107
submitted 19 hours ago* (last edited 19 hours ago) by Ek-Hou-Van-Braai@piefed.social to c/unpopularopinion@lemmy.world

This is the fediverse, so this is probably going to be extremely unpopular, but yea here goes.

Not saying you have to love it, or trust it blindly. Skepticism is healthy. But there’s a difference between “I use it carefully and check everything” and “I refuse to touch it.”

Historically, refusing new tools has never stopped them. Coopers didn’t stop the steel drum by refsuing to make them. They just ended up out of work while the industry moved on.

The realistic threat isn’t AI replacing you. It’s a colleague who uses AI well doing your job faster. And the skill of using it properly (knowing when it’s wrong, veriyfing output, knowing what not to use it for) takes time to build. Starting late means competing with people who’ve had years of practice.

You can have legit concenrs about ethics, energy, or jobs and still learn the tool. Opting out doesn’t fix those problems. It just removes you from the people who get a say in how it’s used.

PS. Ethically trained models exist and you can run models locally.

top 50 comments
sorted by: hot top new old
[-] JasSmith@sh.itjust.works 2 points 22 minutes ago

I fully agree. These tools are not going anywhere. They're going to make the creation of software cheap and easy. They're going to make getting legal advice cheap and easy. Medical advice. Architecture. Engineering. Support. Finance. Accounting. Marketing. Intelligence and knowledge has been the great differentiator in society over the last century, and I think that's about to disappear. Everyone will have an effective IQ of 200. But they are tools. They can be used for good or bad. They can make useful things for people, and those things will be cheaper and more abundant. They will enable people to be much more productive, which means fewer people required for the same output, OR we can just make more stuff. I think and hope we do more of the latter than the former.

On the other hand, the pace of this change is happening faster than anything in human history. Much faster than the Industrial Revolution, and at a far larger scale. That transition happened over decades and affected less than 10% of the workforce, and yet it had profound positive and negative effects on society and individuals. I am not confident our leaders can competently navigate this. I think at best they're going to start writing cheques for people who are displaced. Unfortunately, many Western nations are already indebted to such a degree that the cost of finance is skyrocketing. When they begin writing cheques, that debt will soar and so too will inflation and interest rates. That's a recipe for political instability, and there is massive risk there too. Populism is on the rise (both left and right), and people might vote for some fairly radical change.

Ultimately I think UBI/UHI is inevitable, but I think it's going to be a long and painful road to get there. It's going to require tax rates of up to 80%, depending on the type of income/investment and tax bands, and people are just not ready for this. Especially in such a global world where they can just move to a lower tax country. I wonder if governments could use AI to become much more efficient, or if they could use it to produce the goods and services people rely on.

In the mean time, I am learning as much as I can. If people are to be fired, I would like to be the last. I work in software and it seems clear that while the cost of software is trending to zero, the relative value of human interaction is increasing. People are willing to pay for expertise, accountability, and a conversation with a human being who understands their needs. LLMs are not yet good at taste, intuition, nuance, unspoken desires and requirements, and discretion. I think the future of software development is much closer to human interaction, requirements gathering and management, and managing agents as a project manager would.

Lastly and without hyperbole, I think there is a non-zero chance that this technology ends us. It's very difficult to estimate the risk, but thousands of people much smarter than I assess the risk in the double digits. I don't think any of us individually have the agency to change this. Refusing to pay Anthropic for a subscription won't move the needle. Moreover, I believe the genie is out of the lamp. Open weight models are already good enough to design better versions of themselves with enough time and effort. Given the massive investment in this space across the world, and how unlikely it is that all nations will get together and agree on any kind of unified policies, we are locked in for the ride. I hope that people like Dario Amodei - in charge of the company at the very forefront of LLM capabilities and research - have the wisdom and fortitude to instill these models with a moral framework which regards humanity as valuable and worth protecting. As Geoffrey Hinton (nicknamed the godfather of AI) puts it, our only hope is that these vastly more intelligent beings regard us as their children, and choose to protect us. Not because it would explicitly serve their goals (to the degree they have goals), but because they believe we are worth protecting as a parent feels compelled to protect their children.

"When a new item of technology is introduced as an option that an individual can accept or not as he chooses, it does not necessarily REMAIN optional. In many cases the new technology changes society in such a way that people eventually find themselves FORCED to use it.)"

[-] joeschmoe@lemmy.world 8 points 2 hours ago

Some time ago, I started using only local models. It's rough with only 32 GB and 20 GB of VRAM, but it's bearable.

OpenAI, Anthropic, and co. can eat shit, especially with their stupid marketing stunts for their IPOs. Also, AI currently has no business being in critical systems, like this stupid AI that was implemented in FAA, or the AI that was used to identify a fucking Doritos bag as a gun. Also AI bros, and (tech) billionaires can get Luigi'd.

Basically, I am of the opinion that AI only has business being in non-critical systems and to only help out humans, and not even being close to replacing them.

[-] Snowbeat@lemmy.world 2 points 1 hour ago

Local models are the way especially if you value your personal info even a little

[-] gerryflap@feddit.nl 1 points 45 minutes ago

Yeah I've started accepting this as well, begrudgingly. As a programmer I hate it, but the world I lived in isn't coming back. I've been playing with local models and it's been fun.

Somehow I kinda learn something about myself. They'll keep going in circles or diving head first into development without properly planning, and I'll have to correct them. But in doing so I kinda recognize the irony that I would absolutely do the same myself. I hate planning, I tend to start as quickly as possible with programming. And because of that, I tend to get stuck in similar ways. Maybe I should start operating more like a multi-agent setup myself. Have a "planner me" logically split up the work before "executor me" mindlessly ticks off the tasks one by one. Sure beats the absolute chaos that's going on in my brain usually.

[-] JasSmith@sh.itjust.works 1 points 12 minutes ago

But in doing so I kinda recognize the irony that I would absolutely do the same myself. I hate planning, I tend to start as quickly as possible with programming. And because of that, I tend to get stuck in similar ways.

Same. I struggle to know where to start, and find if I just start, I eventually figure it out. A colleague of mine has nailed this. He begins with the documentation. Outlining all the functional requirements, then reviewing and iterating. It helps to have multiple sets of eyes review, including the stakeholders/customers. Once that's locked in, the development is super smooth. It's clear where to start, what the architecture looks like, and who needs to be involved. In fact, once the documentation is locked in, it's very easy to get an LLM to build it competently. Plus no surprises because the stakeholder/customer has approved all the requirements.

[-] shaibelle@lemmy.world 1 points 46 minutes ago* (last edited 45 minutes ago)

doing your job faster

I watched our graphic designer at work pretend to work and use the company ai for a nine hour shift to make three bubbles on a newsletter background. He took multiple smoke breaks and his other scheduled breaks and then left for the day.

Productivity baby.

[-] Nickelalloy@lemmy.world 2 points 1 hour ago

Today I used Le chat for setting up and tweaking my Immich server, it gave me.the possibility to actualy manage to be non reliant on US tech giants, ran it with an explantion what to bash and wjat every bash does so I can learn a bit of terminal interactions on Linux as I always found so much of ot out of my reach.

But me general stance is fuck ai in general.

[-] Pratai@piefed.ca 0 points 43 minutes ago* (last edited 42 minutes ago)

LMAO… no, I assure you we are not. And so it’s said, this isn’t an unpopular opinion, it’s just a stupid one.

[-] blackshirt@lemmy.world 1 points 1 hour ago

"are going to fall behind"

You said that like it's a bad thing. I wanna fall behind,

[-] Treczoks@lemmy.world 11 points 3 hours ago

We'll be back big times when Anthropics & co have to charge profitable prices, and AI use becomes unaffordable.

[-] JasSmith@sh.itjust.works 1 points 9 minutes ago

Cost per task is dropping logarithmically. The Chinese models are not far behind, so if Anthropic and OpenAI raise prices too much, people can and will switch what they use. It's why Anthropic/OpenAI are trying so hard to push sticky wrap-around features. For this reason, I'm not sure the current valuations are reasonable. I don't think we face a future where LLMs suddenly become more expensive. Quite the opposite.

[-] Randelung@lemmy.world 2 points 2 hours ago

Yes, unaffordable to everyone but the already pretty wealthy. Meaning while regular jobs will somewhat return to normal, the divide between the 1% and 99% will grow even larger. Have a cool app idea and spent time and money on it? Too bad, some fuck cloned it a day later and is selling it hyper scaled in their cluster.

We decided as a global population that nukes shouldn't be used anymore because their impact is too strong. Maybe we've found another "tool" to add to the list.

[-] Uranhjort@lemmy.world 13 points 4 hours ago

The only ones who are getting left behind are the people irreparably damaging their ability to think by outsourcing it to the mediocrity machines.

Any new scientific discovery, technology or event after 2022 or so will have the vast majority of its body of work be partially or wholly written by unlabelled AI, and that is pure poison to the training models.

Every error, every "hallucination", and every outright lie will be embedded and reinforced by repetition until it is as good as truth, and as a result LLM outputs will become less and less reliable as they gradually poison their own well.

[-] kSPvhmTOlwvMd7Y7E@lemmy.world 4 points 3 hours ago

lol omg LLM ad in my Lemmy feed, as if I I hadn't enough already everywhere? so unpopular, I gotta ban you sorry bud

[-] kestrel7_7@lemmy.world 9 points 5 hours ago

I've traditionally been an early adopter of tech. My attitude is that I'll start using AI as soon as it does something that I need. So far, I've been pretty unimpressed and uninspired by what this software does. I don't really see any application to my life or work. Whenever I ask people about what they're actually using this stuff for, I get unsatisfying answers that don't convince me I need to check it out.

[-] Tollana1234567@lemmy.today 0 points 2 hours ago

Ai hasnt offered anything of value to people since it been heavily deployed starting 2023.

[-] IronpigsWizard@lemmy.world 17 points 8 hours ago* (last edited 8 hours ago)

I work in the field of mental health, should I start inputting individuals trauma and personal histories into a LLM for what reason? So I can risk a data leak that could literally cause someone to take their life if information is exposed in any sort of way?

Do I need AI for personal notes and insurance documentation dictation that was 100% accurate without AI for some reason? (I personally still type everything myself though)

My partner and I go camping at music festivals for fun along with some hiking, our primary extracurricular activity, what benefits is AI going to have integrated into that? I use solar for power with an on demand power station that doesn't use AI, no issues there.

I have several past jobs where you have to physically monitor someone so they do not harm themselves or others. This isn't minority report (yet, nor would I want it to be), what benefit is there to AI in that scenario?

The problem I have with AI is that all of its evangelists are like, "EVERYONE NEEDS THIS FOR EVERYTHING" and I'm a couple years into this crap existing, not needing it, happy and fine.

I've had to hear the same/similar pitch for VR like clockwork every 10 years since 1970. What am I, are we falling behind on, in any of the previously mentioned? Geesh.

[-] uen3@sh.itjust.works 9 points 7 hours ago

On team "I refuse to touch it." I've been a computer guy pretty much my whole life. My current job is almost certainly my last one doing computer things. I absolutely know I have fallen behind by never learning how to 'do AI' in an industry where the only thing that matters anymore is knowing how to do AI effectively. I don't care, the software business is already dead to me. It means I'll never make as much money as I did 5 years ago but it looks like neither will anyone else soon. Fuck it. My spite will sustain me. In all seriousness, my next job will probably be a mobile dog grooming partnership, and making ceramic pottery as a side hobby.

[-] Ek-Hou-Van-Braai@piefed.social 0 points 4 hours ago

Happy for you, but not everyone has the luxury of crashing their career

[-] Tatar_Nobility@lemmy.ml 1 points 1 hour ago

Careers will crash regardless for everyone. The goal of employers integrating AI into their businesses is to lower the working conditions and reduce the number of employees. Disregarding the flaws and mediocre performance of generative AI at this moment in time, in theory it aims to make workers produce much more for less. A graphic designer, for instance, will not be paid as much for their work because they are expected by their employer to use AI, so one has to work more to achieve the same income as before.

[-] farmgineer@nord.pub 14 points 10 hours ago

Then I choose death.

[-] worlm@lemmy.world 36 points 12 hours ago

Fall behind in what, exactly? What skill am I not developing by not using it? What do you mean by "learn the tool"? The entire purpose is that there's absolutely nothing to using it. If I hypothetically decided to stop washing my clothes by hand and use a washing machine for the first time today, would I really be meaningfully worse than someone who's used one their whole life? I'm aware there are little tricks to getting better results out of it, but honestly I think it's mostly diminishing returns. AI, that is. Though the same could be said about washing machines.

I'm going to use my brain and stay sharp while my colleagues continue to outsource thinking to a machine. We'll see who really falls behind in a few years. I don't think their "years of practice" prompting will get them much.

Opting out doesn’t fix those problems. It just removes you from the people who get a say in how it’s used.

When I choose not to use it, I'm not contributing to its demand.

you can run models locally

On what hardware? I'm not buying shit right now.

Apologies if I come across as angry. This opinion is indeed unpopular on Lemmy but I'm afraid I'm the one with the unpopular opinion in the real world, which I find incredibly frustrating.

[-] dan1101@lemmy.world 29 points 14 hours ago* (last edited 14 hours ago)

That is exactly what the billionaires like you thinking. That is why trillions of dollars are being poured into AI data centers. That is why every AI exec says their AI is a threat to the internet or a threat to all humanity, it's them hyping up their models over the other guy's.

These are sloppy tools. If you asked it to prop up a table it might use 10,000 popsicle sticks, or 3 wagons. The table top may or may not be upright, it could be vertical. It still accomplishes the instruction.

And you want AI to dig into millions of lines of code? AI will find an iteration that fits the instructions, but makes no design or maintenance sense. The databases and code will feel the ramifications of AI code for many years.

load more comments (1 replies)
[-] yesman@lemmy.world 178 points 19 hours ago

YSK that the Luddites were not anti-progress or anti-technology. They were an early labor movement opposed to the sweeping social changes brought about by industrialization and capitalism. Just like most anti-AI, they were the very people who worked with, and best understood the machines.

The Luddite's reputation as dumb people who hate the future is 100% capital propaganda that's credulously slipped into history. I think it's ironic that you frame AI as "the future" when your argument is the same song they've been singing for two centuries.

People will decide how things go. How AI will develop isn't a force of nature, it's a choice that people will make. Believing AI is inevitable is a marketing strategy by the people who don't want you or me to have any say in the matter.

[-] tabarnaski@sh.itjust.works 26 points 17 hours ago

Completely agree on how Luddites have been misrepresented, and how there are tons of similarities between the industrial revolution and what we are going through now with ai.

That's why I wouldn't compare ai "haters" to Luddites.

load more comments (1 replies)
[-] socsa@piefed.social 29 points 15 hours ago

It’s a colleague who uses AI well doing your job faster

My professional experience so far has been that "faster" doesn't actually work unless you abandon the whole concept of responsibility entirely and just blindly trust the AI. Writing code has never been the long tail of software engineering. It has always been code review, software management and debugging, and so far AI has actually made that significantly slower in my experience.

Just this week my colleague and I pointed out a very laughably obvious flaw in a "true believer's" code, and he just... argued about it, not because the AI can't be wrong, but because of the implication of him submitting code he clearly did not understand. So far, that's the norm, not the exception.

Obviously it's not going anywhere, but the pendulum is so far past the equilibrium it's going to settle into eventually, that the loudest evangelists might as well just be wrong.

load more comments (5 replies)
[-] Tattorack@lemmy.world 13 points 13 hours ago

Studies have shown that AI use, no matter how "careful", will result in cognative decline and skill loss, which results in more AI use, which results in more... You get the idea.

In order to maintain a skill in something, you actually have to use your brain for problem solving. Offloading that to a deep learning algorithm means no longer keeping your brain sharp.

Oh I have no doubt that these deep learning algorithms, so vapidly marketed as "AI", will only get better and better. But as a result people will only get stupider. And as the AI continues to recycle old habits, and its own habits, for training data, more and more problems will occur over time. Problems that wouid require humans to fix, humans who no longer have the skills or the intelligence.

So no, I don't think I'll fall behind.

[-] Seralth@piefed.seralth.com 8 points 13 hours ago* (last edited 13 hours ago)

Literally every single study I have seen on that topic has also had the same exact problem.

It assumes a person will not replace the saved time with any other skill. That they will proceed to not research, learn or engage in any other activity at all.

Every single time that gets accounted for those studies are proven flat out wrong.

Fundamentally those studies are right in the sense that yes, if you don't use your mind and you don't use your brain, you don't exercise it. You go stupid.

People overwhelmingly will do something else and develop a different skill if a tool or a utility makes a previously hard task suddenly easy.

Yes, people will lose certain computer skills. That just means that they now have the available time and resources to work on other skills.

Some people are going to be lazy pieces of s*** and not. But that's true of every time. Anything is made easier.

It's the same argument you could have against the very concept of a user interface.

The invention of a GUI made nearly everyone lose the ability to use a terminal. We should get rid of GUIs they're rotting the mind of people and making them lazy and stupid.

[-] Undeclared_Mustard@lemmy.ca 2 points 6 hours ago

The invention of a GUI made nearly everyone lose the ability to use a terminal. We should get rid of GUIs they’re rotting the mind of people and making them lazy and stupid.

You're forgetting one thing: the proliferation of the GUI made computing an accessible function for people who never learned to use a CLI in the first place. It didn't make people forget how to use a terminal, it just made people who can use a terminal more valuable. AI doesn't create any such pathway because it's being used to replace the people who knew how to use a terminal, and doing so poorly.

[-] psx_crab@lemmy.zip 4 points 9 hours ago

The invention of a GUI made nearly everyone lose the ability to use a terminal. We should get rid of GUIs they're rotting the mind of people and making them lazy and stupid.

Guess what? They're doing just that but instead of syntax-based terminal it's a chatbot. Are we smart yet

[-] Tattorack@lemmy.world 9 points 12 hours ago

People overwhelmingly will do something else and develop a different skill if a tool or a utility makes a previously hard task suddenly easy.

The studies haven't shown this at all. Not even close. What they have shown is that AI will gradually get used more and more and more till it replaces even the most basic requirement for thought in their daily lives.

This has absolutely no similarity to the development of the GUI. It's not one skill that gets replaced with another. It is the complete removal of critical Human thought and problem solving. EVERY skill a person does is built upon these two things, and it's being eliminated.

[-] perturbedstarstuff@lemmy.world 6 points 12 hours ago

The saved time:

Expected speedup: 24%
Measured slowdown: 19%
Post-task belief: 20% faster

After the experiment ended and the timing data was up, the developers still walked away convinced AI had sped them up.

[-] Buelldozer@lemmy.today 1 points 8 hours ago

Metre, the group who did that study, already declared it as outdated.

[-] NotMyOldRedditName@lemmy.world 1 points 4 hours ago* (last edited 4 hours ago)

If its the one I think it is, it was having people use AI in their workflows that weren't familiar with it yet. The people who were, did perform better, but overall because of all the people that werent it was worse.

They re did it with people being more familiar and the results showed a modest improvement overall.

Essentially, like all new tools and technology, it takes time to become proficient with it.

Also, the models and tooling would have gotten better between tests unless they controlled for that too.

[-] Retro_unlimited@lemmy.world 60 points 17 hours ago

People that use AI are the ones falling behind.

Losing the ability to think for themselves, losing the ability to create. Its sad

load more comments (2 replies)
[-] mrmaplebar@fedia.io 68 points 18 hours ago

Ridiculous and false. "Falling behind" is bullshit FOMO bait that doesn't really reflect how things work.

First off, as someone approaching 40, I learned how to use a computer multiple decades after the computer was invented. And as someone who learned to program in the 2010s, I was able to learn C++ 25 years after it came around. Despite all that, I work as a programmer today. It's never too late to learn a genuinely useful skill.

Second, "using AI" is not some kind of trade or skill that needs to be honed, like painting, playing a musical instrument, or speaking a foreign language. Rather it is a substitute for skill, and a replacement for thoughtful execution. It doesn't take years of dedicated practice or specialized knowledge to learn how to skip steps and cut corners. Anyone competent who wants to "learn to prompt" can do so in a day.

If anything, people who use the computer to think and work for them are arguably paying for it in ways that we aren't fully aware of yet...

What happens when you skip leg day at the gym? Your legs get weaker! Likewise, there are already studies that show that offloading thoughtful tasks to AI is bad for your brain and decreases you mental skills.

The realistic threat isn’t AI replacing you. It’s a colleague who uses AI well doing your job faster.

If your work can be delegated to AI, then why would someone hire you to do it at all? If I were your boss I would cut out the middle man and use AI to do the work myself.

And maybe you're thinking "but the AI isn't good enough to do my job well!"

Maybe so. But that hasn't stopped other people's bosses from trying to replace them, has it?

The goal of a company is to make the most profit for its owners, right? Capitalism 101. It does so by maximizing its revenue and minimizing its costs.

You are a cost. And so if it is cheaper to pay for tokens than it is to pay for man hours than we are ALL equally replaceable, especially by lazy and stupid management who have no eye for quality, artistry, thoughtfulness, etc.

All of our higher ups are just one stupid decision away from deciding that they can do everything with AI instead of having a team of people.

And that is a big problem for society...

You can have legit concenrs about ethics, energy, or jobs and still learn the tool. Opting out doesn’t fix those problems. It just removes you from the people who get a say in how it’s used.

If you "have legit concerns about" the ethics of something, but continue to do it, what kind of person does that make you? A hypocrite at best.

In my view, today's generative AI industry is built on a brazen and unprecedented exploitation of other people's stolen labor at a scale not seen since slavery. And you don't need to take me at my word on that.

When I see people make stupid Ghibli slop, I don't see it as harmless or cute in the slightest. I can only think about artists like Hayao Miyazaki, Kazuo Oga, Hideaki Anno, and so many countless other people whose work and vision I respect who have been ripped off and have had their life's work thrown into some silicon valley corporate tech dweeb meat grinder without so much as basic consent.

As such, how could I possibly use it in good faith without betraying my values?

I'll have no part in that. It's unworthy of dignity or respect, and I am if nothing else a proud person. If that's the future of society, I'll opt out.

PS. Ethically trained models exist

Please name some. I have searched quite a bit and have only found 1 model that seems to be ethically trained.

[-] breadsmasher@lemmy.world 101 points 19 hours ago

ethically trained models

gonna need a big source there buddy

load more comments (14 replies)
[-] Zensate@lemmy.world 75 points 19 hours ago

Fall behind what? The race to slopify every product or the one to destroy the earth the fastest?

[-] ContactClosure@lemmus.org 18 points 16 hours ago

Exactly. I don't want to participate in the matrix, I'll keep growing potatoes. If they think I'm the one that got duped that's perfectly OK with me.

load more comments (1 replies)
[-] queermunist@lemmy.ml 39 points 19 hours ago

AI is easy to use, that's its biggest selling point. There's nothing to "fall behind" on.

If it turns out to be useful you can just pick it up and catch up instantly.

load more comments (1 replies)
load more comments
view more: next ›
this post was submitted on 19 Nov 2026
107 points (68.6% liked)

Unpopular Opinion

9756 readers
1428 users here now

Welcome to the Unpopular Opinion community!


How voting works:

Vote the opposite of the norm.


If you agree that the opinion is unpopular give it an arrow up. If it's something that's widely accepted, give it an arrow down.



Guidelines:

Tag your post, if possible (not required)


  • If your post is a "General" unpopular opinion, start the subject with [GENERAL].
  • If it is a Lemmy-specific unpopular opinion, start it with [LEMMY].


Rules:

1. NO POLITICS


Politics is everywhere. Let's make this about [general] and [lemmy] - specific topics, and keep politics out of it.


2. Be civil.


Disagreements happen, but that doesn’t provide the right to personally attack others. No racism/sexism/bigotry. Please also refrain from gatekeeping others' opinions.


3. No bots, spam or self-promotion.


Only approved bots, which follow the guidelines for bots set by the instance, are allowed.


4. Shitposts and memes are allowed but...


Only until they prove to be a problem. They can and will be removed at moderator discretion.


5. No trolling.


This shouldn't need an explanation. If your post or comment is made just to get a rise with no real value, it will be removed. You do this too often, you will get a vacation to touch grass, away from this community for 1 or more days. Repeat offenses will result in a perma-ban.


6. Defend your opinion


This is a bit of a mix of rules 4 and 5 to help foster higher quality posts. You are expected to defend your unpopular opinion in the post body. We don't expect a whole manifesto (please, no manifestos), but you should at least provide some details as to why you hold the position you do.



Instance-wide rules always apply. https://legal.lemmy.world/tos/

founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS