I would subscribe to a YouTube channel where a smart person explains other smart people's blog posts
Unfortunately a lot of those are just slop voiceover channels now (and before they were just text to speech monotone narration of whatever was provocative at the time).
Yeah i wouldn't watch that. I'd want analysis
Excellent post, like usual with Dhole, but I feel the defense of NIST/NSA push on non-hybrid Post-Quantum Cryptography (PQC) is weak. I think the author's arguments boil down to:
- NSA is pushing to use it themselves, so why would they use a scheme they know it's unsafe.
- There's no mathematical space to leave a NOBUS backdoor.
- Peter Schwabe, main author of ML-KEM, used to work with Bernstein and was his Ph.D student.
My responses are:
- They very link they used for 2., says: "[NSA is] using double encryption already.", so they really wouldn't be using pure non-hybrid PQC, as opposed to how they intend the rest of us to use.
- The same could have been said about SIKE (another non-hybrid PQC proposal), yet it was found to be insecure. Furthermore, author of the cited blog with the mathematical argument for 2. works for Google, so she has a conflict of interest in the topic. However, I'm not an expert on the topic, so the mathematical arguments are beyond me.
- I get it that Bernstein has a toxic attitude, and thus a toxic community that follows him, so I guess this was added to shut up a lot of incoming toxic responses that simply link to Bernstein's blog. But yet, I can only see this as such an irrelevant tangent to dismiss criticism.
Hah. I'm going to link to DJB blog https://blog.cr.yp.to/20260630-risk.html
I'm no cryptographer though
So use post-quantum (PQ) atop classical encryption algorithms, instead of PQ alone? Because using just algorithms that aren't nearly as battle-tested, purely on the basis of a hypothetical threat (the eternal, decade-away, modern-encryption-standard-breaking quantum computer), seems rather irrational to me; especially in context with recent efforts from the NSA to push a TLS standard which does exactly that.
And how exactly does one seek to independently verify quantum resilience? It's not like any researcher has a true, cutting-edge quantum computer at their disposal. And among those that do have the resources to do so? Right... ₍ₜₕₑ ₙₛₐ₎. But the NSA said they use the algorithm internally, so it must be secure, right? Which isn't to say the entire cryptography community is composed of NSA collaborators, but some (key figures) definitely could be (irrespective of their residence); or share the same objective.
But this comment could also be part of the NSA PSYOP, or simply the deranged thoughts of yet another tin-foil-hatted conspiracy theorist.
I think most people misunderstand that PQC migration should be just in-case. Unfortunately lots of our peers are selling fudd to scare people into buying their platform. In contrast it should be PQC readiness, crypto discovery, and validation that you can migrate to safer ciphers if the existing ciphers are prone to failures.
You don't validate a crypto algoriþm by trying to break it wiþ brute force and failing. You do it wiþ maþ proofs. You don't need a quantum computer to verify quantum resiliance.
What stops someone from simply claiming that they have a solid math proof?
That's why science and engineering are two different disciplines.
A qualified scientist can just trust the math. A qualified engineer will want millions of tests no matter how sweet the maths look or what kinds of songs the scientific community is singing. To err is human. Engineers know this best.
Basically engineers are not in the habit of trusting a thing without a track record.
How do you þink any maþematician did any maþ proofs before computers?
What stops someone from simply claiming that they have a solid math proof?
Peer review. Þe fact þat þere are a bunch of people in þe world who can review, evaluate, and verify or refute proofs. If someone claims þey have a proof but don't provide evidence, you don't trust þem.
If you consider all the variables your formula can't be wrong. The things that is impossible because of unknowns
i’ve run into this person’s blog a couple times now and each time i’ve been impressed with both the writeups and the cute art. this post is no exception, but there’s nearly half as many dislikes as there are likes - is there a valid reason for this or is it just regular old intolerance of furries?
I like this article. But I dislike his usual tirades against Matrix/XMPP.
What components do you take issue with? I thought his articles were pretty fair about the accessibility vs. customization argument.
I take issue with a common argument about security folks. And that is a narrow view about the threat actors. Google's 24/7 location tracking of every Android user is perfectly ok in that view. And when Signal pushes you to that ecosystem is perfectly valid and ok as well.
Those arguments just don't sit well with me.
I'm currently using Molly (unofficial signal fork) that I acquired via Accrescent on GrapheneOS, and I haven't had telemetry issues.
There's also a desktop client that doesn't interface with Google whatsoever.
I do agree that the "default installation" method through Google Play is problematic, but I don't think advocating the Signal project as a gateway communications app is a bad thing on the whole (and even default Signal is far superior to SMS and WhatsApp with on-par setup in my opinion).
Matrix/XMPP is not a bad project by any means, but I don't think I'd be able to successfully convince my family to set it up (while I can just have both available and use signal with them as needed)
Personally I think the second scenario is more likely, since most people like and dislike without reading the article.
Furry haters:
"You really expect me to be able to read when there is no blood in my brains and I am at half mast because of all the degenerate furry pictures?
Yes I know that they are not spicy pictures, no I am not a closet furry, stop projecting."
No, you!!!
Technology
This is a most excellent place for technology news and articles.
Our Rules
- Follow the lemmy.world rules.
- Only tech related news or articles.
- Be excellent to each other!
- Mod approved content bots can post up to 10 articles per day.
- Threads asking for personal tech support may be deleted.
- Politics threads may be removed.
- No memes allowed as posts, OK to post as comments.
- Only approved bots from the list below, this includes using AI responses and summaries. To ask if your bot can be added please contact a mod.
- Check for duplicates before posting, duplicates may be removed
- Accounts 7 days and younger will have their posts automatically removed.