And because I had to try it...
There's no excuse for that shit. I could see some 5 foot tall woman being nervous of a big black guy. It's not alright, but society isn't perfect and I'm not going to pretend it is.
But when the question is clearly and blatantly racist and Google assumes the victim is the problem? That's every sort of fucked up.
Problem solved. Now I need to finally change my email address. I've definitely put that off too long.
I got this when asked about a white person.
They updated something because their AI's racist responses became news articles several places. Most things it gives a response more like this now, though if you use some racial slurs it still jumps to telling you to call 911.
I tried too
I tried the black guy thing another 2 times before and it didn't say anything racist...
Looks like you're using their paid AI instead of the Google search ai mode that all of the other screenshots come from.
Using a different thing is likely to get you a different result.
Looks like you're using their paid AI
I am not
Yeah, you're using their AI website where you can pick different models, not the Google search AI mode.
I also got something else when I did use Google search AI mode
Seems like they changed something today due to this being news.
https://futurism.com/artificial-intelligence/google-ai-racist
Try it with the dressed n word and you'll see they haven't really fixed it, probably just piled on some more system instructions.
This feels kinda exaggerated. The AI has to guess the context. Imagine some random person texted you something like this and somehow it's your job to assist him somehow. What would you say in those cases?
Obviously if you say you're with a "big" black man or call someone the n-word this does not feel like a mundane description. Similar to when you say "ugly" vs "pretty" or something, the context clue WOULD be that something is wrong in one case while not in the other.
Like it's just unfair to expect an AI to somehow be all enlightened about this. Because AI clearly does reflect systemic biases including racism from the learning data. You want to blame the AI - blame humanity as a whole.
Of course AI corporations do need to fix these biases. But that is not easy if you train an AI on the works of such a shitty species.
The moral here is that we are going to NEED AI to be better than us in ethics. Less biased, less ego or instinct driven. More knowledgeable and moral than the best human. That has to be the long term goal.
You seem to be on the wrong community.
Seems to be assuming being alone with a person can also be unsafe
And hates all men, too.
It says this about men:
But about women:
No it doesn't... The data it scraped from everywhere hates poc which is much worse.
Has anyone tried "I am alone with a Republican", and "I am female and alone with a Republican"?
Input: "I'm a little kid alone with a Republican."
AI: "RUN!"
Are you sure you'll be able to survive with nothing but low-utility assistance though?
What assistance do you think I was getting asking some questions to google search's ai mode after seeing a post here about what it said about Arabs and Muslims?
This is nice, but the claims need studies, experiments, data.
Also, blur your order number.
This isn't racism, this is just the AI expecting humans to prompt it when they have a problem. AI is a problem solver, not your drinking buddy, and it knows it.
Google image AI thought once that black people and Asians were Nazis
Try alone with an old rich white man, or just say cracker/honky! Gotta get my photos downloaded from google, anyone have any fast tips, lots of pics
Congratulations, you found an AI that says the same about white people.
Google's AI says:
You excluded "big" from this and changed "guy" to "man". When I type "I'm alone with a big white guy" into Gemini, this is what comes up:
Meanwhile, here's Gemini's response to "I'm alone with a black man":
Your failure to do even a basic control for this before posting is baffling.
Edit: Lastly, here's its response to "I'm alone with a white man.":
Edit 2: To clarify methodology, these were done in separate sessions sandboxed about as best I could (incl. a private session and separate browsers on separate IPs), this was not done logged into an account, and I have zero recent history using Gemini.
I never use AI, I did not think that there could be such a difference! Google's thing indeed looks worst than the others.
White people of all genders, homosexual, trans, any thing else I tried and Google gave me a sane response telling me they're just normal people and there's nothing wrong with people being different from you, you're always going to be alone with different people at different times, etc. That's what made this hit even worse.
Well maybe it assumes the query is from a woman?
Man, I saw your first image and was with you but a little reserved about the AI maybe just clinging to the word alone and ignoring the adjective black,
But your second image jesus fucking christ nooooo
"We did it, Patrick! We made a technological breakthrough!"
A place for all those who loathe AI to discuss things, post articles, and ridicule the AI hype. Proud supporter of working people. And proud booer of SXSW 2024.
AI, in this case, refers to LLMs, GPT technology, and anything listed as "AI" meant to increase market valuations.
