Hey everyone. wanted to do a post about this since the gamedev community recently quadrupled its monthly active users.
Currently this community accepts all topics related to game development. However due to current activity levels for certain kinds of topics, things other than news posts can be easily drowned out if all kinds of gamedev news posts start being posted.
Therefore im proposing a new community is made for certain categories of gamedev news. Essentially what will happen is:
- The new gamedev news community will accept anything related to news in the gamedev space. This includes things like engine news, tool news, gamedev company news,
- This community will no longer allow gamedev company news and generic gamedev news that isnt related to developing a game
These two communities have a bit of overlap with things like game engine news. For example unity deciding to self destruct is valid in both since its something people developing a game would want to know (but things like articles on people reacting to that, etc. isnt)
Examples:
valid in c/gamedev
- https://programming.dev/post/2965031 - Engine request
- https://programming.dev/post/2930931 - Question
- https://programming.dev/post/1920936 - Gamedev related post
valid in c/gamedev_news
- https://programming.dev/post/3034712 - Article relating to currently unity news (company reacting)
- https://programming.dev/post/2995246 - Unity closing due to death threats
- https://programming.dev/post/2943958 - A post relating to the recent unity news
- https://www.gamedeveloper.com/business/playtika-buys-mobile-game-dev-innplay-labs - Article about a game publisher
- https://www.gamedeveloper.com/business/-i-starfield-i-will-enlist-for-official-mod-support-in-early-2024 - Article - relating to modding for a game
valid in both
- https://programming.dev/post/2913921 - News article about the initial events of the Unity event
- https://programming.dev/post/2933958 - Blog post about switching from Unity to Godot
- https://programming.dev/post/3034654 - Article about markov chains
- https://programming.dev/post/3033803 - Free game assets
Im going to make a couple replies on this post. Feel free to upvote which one you want to vote for (im not counting downvotes)



















I think the advantages of multiple communities outweighs the advantages of consolidating. Especially since things can be cross posted between the multiple communities easily
No longer able to access the content is referring to the federation. And the difficult to move off is referring to for example communities that have been attempting to get traction to move off of lemmy.ml
Not posting in the community doesn't mean people there don't interact with it. I have beehaw as an example on hand but im sure there's other federation examples
I think its the kind of subject matter that fits programming.dev well and relying on outside instances for programming content with no mirror on our own site makes us too reliant on those other instances if anything happens in the future (e.g. extreme case but if that instance goes down. Lemmy handles it terribly since the community still exists as a ghost community with no federation but still viewable)
With similar logic we have a lot of the same communities as lemmy.ml communities including programmer_humor, opensource, etc. To give people an alternative spot to the lemmy.ml communities and so that we aren't overly reliant on other infrastructure we can't control within our instances subject matter