Not sure if the interest in TTRPGs extends to actual play shows, but 3 that I have enjoyed are:
- Not Another D&D Podcast (NADDPOD): The other D&D actual play filled with former CollegeHumor people, the most famous being Dimension 20. First campaign is very classic D&D vibes to me, but with the twist that the world has already been saved by legendary heroes and our cast is finding their way in the shadow of that.
- Dungeons & Daddies: A group of dads lose their kids through a portal to the Forgotten Realms, and have to go in after them. Hilarity ensues
- Legend Lark (previously Dames & Dragons): Originally picked this as a counterbalance to the number of RPG podcasts that have a cast of all men. Did not disappoint. Great custom world and atmosphere, and the cast is extremely funny.
These are all comedy actual play casts because that's what I like. I will also caveat that I'm not caught up on any of them, and I've listened by far the most to NADDPOD, and give them some money on their Patreon to get bonus content.