The fact that chess is seperated by gender at all shows that these sorts of distinctions have absolutely nothing to do with men being stronger or whatever your average sports MAGA guy says
For chess, they're very open about the fact the women's tournaments are just a way to try to get more women to play. The other category isn't even typically restricted to men, it's open to anyone.
I used to be in a chess club and they wanted to me compete in our local league. When I looked into it, I would have had to sign up to our federation as my assigned gender at birth so I said I couldn’t join.
The amount of shit I got because of it was amazing, apparently I was taking the piss and should have just signed up. I stood my ground and ended up having to leave.
Utter bullshit.
Ugh I’m so tired of cis like that.
That's really fucking stupid. That's something silly like that would affect your engagement in the group. Good riddance.
"I promote my pawn to a quee-"
"Uhhhhm do they have letters from a qualified healthcare provider stating that promotion is appropriate for them? Other pieces might discriminate against them for being a biological pawn so it might be easier NOT to promote. Have they considered that they could just live as a feminine pawn rather than promoting into a queen?"
tfw i supposedly have a biological advantage but i still suck 😔
Why is there a woman's category in chess? Are the pieces heavier in men's chess? Or maybe it's a sexual harassment thing (I've met a few chess players).
The reason there's separate women's competitions is because it's a sport that has traditionally been very unrepresentative of women. Having a separate women's category gives women more playing opportunities and visibility/recognition. It's not a separate league, there are just certain tournaments that are restricted to only women (according to FIDE this does not include trans women, which is unsurprising considering FIDE is an awful, corrupt organization for plenty of other unrelated reasons.).
It was started as a way to recruit more women by being able to hold women-only events
Yeah, and it turns out the reason why women didn't feel comfortable at chess tournaments is the because they're run by the sort of people who want to know about your genitalia
It's because there's always that one guy at the tables from the contemporary stories I've read... But also very systemic shit in the past with for instance Judit Polgar that probably persists although to a lesser degree.
The organisers you barely see for registration, the real problems will be on the other side of the board.
From what I've seen, it's purely an ego and harassment thing (probably comes with the territory of being one of the oldest competitive organizations).
Honestly I'd just rather play against people online, since there's less emphasis on identity to begin with.
I am with you there, it is exclusionary in my opinion. The reason for women's categories is that there is a proven biological advantage, and will lead to exclusion. Not to say that women have never faced hurdles especially with education and a whole can of other worms.
But I think sports should re-evaluate their categories, like how boxing has weight for example. Chess is a great example to remove any gendered separation. Sports where male biological development has shown to have an advantage, I am thinking of sports where testosterone has provable advantage maybe like deadlifts for example (this is a thought up example for this argument, I am not sure if it is true), they have gendered categories to ensure women are not excluded.
But chess I cannot think why there should be gendered categories, will women or men be prevented from playing against the other genders in a competition, or is there a third open category, seems like a very convoluted idea
chess already doesn't have a traditional split of women's and men's categories, it has a split of women's and open. the reason behind it is that women are so underrepresented that even though there is no biological disadvantage to speak of, the trailing upper edge of the bell curve would leave so few of them in high tiers such as grandmaster and international master that they made women's grandmaster and women's international master titles to increase their representation. but nothing bars a woman from competing in open championships and acquiring open titles too. Judit Polgar, for example, is a GM, not a WGM.
imo it's indefensible with this justification not to include trans women. there are even fewer trans women in chess than cis women, so logically, they should be more protected and elevated, not less. and even if fide won't make a full-on trans women category (which they shouldn't for unrelated reasons), they already have a track record of letting people from the more exclusive category compete in the more inclusive one. there is zero mathematical reason to worry about including trans women in women's chess, and there are no arguments for trans exclusion that are in any way consistent with their treatment of cis women.
I bet they think males have an advantage, but in reality they would be ashamed of losing to a girl. Conservative males still behave like they're childs.
Women are free to enter the open tournies, there are no "men only" chess leagues
almost as if all gender criticism, terf feminism, and right wing reactionary politics is all based in misogyny.
I just saw this post when scrolling and know nothing about chess. I didn't even know there was gendered chess before now. But of course there is.
I find it weird sports are gendered at all, but damn you need to be deep into conservative territory to feel a need for gendered chess.
Yeah I don't understand this at all. I can understand wanting to separate physical sports between genders (to a point), but why a game that's entirely strategy? Heck, I'd quite like to see if the best strategists are men or women or if it makes no difference.
It's just a way to try to get more women into the game and into public tournaments. Chess tournaments still tend to skew very heavily male.
They don't even typically have mens only tournaments. They're typically split into a general tournament open to all genders and a women's specific tournament.
I would think the best players are male, not because rhey are more clever, but just because more men play chess. It gives me male vibes like playing FPS Videogames.
The only chess I know is 圍棋.
I wonder if it's the same with Go?
Trans Memes
A place to post memes relating to the transgender experience.
Rules
- Follow lemmy.blahaj.zone community guidelines.
- Posts must be trans related.
- No bigotry.
- Do not post or link to pornography.
- If a post is tagged with a specific gender identity, keep the conversation centered on that identity.
- Posts that assume the viewer’s gender and/or contain potentially triggering content must be spoilered and tagged at the beginning of the post title. Example content-warning tags that you can copy include the following:
[CW: Assumes Viewer is Transmasc][CW: Assumes Viewer is Transfem][CW: Assumes Viewer is Nonbinary][CW: Transphobia][CW: Violence][CW: Weapons/Firearms][CW: Disturbing Imagery]
- Mods can be arbitrary.
Because it apparently has to be said, this community is supportive of all forms of DIY HRT.
Recommendations
- Include other tags in posts for example:
[Transfem/Transmasc/Non-binary]
- Include image description when possible.
- Link to source