got so many Terry Gilliam but no mention of Brazil?
I just watched the whole Evil Dead series of films. The new ones are surprisingly good.
Tv show is also entertaining.
Shit, I missed that. I'm going back in!
lucky! its soooo good
I could spend hours writing my favorite movies and Gilliam would be near the top.
They're possibly my favorite director, such wild stuff. Brazil is often one of the first movies I'll show new people as a way to check if they'll vibe with my sense of weird
I just recently saw it for the first time. I loved it and would take more suggestions if you've got any!
I'm a big fan too.
Groundhog Day
Who Framed Roger Rabbit
12 Angry Men, Amadeus, Gladiator, Jurassic Park, The Shining, to name a few. Practical effects always hold up better especially against early CGI.
There is a wealth of good movies out there if you're willing to dig a little. Sometimes you have to get out of your comfort zone or contextualize a film as being a product of its time. But there are great films in every decade back to the late 1920s. I mean, Wings is almost 100 years old but you can still watch it and see how it influenced films that came after.
12 Angry Men was one that immediately came to mind for me too.
The Princess Bride, To Kill a Mockingbird, and the 1951 version of “The Day the Earth Stood Still” are the ones I’ll throw into the ring.
Tbf the robot in the latter is very slightly dated BUT it remains a cult classic for a reason and that’s the writing. One of the earliest “hard” science fiction films and well worth a watch.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Thin_Man_%28film_series%29
The Thin man series is a good group of old films that capture the time it was made.
And after that watch Steve Martins file Dead Men Don't Wear Plaid.
I think Interstellar, while not very old, will probably be timeless.
For an old movie, Blues Brothers.
Ouch, right in my bottle of back pills....
But yeah, Blues Brothers
Interstellar is the movie I’d pick if I was allowed to ever watch just one movie.
Goodfellas
Yes, though it does contain lots of cultural things from the setting's era. Its great though.
Just least week, De Niro saying, "a little bit... A little bit." popped in my head.
North by Northwest. 1959, Hitchcock, Cary Grant.
2001: A Space Odyssey. 1968, Kubrick/Clarke. The movie by itself is an experience; paired with reading the book makes it brilliant.
Not that old, but... bullet train
Share a story, ask a question, or start a conversation about (almost) anything you desire. Maybe you'll make some friends in the process.
RULES
Casual conversation communities:
Related discussion-focused communities