241
$1$ (lemmy.nz)
top 43 comments
sorted by: hot top new old
[-] Objection@lemmy.ml 70 points 5 months ago
[-] MoffKalast@lemmy.world 48 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

The most realistic part of this joke is that the bartender is also a mathematician, probably after they did not qualify for any phd research grant.

[-] Eq0@literature.cafe 2 points 5 months ago
[-] Nurgus@lemmy.world 2 points 5 months ago

On behalf of British pub goers, a half is a perfectly normal thing to order. :p

[-] RustyNova@lemmy.world 70 points 5 months ago

I get the physics one but not the math one

[-] PM_ME_VINTAGE_30S@anarchist.nexus 86 points 5 months ago

The math one uses the fact that 1 + 2 + 3 + ... "=" -1/12, where the equality is in the sense of Ramanujan summation. Classically, the series diverges, so using the equality sign is a bit deceptive. However, in some contexts, it is meaningful to assign a sum to divergent series.

[-] HumanOnEarth@lemmy.ca 33 points 5 months ago

Ahhhh Ramanujan summation. The Forsythe plausabilities but with regards to polynumerstatistical deprecations. Hortense Guildmeier is rolling in his grave!

[-] tdawg@lemmy.world 77 points 5 months ago
[-] RebekahWSD@lemmy.world 44 points 5 months ago
[-] KairuByte@lemmy.dbzer0.com 29 points 5 months ago

I am a wordologist, and those are definitely probably words.

[-] LovableSidekick@lemmy.world 3 points 5 months ago

I've heard those words! Er, I mean, I've heard words!

[-] LovableSidekick@lemmy.world 32 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

I believe you, but that made about as much sense to me as when Wesley saves the ship by reversing the polarity of the navigational deflector array.

[-] cAUzapNEAGLb@lemmy.world 23 points 5 months ago
[-] Klear@piefed.world 21 points 5 months ago

Oh, good. There's a Numberphile video on it linked at the end. That gives me much better odds of understanding this than just reading the article.

[-] PM_ME_VINTAGE_30S@anarchist.nexus 28 points 5 months ago

Actually, the Numberphile video is notorious for lacking mathematical rigor. Mathologer did a video on it. IMO, it's really really important to explain the difference between what's going on here (assigning a number to a divergent series) and what we ordinarily do (computing the limit of a sequence of partial sums).

[-] i_love_FFT@jlai.lu 6 points 5 months ago

There was a full on mathematical war on YouTube, with numberphile coming back later to show that most partial sum methods also end up at -1/12.

As a science nerd, mathologer basically just took the camp of "old concensus" and gave no other argument than "this is alien math, nope, I don't like it". It just felt like mathologer was Pythagoras fighting against irrational numbers...

[-] PM_ME_VINTAGE_30S@anarchist.nexus 1 points 5 months ago

As a science nerd, mathologer basically just took the camp of "old concensus" and gave no other argument than "this is alien math, nope, I don't like it".

I mean maybe in the first video, but not the one I linked. Here, he was very precise about the mistakes Numberphile made in the presentation, and the purpose and utility of standard summation of convergent series versus the other methods of summation. Like he's not dissing the idea or utility of summing divergent series literally at all, just Numberphile's oversimplified presentation of it.

[-] i_love_FFT@jlai.lu 2 points 5 months ago

Yeah that's fair! I didn't get through some of his videos, being more of a downer "grumpy style" 😉

I'll try to watch that again

[-] NeatNit@discuss.tchncs.de 5 points 5 months ago

There have been some claims that the numberphile video is very misrepresentative of the underlying math. But I never dug deep enough into it.

[-] khannie@lemmy.world 8 points 5 months ago

Feels like a risky click. I'm not sure my worldview can take any more shattering. It's already shattered I tell you. SHATTERED.

[-] rumba@lemmy.zip 39 points 5 months ago

And that -1/12 bs is why I cannot math.

1+2+3 ... tends toward infinity and there's no amount of playing with numbers will convince me otherwise.

[-] bort@sopuli.xyz 32 points 5 months ago

And that -1/12 bs is why I cannot math.

it's not actually math. It's people coming up with alternative definitions and then feeling smug when their alternative definitions give weird results.

[-] PM_ME_VINTAGE_30S@anarchist.nexus 25 points 5 months ago

it's not actually math.

It literally is math tho

It's people coming up with alternative definitions and then feeling smug when their alternative definitions give weird results.

Yeah because these weird definitions might be useful in some other context.

[-] baltakatei@sopuli.xyz 12 points 5 months ago

Like robbing a bartender. Or your 401(k).

[-] psud@aussie.zone 7 points 5 months ago

None of those contexts include ordering a number of beers

[-] PM_ME_VINTAGE_30S@anarchist.nexus 9 points 5 months ago

But that's literally the joke in the meme tho

[-] tdawg@lemmy.world 5 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

Ostensibly it's used a lot in quantum physics

[-] marcos@lemmy.world 5 points 5 months ago

That's all that math is about.

[-] Asetru@feddit.org 5 points 5 months ago

It's really not.

Also, here's a video on why that -1/12 stuff is pretty much nonsense:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YuIIjLr6vUA

[-] TwilightKiddy@programming.dev 8 points 5 months ago

Hello, I play with numbers:

1+2+3+...=S
S-S=1+2+3+4+...
     -1-2-3-...=
1+1+1+1+...=S-S=0

Moral of the story: ones together are nothing.

Thank you for your attention.

[-] rumba@lemmy.zip 4 points 5 months ago

let me hand you a tissue, looks like you got some 'stuff' in your text box

[-] TwilightKiddy@programming.dev 4 points 5 months ago

Much appreciated. 🤧

[-] jaybone@lemmy.zip 0 points 5 months ago

lol 1-1, 2-2 etc.

How do you get 1 + 2-1?

You need to distribute that minus sign to all numbers in the sequence. You can’t leave off the first one.

[-] prime_number_314159@lemmy.world 3 points 5 months ago

He has a plus one, and a minus one, a plus two, and a minus two, and so on. This is analogous to how conditionally convergent series can be modified to give any finite (or infinite) sum merely by changing the order of the terms.

[-] TwilightKiddy@programming.dev 3 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

It's an infinite series, love, I just moved it, there are still enough elements in them because, well, they are infinite. If you are so sad about it, write the second one as 0-S, changes nothing but now you have a donut to pair up with the 1 in the first series.

[-] bmpvy@piefed.social 17 points 5 months ago

Me, having dyscalculia: ok

[-] crwth@piefed.zip 10 points 5 months ago

I had a student tasked with summing a finite geometric sequence with |r|>1, let's say 1+2+4+8+16. He had apparently forgotten the formula for that, but knew the formula for the infinite series a/(1-r). Good enough he thinks, and sums 1+2+4+... = -1, then subtracts off the excess terms 32+64+128+... = -32, and gets the correct answer of 31.

[-] PM_ME_VINTAGE_30S@anarchist.nexus 9 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

You gotta make sure those tricky infinite mathematicians order an absolutely convergent series of beers before you sell them 🍺

[-] lime@feddit.nu 8 points 5 months ago

...but only three of them ordered beers

[-] Nima@leminal.space 6 points 5 months ago

i thought the first one ended with "after 4 orders the bartender says 'you guys suck' and pours two beers."

[-] SwingingTheLamp@piefed.zip 3 points 5 months ago

This bar's pricing makes no sense whatsoever. One beer is $1. One and 3/4 beers is also $1. Maybe they round down? Then, everybody should order 0.9999... beer, except that for some reason seventy-two beers is -$1? Weird.

[-] sepiroth154@feddit.nl 7 points 5 months ago

They mean that the sequences go on forever, but the joke definitely doesn't make that clear.

[-] SwingingTheLamp@piefed.zip 2 points 5 months ago

Too subtle a joke, I guess. The description is just missing "and so on." But the "and so on" is the crux of the bullshit in the mathematical "proof" referenced.

this post was submitted on 01 Jun 2026
241 points (96.2% liked)

Science Memes

21155 readers
1 users here now

Welcome to c/science_memes @ Mander.xyz!

A place for majestic STEMLORD peacocking, as well as memes about the realities of working in a lab.



Rules

  1. Don't throw mud. Behave like an intellectual and remember the human.
  2. Keep it rooted (on topic).
  3. No spam.
  4. Infographics welcome, get schooled.


Research Committee

Other Mander Communities

Science and Research

Biology and Life Sciences

Physical Sciences

Humanities and Social Sciences

Practical and Applied Sciences

Memes

Miscellaneous

founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS