31

There are many dead or entirely empty communities on Lemmy.world. Many of which seem to have been founded simply to squat the space here on the Fediverse. This has come to my attention when I noticed that many communities I have requested moderationship of have been founded by a single account.

While I would love it if the fediverse were able to support so many communities, many of these empty spaces are only minor deviations within single topics, at most containing a singular post calling for moderators. My opinion as a proponent for the Fediverse is that a community should first justify it's existence to be made, and evidently, I do not believe that there is capacity to justify these communities currently.

For example, the account, @comcreator@lemmy.world (i.e 'community creator'), is the sole moderator and founder of a large amount of communities which are exemplary of those which fail to justify their founding. Many of these communities are in fact, miniscule deviations that may be served by a single community, which can be seen as this account moderates over twenty Call of Duty communities.

I am not familiar with Lemmy's administrative tools, and this is simply a proposal; but if it is both possible, and the admins are willing, I believe it would be best if communities could be requested for deletion. I would, personally, be glad to identify unnecessary communities, which I could propose for deletion. My approach would include a rationale for each proposal, so that the admin team may make an informed decision without being expected to put in undue effort.

top 12 comments
sorted by: hot top new old
[-] ieh@lemmy.world 11 points 1 week ago

So there's no restrictions on creating communities, and generally that is a good idea. It does mean that people will create communities and abandon them, but there's not a huge amount of harm in that. Generally speaking, when searching for communities, it becomes pretty quickly clear what's dead and not dead.

There is one further advantage to Lemmy: It's still small enough that it makes sense to browse the home page of all communities. Unlike other places (I keep wanting to compare to reddit since I spent many years there), even content from tiny/new/dead communities can end up on the front page as it doesn't take many upvotes to get there.

So really, from my point of view, it's not a huge issue to have the communities out there. I mean, it'd be better to perhaps auto-close communities that are idle for so long, but we don't have that capability at present.

Meanwhile, as you know personally since we're working on a few communities right now that I'm overdue to get transferred to you (with possibly one other mod in one of them working with you), that's in my humble opinion the more important way forward.

I'm a new admin here - been here 2-3 months - and one of the things I'm spending time looking at along with ways to catch spammers more quickly (in some ways that hey have been slipping through as there are already a lot being caught) is to look at old open reports and active communities with idle moderators and try to get volunteers to mod.

I'm frankly less concerned about idle communities and more concerned about communities that have open reports (i.e. problems that no mod has handled), idle mods, or no mods - active communities. That's my priority.

Also, we have at least one member of our community team who has been around and working on this issue for a long time, so it's not like nothing has been done - but I'm mentioning them because I don't want to make it sound like I'm doing this big thing nobody else has or could. lol.

The main problem is finding people who are willing to moderate. Also, frankly, moderation is a very very difficult task. Well, it's easy most of the time, but it is something that you must have the right personality for. There's a lot I can't do, but I've got almost 30 years of moderation experience.

Some of those qualities include:

  • Being willing to look at the reports in a timely manner and process them fairly
  • Being willing to take the time to talk to the community, get their consensus on what the rules should be, how the community should work, what it should allow or prohibit
  • Enforce the rules as fairly as as calmly as possible
  • De-escalate where possible

We're all human, and a LOT of mods really aren't great moderators. And that's mostly fine most of the time. You do get users who don't understand, who break rules and then complain about power mods, and sometimes they're right, and sometimes they're annoyingly wrong. lol.

The best moderator is a facilitator. It's not a position of power, it's a position of extra work for little reward.

I get satifaction from it: Finding spammers and nuking their accounts. As an admin, I generally leave things like incivility and bigotry to mods, but on my user account I mod a couple of communities, and when I see invicility or bigotry, it is satisfying to remove it, although it's even MORE satisfying to be able to talk the person out of acting that way when I can do that.

I've turned this into sort of a rant, but it's not intended as a rant, just discussion about the relevant issues, because to me, the MOST important issue is that we need more people willing to be moderators.

My humble opinion on deletion is - I have a mod tool I've developed that gives me a list of communities and activity levels. It even can tell me how active any mods are. So I can identify idle communities with ease, and I could make it easy to nuke them. But I don't think that's a good way forward.

That said, these are all my personal opinions, and I haven't discussed this with my fellow admins. It's worth running it by them - some of the tools I'm working on give us capabilities we didn't have before.

[-] rosahaj@piefed.blahaj.zone 1 points 1 week ago

Very happy to see my post bringing out an insightful take like this on moderation and administration here on Lemmy. I've always known that it's a big task, but hearing it put into perspective like this is eye-opening as to just how much work you all put into keeping this place alive. Kudos for that.

However, you have also given me a perfect opening to elaborate on my rationale for why I believe these empty communities are an issue for Lemmy, which were excluded from the OP for the sake of brevity. So I'm afraid that you'll have to excuse me taking the chance to elaborate on them now.

  • Posting and cross-posting pages allow searching for a community to post in, yet do not have the same tools as the community and search tabs. This means that a user could realistically post in a 'dead' community without realising. This isn't actually too big of an issue on it's face since, as you've stated, "[Lemmy is] still small enough that it makes sense to browse the home page of all communities", but hopefully you'll be able to recognise how this is an issue along with my other points.

  • Many of these empty communities are too specific and resultingly, have never received posts. My opinion is that while it is good to have communities fulfil a certain niche, those niches must first exist. Most of these communities are already served by broader, existing communities, and aren't founded to meet a demand, but rather only to be squatted upon. The inevitable consequence is a myriad of tiny, abandoned, communities that lack both visitors and moderators. And when a community cannot sustain visitors, reportable offences are far more likely to be left unnoticed.

  • Communities are best as well, communities. And due to Lemmy's small userbase, communities benefit more from members periodically browsing them, rather than consistent content. This means posts don't tend to stay in home feeds long enough for much exposure. If broader communities lose activity to 'dead' ones for reasons like my first point, then it is harder to build kinship between members simply because there isn't a common space. Conversely, user responses to this issue may instead promote spam through excessive crossposting. This is a line I've personally struggled to avoid crossing. Being someone who wants to encourage activity on the fediverse, I enjoy sharing a post between relevant communities; but when there may be upwards of four applicable communities (and it requires multiple times more effort to research the candidates than authoring a post), it's hard to not be excessive which then floods user's feeds.

Obviously once you've read all of this you'll see that my opinions are perfect, infallible, and that I would be the only real candidate for head administrator here on Lemmy.world, but we'll leave that conversation for another time ;)

TL:DR, Spreading topics and moderators too thin across spaces makes oversight much more laborious, and squatted communities often don't justify their existance. I exaggerate the severity of the issue, but do so in the interest of illustrating my logic. Hopefully this is good food for thought?

[-] ieh@lemmy.world 3 points 1 week ago

Giving you another top level reply with more information: Another issue raised is that once we remove a community, that blocks the name from being used. We could say "Contact us to have this community unblocked", but people would have to know how to do that, because a removed community wouldn't be able to tell them that. So it would just multiply the problem as users would see a removed community and just come up with an alternate name.

So… it's not great that there's not better solutions… but there's not really.

[-] rosahaj@piefed.blahaj.zone 2 points 1 week ago

I suspected something like this would be the heel, given that federation tends to keep 'ghosts'. Hadn't considered this possibility, though.

I wish that people took the time to stop and read the rules more, as it would make it alot easier to inform users. But I will be the first to admit that's unrealistic.

Ultimately it's up to you admins to decide what will be the course going forward, I just wanted to help prompt that conversation.

Thanks for your contribution :)

[-] Eldritch@piefed.world 2 points 1 week ago

If there is a community like that that you wish to take over, all you have to do is contact the admin team, and make the case that the creator is no longer active or contactable. They will usually turn it over to anyone actually interested in running it.

[-] rosahaj@piefed.blahaj.zone 3 points 1 week ago

I may not have explained myself well enough. I am well aware of having moderatorship transferred by instance admins, having done so myself a couple of times over the past few years.

The intent of this post is to open a discussion about the impacts that mass-founding, and then subsequently abandoning postless communities has on the Fediverse, and what the best response to this would be.

[-] Eldritch@piefed.world 3 points 1 week ago
[-] ieh@lemmy.world 2 points 1 week ago* (last edited 1 week ago)

In progress :)

Also, I think we're all here on basically the same page, minus maybe some details :)

[-] rosahaj@piefed.blahaj.zone 2 points 1 week ago

Fortunately, @ieh@lemmy.world is already doing a great job working at this. This discussion is aimed more towards where adoption isn't a helpful solution, however. Just finished editing a reply where I outline how I believe these communities effect Lemmy as a whole, in fact.

[-] ieh@lemmy.world 2 points 1 week ago

Yep, main things I'm looking for:

  • Been around a little bit
  • Posted some comments in communities
  • Modlog is not excessive (everyone screws up, sometimes mods are wrong)
[-] Eldritch@piefed.world 2 points 1 week ago

Yes, if it's not something that's already posted prominently somewhere it would be a good thing to add. I don't think a lot of people realize this. I probably wouldn't had I not experienced it myself.

There absolutely were a ton of people in 22 and 23 creating tons of communities to squat etc. Nothing wrong with creating one on another instance. But also no reason not to adopted as well.

[-] ieh@lemmy.world 2 points 1 week ago

I'm currently working through active communities with no mods or no active mods, but those with open, old reports first. I'm posting in the communities seeking volunteers. It's an ongoing project :)

I'm not posting outside of those communities because I'd prefer to attract volunteers who browse those communities. :)

And yep, absolutely - I first came here in 2023 in one of the large reddit exoduses. heh. And I see a LOT of accounts that created something still in use that stopped coming here after a while.

this post was submitted on 11 Nov 2026
31 points (100.0% liked)

Lemmy.world Support

3719 readers
2 users here now

Lemmy.world Support

Welcome to the official Lemmy.world Support community! Post your issues or questions about Lemmy.world here.

This community is for issues related to the Lemmy World instance only. For Lemmy software requests or bug reports, please go to the Lemmy github page.

This community is subject to the rules defined here for lemmy.world.

To open a support ticket Static Badge


You can also DM https://lemmy.world/u/lwreport or email report@lemmy.world (PGP Supported) if you need to reach our directly to the admin team.


Follow us for server news 🐘

Outages 🔥

https://status.lemmy.world/



founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS