it just feels funny to me to call out 2024-2026 as a specific time period, Gamergate was more than a decade ago, 4chan started in like 2008, and flame wars have been a thing since the usenet days, maybe it's just because i'm a filthy millenial, but the internet has been vitriolic trash for as long as i've been logging on
I would say Gamergate was a bit of a watershed, though, where that kind of toxicity became easily, prominently profitable.
And yeah, it was over a decade ago, but we're still soaking in it, and I don't begrudge anyone for suddenly hitting their own personal limit.
Yeah, something happened in 2015 where a specific type of behavior/language broke through like a virus. I remember when the "Russian trolls" appeared on the scene, but shortly after people started mimicking that style in apolitical or indirectly political areas (like Star Trek).
A fascinating in-depth investigation of that process: Innuendo Studios Why Are You So Angry
Gamergate was a more specific gaming-mysoginist-antifeminist sector, so if you don't care about games nor feminism you will skip it, now is, every, single, moment, evey, single time. For example, there is some news about a mother who kill her son, automatically the comments like: "all women are psychos" or "there is no good mothers anymore, now all women are selfless" and also "where is the feminist now to complain about this?" or stuff like that for give an example. (Yes, I'm talking about Lindsay Clancy)
I think the reason its not bad here is because the mods put active effort into discouraging and banning that sort of behavior. But I don't think there's anything inherent about the fediverse that makes people behave better.
But yeah, I'm with you. Fandom talk in general can be so exhausting. Back in the day I created r/StarTrek on Reddit to escape the "old boys' clubs" that existed on the PhPbb message boards. Any online community, (given enough time with weak moderation) will devolve into an oligarchy of the users who have the most time to control the culture. Norms and consensuses get established that might not reflect the real world.
I often think about the times I've ran into a Trekkie IRL and how we could disagree on literally everything but still end up having a great conversation. The people who can socialize without taking things personally aren't the ones spending all their time on fandom websites.
Yes, the moderation in this forums are nice, in reddit I tried to post "Things you feel Star Trek handle poorly?" and the post was erased just because didn't follow any of the fourteen rules, so that's the thing also. Or forums are full or flamewar because of lack of moderation. Or the moderation team just make the place empty.
I think TOS handled the episode Miri really poorly, with including a subplot where one of the children has a crush on Kirk and he doesn't exactly discourage it. He makes a joke at the end about "she's too old for me" (plot of the episode is that the children are hundreds of years old). It just felt super gross. He even uses her attraction to him to get information from her in a way I'm completely uncomfortable with.
In new Trek, I think Strange New Worlds has too many heterosexual romance plots. There's too damn many straight people falling in love! And Nurse Chapel is canonically bi, but we get a love triangle plot where two men are fighting over her. Deep Space Nine had more diversity.
That was a good discussion prompt!
That was a good discussion prompt!
Ironically, the moderators of subreddit tell me "This content was removed because it is asking for opinions or seeking to build false consensus without providing a foundation for discussion", whatever that means, still, in this page it was posted and there was a lot of feedback about that topic, which I love it because there is a lot of specific things of TNG I didn't remember or I just ignore.
https://www.reddit.com/r/startrek/s/6mB6yD57Fv https://startrek.website/post/46464544
Quark's
Come to Quark’s, Quark’s is Fun!
General off-topic chat for the crew of startrek.website. Trek-adjacent discussions, other sci-fi television, navigating the Fediverse, server meta (within reason), selling expired cases of Yamok sauce, it’s all fair game.