It's not revolutionary. Especially not in a place where literal privatised prisons exist.
They didn't even do that, let alone be revolutionary.
When did these 'similar things' happen?
So you’re really going to pretend that the Warsaw Pact wasn’t imperialism? Even though you claim NATO is?
NATO is carrying out a genocide and enforces relations of severe unequal exchange, unlike Warsaw Pact which literally acted against all that.
What is your issue with the Warsaw Pact?
Not for lack of trying. If you don’t think invading Georgia and Ukraine count as attempts at colonization
Apart from you not understanding what colonisation is, there are also the following issues:
- Georgia was the one to attack the peacekeepers in South Ossetia, as well as South Ossetians. Not sure what you think Russia should have done differently.
- Ukraine had a NATO coup d'etat, and immediately attempted to become a glorified NATO military base (while also selling off its wealth to NATO capitalists in unpopular moves). That is an unambiguous act of aggression, and I am again not sure what you think Russia should have done differently.
There is essentially fuck-all difference between Russia under Putin and the US under Trump
Apart from the fact that, for all its massive faults, contemporary Russia hasn't been the aggressor in military conflicts (no, reaction to NATO's aggression via Ukraine is not itself aggression), and has militarily helped various countries fighting against your colonial subjugation of them.
Also, why are you singling out the US and Trump, and not all of the other invaders of Iraq and Afghanistan?
I understand what you think you’re going to accomplish by supporting Russia, but all you would actually accomplish is trading out one imperialist capitalist oppressor for another.
Let's say you were correct. Why wouldn't one trade NATO for a much more manageable foe?
I do not find them trustworthy, no.
Okay, what agreements did they break, and/or what countries did they invade this century, then?
I don’t like you putting words in my mouth
What words did I put in your mouth?
nor do I like you assuming where my information comes from
There are claims (and opinions) that you are making that have very few sources and those sources are the same where one would get stuff like Iraq having WMDs, so you definitely do need to engage in some reflection.
especially when you’re not even informed about the straight up WMF-level financial colonialism going on in the Congo
Considering that all of the claims about the PRC supposedly engaging in financial entrapment of other governments have been false, I have a good reason to disbelieve this claim unless I see a trustworthy source. (No, Adrian Zenz is not one, and neither is RFA.)
along with many other recipients of Belt and Road funding
Ah, so, it is just Zenz/RFA stuff, again.
To answer your questions: yes, yes, and set up defensive measures.
Defensive measures like what?
Let me remind you that the problem in question was homelessness. Planned economy solve that problem by making it so that all economic agents (in this case we only care about one - the state) are interested in providing guaranteed housing.
As for running out of working-age people, planned economies have been able to provide favorable conditions to people having children and universal healthcare and guaranteed housing so that people don't die simply because that would make some rich guy even richer.
So, you do find those governments trustworthy, and you do understand why the rest of the world does, as well, you just have criticism of some of their policies (in some cases, it is understandable, but, in other cases, it's just old pieces of your empire's propaganda that you're leadership doesn't even bother with trying to substantiate anymore - I recommend you reevaluate what the people that previously sold you on Iraq's WMDs say about their enemies instead of blindly believing them). Not sure what you mean about the PRC doing something bad to Congo.
Also, considering that you seem to find Belarus and the DPRK's help to Russia, I have a couple of questions for you:
- Do you, in that case, condemn Ukraine helping NATO invade Iraq, Syria, Iran, and elsewhere?
- Do you concern NATO self-admittedly pushing for war with Russia (including prior to 2022)?
- What should a state do when the most prolific invader in the world - NATO - starts amassing troops on that state's border?
Liquid assets
Do you think we support either part of the USian uniparty in general?
So, what you are saying is that it is not possible, under capitalism, to provide a solution for the problem that planned economy solves, and that, under capitalism, people will necessarily be tortured by being denied basic necessities like that. If so, I would argue that you are, indeed, correct.
The thing is, Russia is exactly the polar opposite of “supporting bourgois states that fight against imperialism” or being “under imperialist aggression.” Those statements describe states like Ukraine
You think that a state that has invaded Iraq, Syria, Iran, and other places, and has been trying to formally join the gang of other invaders of Iraq and Afghanistan as 'fighting against imperialism'. You are silly.
Also, what do you think a state should do when the most prolific invader in the world - NATO - starts amassing troops near that state's borders, especially after conducting a coup d'etat against a neighbouring state?
Tomorrow_Farewell
0 post score0 comment score
If the views in question are about whether or not the vast majority of people should have decent lives, that's kind of significant.